Skip to content
Heavy Metal Index
Small green water lentil fronds floating in a glass dish of water illustrating water lentils ingredient context.

Heavy metals in Water lentils

Quick read

Controlled water lentils in the available batch stay below detection for lead, arsenic, and cadmium, while wild plants from polluted lakes reached 51,000 ppb arsenic.

  • Metals of concern: Lead, arsenic, and cadmium in controlled plants; arsenic is far higher in wild plants from polluted lakes.
  • Main drivers: Cultivation water quality, and whether the plants are grown for food or gathered from lakes.
  • Practical framing: The food-grade result is one batch, and several metals are still unmeasured.

This page draws on evidence from EFSA, together with 4 other cited sources. The complete citation list is at the bottom of the page.

Why water lentils accumulate heavy metals

Water lentils are rootless floating aquatic plants that absorb mineral nutrients and contaminants directly from the surrounding water column through their entire surface area. This direct dissolved-phase uptake makes contamination levels a near-linear function of cultivation water quality: a plant grown in clean water with controlled nutrient inputs shows trace metals at or below detection limits, while the same species harvested from an anthropogenically contaminated lake can reach arsenic concentrations exceeding 50,000 ppb dry weight 5.

The cultivation medium dominates contamination outcomes in a way that is unusual among food ingredients. For most leafy vegetables, soil composition matters but root-barrier and foliar dilution effects moderate uptake. For water lentils, there is no root barrier: dissolved metals in the growth medium translocate directly into plant tissue. This makes water quality and fertilizer composition the primary control points for heavy metal management, more critical than harvest processing or washing 1.

Manganese accumulation illustrates a secondary driver. Wolffia globosa accumulates manganese at 203-302 mg/kg on a freeze-dried weight basis under controlled cultivation conditions 4, reflecting the high manganese uptake capacity of Lemnoideae even in clean water. At approximately 3% dry matter (97% moisture as measured in Thai W. globosa 2), this converts to roughly 6-9 mg/kg fresh weight, which is at or above EFSA’s 6 mg/kg fresh weight specification for manganese in Wolffia intended for human consumption 3. Manganese is not among the HMT&C monitored analytes; this finding is documented here as a nutritional safety consideration specific to Lemnoideae.

Heavy metal contamination profile

The contamination profile table is generated from frontmatter. The n = 1 food-grade batch value (Tongyai 2026 2) reflects a single Thai controlled-cultivation batch analyzed in triplicate. The EFSA 2022 opinion 1 reports 10 Lemna minor and Lemna gibba batches with arsenic, cadmium, and mercury below LOQ and lead detected in 3 of 10 batches at 10-30 ppb fresh weight; those values are expressed on a fresh weight basis and are not pooled with the Tongyai dry weight values in the typical_ppb fields above.

AnalyteCoverageTypical (ppb)ConfidenceKey sources
Lead (Pb)n=10–40low—
Cadmium (Cd)n=10–10low—
Inorganic arsenic (iAs)data gap———
Total arsenic (tAs)n=10–50low—
Total mercury (tHg)data gap———
Nickel (Ni)data gap———
Aluminum (Al)data gap———
Chromium (Cr)————
Tin (Sn)data gap———
Uranium (U)————

Ranges by source, region, and variety

Under controlled food-grade cultivation, arsenic, cadmium, and lead consistently fall below detection limits across the measurement studies in this unit: a Thai Wolffia globosa batch 2 and ten commercial Lemna minor and Lemna gibba batches evaluated by EFSA 1. The EFSA Lemna data detected lead in 3 of 10 batches at 10-30 ppb fresh weight, with the other 7 batches below the LOQ of 10 ppb FW; this trace lead signal was not flagged as a safety concern by the EFSA Panel.

The critical geographic driver is water quality. Wild-harvested Lemna minor from four Kashmir lakes showed arsenic 23,950-51,470 ppb dry weight and mercury 790-1,340 ppb dry weight 5. These lakes receive agricultural runoff, urban wastewater, and industrial discharge. The 1,000-fold gap between food-grade (below 50 ppb DW) and wild-harvest (up to 51,000 ppb DW) arsenic concentrations is the clearest illustration that water lentil contamination is overwhelmingly determined by cultivation-water quality rather than intrinsic plant biology.

The review by Hernani-Rodrigo et al. 4 compiles an arsenic range of 0.3-2.52 mg/kg from multiple controlled-cultivation primary studies. The upper end of this range (2,520 ppb) is substantially above the below-MDL values in Tongyai 2 and the below-LOQ values in the EFSA batches 1, consistent with the dependence of accumulation on the specific cultivation system, fertilizer source, and water treatment applied. No data in this unit allow geographic or variety-level stratification within the food-grade range.

Wolffia species (W. globosa, W. arrhiza) and Lemna minor are related but distinct. The EFSA 2022 data are for Lemna spp.; the Tongyai food-grade batch is W. globosa. Where mineral profiles differ between species, the available data do not permit quantitative cross-species inference with the sources in this unit.

Processing effects

No processing-effect data for heavy metals in water lentils appear in the sources in this unit. The EFSA 2022 opinion 1 assessed heat-treated whole plant material, and no comparison between unprocessed and heat-treated batches for heavy metal content was reported. The Tongyai 2026 study 2 used freeze-dried powder; no fresh-weight or wet-processed comparison data were included.

Protein concentrate production from Lemnoideae, mentioned in the safety review 3 as a form that raises manganese concerns, may alter heavy metal distributions relative to whole-plant material, but no concentration data for protein concentrates appear in the sources in this unit.

Ingredient-derivative risk

Water lentil protein powder and protein concentrate are the most commercially relevant derivatives. The EFSA NDA Panel expressed its primary safety concern about manganese, not lead, arsenic, or cadmium, when assessing Wolffia-based protein concentrates 3. Concentration processing that retains manganese while removing moisture and fiber could elevate the effective manganese exposure relative to whole fresh plant consumption. No heavy metal data for water lentil protein concentrates or isolates appear in the sources in this unit.

Mitigation options

Sourcing. Cultivation water quality is the primary lever. The gap between below-MDL food-grade concentrations and the tens of thousands of ppb dry weight seen in wild-harvest from polluted lakes 5 establishes that certified water sources and closed or semi-closed cultivation systems substantially eliminate contamination risk. The EFSA 2022 opinion 1 notes that trace element concentrations are highly dependent on cultivation conditions and fertilizer composition.

Agronomic. Fertilizer selection controls the trace element load introduced to the cultivation medium. Synthetic or verified-low-metal fertilizers applied at defined rates reduce the risk of unintended metal introduction that would then be taken up by the plants.

Testing and QC. Given the cultivation-condition dependence, lot-level metal monitoring is essential 1. The EFSA Panel recommended monitoring as a standard requirement for commercial production. Single-site, single-batch qualification data (as in Tongyai 2026 2) are not sufficient to characterize a supply chain; ongoing lot-level testing for lead, total arsenic, cadmium, and total mercury is the minimum QC posture consistent with the evidence.

Regulatory limits that apply

EFSA proposed the following maximum levels for fresh Wolffia intended for human consumption, as summarized by Ziąć et al. 3 (Table 3, basis assumed fresh weight):

  • Lead: <0.3 mg/kg FW (300 ppb FW)
  • Inorganic arsenic: <0.10 mg/kg FW (100 ppb FW)
  • Cadmium: <0.2 mg/kg FW (200 ppb FW)
  • Total chromium: <1 mg/kg FW (1,000 ppb FW)
  • Mercury: <0.10 mg/kg FW (100 ppb FW)
  • Manganese: <6 mg/kg FW (6,000 ppb FW)

These specifications were proposed in the context of EFSA’s novel food safety assessment. EFSA’s overall conclusion, that typical consumption (100-300 g FW/day) raises no safety concerns, was qualified by the need for lot-level monitoring 1.

No EU, Codex, or FDA maximum levels specific to water lentils or Lemnoideae for the HMT&C monitored analytes (lead, total arsenic, cadmium, total mercury) have been identified in the sources in this unit beyond the EFSA specifications above.

What remains uncertain

The food-grade heavy metal evidence base for water lentils is thin. The only direct ICP-MS food-grade measurements in this unit come from a single Thai controlled-cultivation batch of Wolffia globosa (Tongyai 2026 2) and ten commercial Lemna batches in the EFSA dossier 1. All values are censored (below MDL or LOQ), which provides an upper-bound assurance but no measured central value. Confidence in the contamination profile is low.

The following questions remain open with the evidence in this unit:

  • Inorganic arsenic fraction and methylmercury have not been measured in any food-grade water lentil source. Total arsenic values cannot be parsed without speciation data, and the EFSA-proposed inorganic arsenic limit of 0.10 mg/kg FW cannot be evaluated from the available data.
  • Mercury speciation (methylmercury vs. inorganic) is unknown. Wild-lake data show total mercury up to 1,340 ppb DW 5; the food-grade fraction is below LOQ 1, but no speciation exists in either dataset.
  • Nickel, aluminum, hexavalent chromium, and tin have not been reported for food-grade water lentils in any source in this unit.
  • The arsenic range of 0.3-2.52 mg/kg compiled in Hernani-Rodrigo et al. 4 from mixed controlled-cultivation sources points to substantial variability across cultivation systems; the basis and species breakdowns of that compiled range are not resolved in this unit.
  • The manganese finding (W. globosa up to 302 mg/kg FDW in controlled cultivation 4, converting to approximately 9 mg/kg FW at 3% dry matter) exceeds EFSA’s 6 mg/kg FW specification 3. Whether this reflects the range of cultivation conditions broadly or just specific high-manganese water sources is not resolved.
  • Cross-species extrapolation between Wolffia spp. and Lemna minor has not been validated for heavy metal profiles. The commercial food-grade market involves both genera; the available data do not support species-level differentiation.

References

  1. EFSA NDA Panel, Turck D, Bohn T, et al. Safety of Lemna minor and Lemna gibba whole plant material as a novel food pursuant to Regulation (EU) 2015/2283. EFSA Journal. 2022. DOI: 10.2903/j.efsa.2022.7598
  2. Tongyai S, Petchoo J, Phumalee T, et al. Integrated Characterization of Wolffia globosa as a Potential Food Ingredient: Nutritional and Physicochemical Properties, Selected Elements, and Preliminary In Vitro Responses. Foods. 2026. DOI: 10.3390/foods15162919
  3. Ziąć M, Kowalczewski PŁ, Bzducha-Wróbel A, et al. Nutritional Value, Health Properties, Safety Considerations, and Consumer Acceptance of Lemnoideae as Human Food. Nutrients. 2025. DOI: 10.3390/nu17183026
  4. Hernani-Rodrigo I, Di Renzo A, Bhatt PM, et al. Duckweed (Wolffia globosa, Wolffia arrhiza, and Lemna minor) as novel therapeutic food for acute malnutrition and famine alleviation in low- and middle-income countries and humanitarian crisis settings. Frontiers in Nutrition. 2026. DOI: 10.3389/fnut.2026.1835959
  5. Islam MN, Mustafa B, Khan MA, et al. Evaluation of mineral composition and in-vitro nutrient digestibility of macrophytes to assess their potential as sustainable animal feed. Scientific Reports. 2026. DOI: 10.1038/s41598-026-37642-4

Sources

Source records associated with this topic. Inclusion does not establish that every finding applies to this product or ingredient. References above identify works cited in the text.

#CitationYearTypeUsed on this page for
1Hernani-Rodrigo et al. 2026. Duckweed (Wolffia globosa, Wolffia arrhiza, and Lemna minor) as novel therapeutic food for acute malnutrition and famine alleviation in low- and middle-income countries and humanitarian crisis settings, Frontiers in Nutrition2026ReviewContribution to this topic remains under review; see the source record for its reported scope.
2Islam et al. 2026. Evaluation of mineral composition and in-vitro nutrient digestibility of macrophytes to assess their potential as sustainable animal feed, Scientific Reports2026Primary researchContribution to this topic remains under review; see the source record for its reported scope.
3Tongyai et al. 2026. Integrated Characterization of Wolffia globosa as a Potential Food Ingredient: Nutritional and Physicochemical Properties, Selected Elements, and Preliminary In Vitro Responses, Foods2026Primary researchContribution to this topic remains under review; see the source record for its reported scope.
4Sirison et al. 2025. Cultivation of Wolffia globosa and its application in functional food development, Scientific Reports (2025) 15:382552025Peer-reviewedContribution to this topic remains under review; see the source record for its reported scope.
5Ziąć et al. 2025. Nutritional Value, Health Properties, Safety Considerations, and Consumer Acceptance of Lemnoideae as Human Food, Nutrients2025ReviewContribution to this topic remains under review; see the source record for its reported scope.
6EFSA 2021. Technical Report on the notification of fresh plants of Wolffia arrhiza and Wolffia globosa as a traditional food from a third country pursuant to Article 14 of Regulation (EU) 2015/2283, EFSA Supporting publication 2021:EN-6658, 15 pp.2021ReportContribution to this topic remains under review; see the source record for its reported scope.
7EFSA 2021. Safety of water lentil powder from Lemnaceae as a Novel Food pursuant to Regulation (EU) 2015/2283, EFSA Journal 2021;19(11):68452021ReportContribution to this topic remains under review; see the source record for its reported scope.
8EFSA 2021. Safety of Wolffia globosa powder as a Novel food pursuant to Regulation (EU) 2015/2283, EFSA Journal 2021;19(12):6938, 25 pp.2021ReportContribution to this topic remains under review; see the source record for its reported scope.

Update history

CommitDateChangeDescription

Update history

No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.