Skip to content
Heavy Metal Index
Black and pale peppercorns, turmeric powder and cinnamon sticks illustrating black pepper ingredient context.

Heavy metals in Black Pepper

Lead, cadmium, arsenic and other metals in black pepper: monitoring results, market surveys, whole and ground forms, origins, packaging, limits, testing and controls.

Quick read

Most monitored black pepper is low in lead, cadmium and arsenic, but lead is the metal to check: the EU limit is 600 µg/kg, and several market surveys report means near or above it.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →2European Commission · 2023Commission Regulation (EU) 2023/915 of 25 April 2023 on maximum levels for certain contaminants in food and repealing Regulation (EC) No 1881/2006Official Journal of the European UnionRead source →3Osei-Safo I, Miezah K, Sackey LNA, Adusei-Gyamf J, Abdul AM · 2024Trace and Heavy Metals in Locally and Imported Spices Sold on Markets in Accra Metropolis, GhanaThe Scientific World JournalRead source →4Ziyaina M, Rajab A, Alkhweldi K, Algami W, Al-Toumi O, Rasco B · 2014Lead and cadmium residue determination in spices available in Tripoli City markets (Libya)African Journal of Biochemistry ResearchRead source →

Black pepper overview

Black pepper usually carries lead, cadmium and arsenic in the tens to low hundreds of µg/kg, with aluminum, nickel and chromium far higher.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →6Cicero N, Gervasi T, Durazzo A, Lucarini M, Macrì A, Nava V, Giarratana F, Tardugno R, Vadalà R, Santini A · 2022Mineral and Microbiological Analysis of Spices and Aromatic HerbsFoodsRead source → In WHO GEMS/Food, 362 black pepper lead results had a median of about 53-60 µg/kg, and 9 (2.5%) were definitely above 600 µg/kg.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source → Total arsenic was below detection in most of 197 results, and cadmium had a median below 7 µg/kg.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →

Lead is the metal most likely to decide a black pepper question, because a minority of lots are far higher than the rest. The EU sets a binding maximum of 0.60 mg/kg (600 µg/kg) for lead in dried fruit spices, the class that covers peppercorns as dried fruits, and Codex adopted the same 0.6 mg/kg for dried fruit and berry spices; neither sets a cadmium limit for pepper.2European Commission · 2023Commission Regulation (EU) 2023/915 of 25 April 2023 on maximum levels for certain contaminants in food and repealing Regulation (EC) No 1881/2006Official Journal of the European UnionRead source →7Codex Alimentarius Commission · 1995General Standard for Contaminants and Toxins in Food and Feed (CXS 193-1995)Codex Alimentarius (Joint FAO/WHO Food Standards Programme)Read source → Market surveys outside routine monitoring report much higher lead: means of 714 µg/kg in Malaysian-grown pepper bought in Accra, 730-820 µg/kg in Libya and 2,470 µg/kg in bulk pepper from eastern turkey.3Osei-Safo I, Miezah K, Sackey LNA, Adusei-Gyamf J, Abdul AM · 2024Trace and Heavy Metals in Locally and Imported Spices Sold on Markets in Accra Metropolis, GhanaThe Scientific World JournalRead source →4Ziyaina M, Rajab A, Alkhweldi K, Algami W, Al-Toumi O, Rasco B · 2014Lead and cadmium residue determination in spices available in Tripoli City markets (Libya)African Journal of Biochemistry ResearchRead source →8Mercan Yucel U · 2022Determination of Aflatoxin and Heavy Metal Levels in Some Spices Sold as Unpackaged in Van Province and Health Risks Assessment of Heavy MetalsBalikesir Health Sciences JournalRead source →

For a buyer, the supported priorities are a lot-specific lead result with a quantification limit well below the applicable limit, a cadmium result for markets that set one, and a supply chain that keeps grinding and handling under control.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →2European Commission · 2023Commission Regulation (EU) 2023/915 of 25 April 2023 on maximum levels for certain contaminants in food and repealing Regulation (EC) No 1881/2006Official Journal of the European UnionRead source → Whole pepper had a lower lead median than ground pepper in monitoring data, but growing origin alone did not settle the question: Malaysian-grown pepper measured 100 µg/kg in Queensland and 714 µg/kg in Accra.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →3Osei-Safo I, Miezah K, Sackey LNA, Adusei-Gyamf J, Abdul AM · 2024Trace and Heavy Metals in Locally and Imported Spices Sold on Markets in Accra Metropolis, GhanaThe Scientific World JournalRead source →5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →

What counts as black pepper

This page covers black pepper, the dried fruit of Piper nigrum, sold whole, cracked or ground, measured as the dry spice without moisture conversion.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →6Cicero N, Gervasi T, Durazzo A, Lucarini M, Macrì A, Nava V, Giarratana F, Tardugno R, Vadalà R, Santini A · 2022Mineral and Microbiological Analysis of Spices and Aromatic HerbsFoodsRead source → White pepper, green and long pepper, chilli and bell peppers, spice blends and foods seasoned with pepper are outside its scope.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →9Matloob MH · 2016Using Stripping Voltammetry to Determine Heavy Metals in Cooking Spices Used in IraqPolish Journal of Environmental StudiesRead source →10Moussa L, Hassan HF, Savvaidis IN, Karam L · 2024Impact of source, packaging and presence of food safety management system on heavy metals levels in spices and herbsPLoS ONERead source →

Pepper identity matters because monitoring categories and surveys use different labels. The EU monitoring category “Pepper, black and white (Piper nigrum)” does not separate black from white pepper, so its 1,051 GEMS/Food results are shown separately and not compared with the black pepper reference.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source → A WHO region in GEMS/Food is a reporting region, and most surveys report where the pepper was bought rather than where it was grown.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →3Osei-Safo I, Miezah K, Sackey LNA, Adusei-Gyamf J, Abdul AM · 2024Trace and Heavy Metals in Locally and Imported Spices Sold on Markets in Accra Metropolis, GhanaThe Scientific World JournalRead source →5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →

Heavy metal contamination profile of black pepper

The table holds every black pepper result extracted from sixteen survey and monitoring sources: one row for each statistic a source reports for a subgroup and metal, so a mean and a range from the same samples appear as separate rows.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →4Ziyaina M, Rajab A, Alkhweldi K, Algami W, Al-Toumi O, Rasco B · 2014Lead and cadmium residue determination in spices available in Tripoli City markets (Libya)African Journal of Biochemistry ResearchRead source →5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →11Kowalska G · 2021The Safety Assessment of Toxic Metals in Commonly Used Herbs, Spices, Tea, and Coffee in PolandInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public HealthRead source →10Moussa L, Hassan HF, Savvaidis IN, Karam L · 2024Impact of source, packaging and presence of food safety management system on heavy metals levels in spices and herbsPLoS ONERead source → Ratings place a mean, median or single result against a pooled HMI black pepper reference built from six lead sampling families and six cadmium families; non-detects remain intervals and are never read as zero.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →6Cicero N, Gervasi T, Durazzo A, Lucarini M, Macrì A, Nava V, Giarratana F, Tardugno R, Vadalà R, Santini A · 2022Mineral and Microbiological Analysis of Spices and Aromatic HerbsFoodsRead source →10Moussa L, Hassan HF, Savvaidis IN, Karam L · 2024Impact of source, packaging and presence of food safety management system on heavy metals levels in spices and herbsPLoS ONERead source →12Cantoral A, Betanzos-Robledo L, Collado-López S, García-Martínez BA, Lamadrid-Figueroa H, Mariscal-Moreno RM, Díaz-Ruiz A, Ríos C, Téllez-Rojo MM · 2024Lead Levels in the Most Consumed Mexican Foods: First Monitoring EffortToxicsRead source →13Ammar HR, Saleh SM, Sivasankaran S, Albadri AEAE, Al-Mufadi FA · 2023Investigation of Element Migration from Aluminum Cooking Pots Using ICP-MSApplied Sciences (MDPI)Read source → Rows that failed a check against their own paper stay visible with the reason and are not compared.11Kowalska G · 2021The Safety Assessment of Toxic Metals in Commonly Used Herbs, Spices, Tea, and Coffee in PolandInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public HealthRead source →9Matloob MH · 2016Using Stripping Voltammetry to Determine Heavy Metals in Cooking Spices Used in IraqPolish Journal of Environmental StudiesRead source →14Sabri S, Sabri C, Salam MR, El Mellouli F, Lafram A, Khallouki H, Hassane YA, Kabine M · 2025Essential and Toxic Element Profiles in Selected Spices from Greater Casablanca, MoroccoWorld’s Veterinary Journal 15(4): 863-881Read source →15Savić S, Petrović S, Petronijević M, Cvetanović A, Petronijević Ž · 2019Determination of the mineral content of spices by ICP-OESAdvanced TechnologiesRead source →

Typical pepper results differ greatly by metal. In Queensland retail pepper, means were 130 µg/kg lead, 26 µg/kg cadmium, 180 µg/kg total arsenic, 560 µg/kg chromium, 2,080 µg/kg nickel and 144,000 µg/kg aluminum.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source → Mercury was mostly below detection: all 26 Polish samples were below 5 µg/kg, and 14 of 17 Western Pacific GEMS/Food results were non-detects.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →11Kowalska G · 2021The Safety Assessment of Toxic Metals in Commonly Used Herbs, Spices, Tea, and Coffee in PolandInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public HealthRead source →

Comparison methods and scope

Each row is one statistic a source reports for one subgroup and metal; a mean and a range from the same samples are separate rows. Ratings place a reported mean, median or sample result against a pooled HMI black pepper reference built from every compatible sampling family. Same-study contrasts compare packaged with bulk pepper, retail with wholesale, or an origin with the study total. Held rows failed a check against their own paper and are shown but not compared.

About this table
Food formCollection scopeFindingComparisonEvidence
Black pepper findings from every extracted survey and monitoring dataset, in µg/kg with each source’s statistic, form, packaging, censoring and sampling frame retained.
Food formCollection scopeFinding (µg/kg)ComparisonEvidence
23 findings · 11 studies · 3 spread figures folded in
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EMRO2014-2022median.
Black pepper, packagedWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2014-2023median.
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2014-2023median.
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2021-2022median.
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2015-2022median.
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region SEARO2018median.
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2016-2021median.
Black and white pepper (not separated)WHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2003-2018median.
Black and white pepper (not separated)WHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2003-2017median.
Black pepperAmmar et al. 2023Black pepperCollection date unreportedmean.
Black pepper, bulk or looseCantoral et al. 2024Black Pepper "Piper nigrum L."2022-2023sample value.
Black pepperEricson et al. 2020Homes2019median.Same samples: minimum <4,140 µg/kg; 48,400 µg/kg (maximum)
Black pepperIslam et al. 2023S-19 Gool Morich / Black PepperCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepperKowalska 2021Black pepper2015-2018mean.Same samples: up to 740 µg/kg (range maximum)
Black pepper, bulk or looseMercan 2022Black pepper, n = 202018mean.
Black pepper, bulk or looseMoussa et al. 2024Bulk (sold unpackaged)2020mean.
Black pepper, packagedMoussa et al. 2024Imported (packaged in France)2020mean.
Black pepper, packagedMoussa et al. 2024Local brands with FSMS2020mean.
Black pepper, packagedMoussa et al. 2024Local brands without FSMS2020mean.
Black pepper, bulk or looseSabri et al. 2025Black pepper2025mean.
Black pepper, bulk or looseSabri et al. 2025Black pepper2025range.
Black pepperSavić et al. 2019Black pepperCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepperWiniarska-Mieczan et al. 2023Black pepperCollection date unreportedmean.
15 findings · 3 studies · 6 spread figures folded in
Black pepper, ground, bulk or looseWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2023median.
Black pepper, ground, packagedWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2014-2023median.
Black pepper, groundWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2014-2023median.
Black pepper, groundWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region PAHO2014-2017median.
Black pepper, groundWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region SEARO2016-2018median.
Black pepper, groundWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2008median.
Black pepper, groundWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2024median.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Black pepper (n = 13)Collection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 16-370 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in ChinaCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 83-140 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in IndiaCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 30-370 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in MalaysiaCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in Sri LankaCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in VietnamCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 16-100 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundZiyaina et al. 2014Piper nigrum, Retailer (n = 36)2011mean.Same samples: 690-900 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundZiyaina et al. 2014Piper nigrum, Wholesale (n = 24)2011mean.Same samples: 660-800 µg/kg (range)
9 findings · 4 studies
Black pepper, wholeWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2015-2022median.
Black pepper, wholeWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2015median.
Black pepper, wholeWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region PAHO2014-2017median.
Black pepper, wholeWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region SEARO2015-2018median.
Black pepper, wholeWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2012median.
Black pepper, wholeWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2024median.
Black pepper, wholeCicero et al. 2022Grown in VietnamCollection date unreportedmean.
Black pepper, wholeMatloob 2016Black pepper (fruit), n = 5Collection date unreportedmean.
Black pepper, wholeOsei-Safo et al. 2024Grown in MalaysiaCollection date unreportedmean.
17 findings · 9 studies · 2 spread figures folded in
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EMRO2015-2019median.
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2003-2006median.
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2003-2008median.
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2021median.
Black and white pepper (not separated)WHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2003-2018median.
Black and white pepper (not separated)WHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2003-2017median.
Black pepperAmmar et al. 2023Black pepperCollection date unreportedmean.
Black pepperIslam et al. 2023S-19 Gool Morich / Black PepperCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepperKowalska 2021Black pepper2015-2018mean.Same samples: up to 80 µg/kg (range maximum)
Black pepper, bulk or looseMercan 2022Black pepper, n = 202018mean.
Black pepper, bulk or looseMoussa et al. 2024Bulk (sold unpackaged)2020mean.
Black pepper, packagedMoussa et al. 2024Imported (packaged in France)2020mean.
Black pepper, packagedMoussa et al. 2024Local brands with FSMS2020mean.
Black pepper, packagedMoussa et al. 2024Local brands without FSMS2020mean.
Black pepper, bulk or looseSabri et al. 2025Black pepper2025mean.Same samples: 6-49 µg/kg (range)
Black pepperSavić et al. 2019Black pepperCollection date unreportednot detected.
Black pepperWiniarska-Mieczan et al. 2023Black pepperCollection date unreportedmean.
12 findings · 3 studies · 6 spread figures folded in
Black pepper, groundWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2004median.
Black pepper, groundWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2003median.
Black pepper, groundWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region PAHO2017median.
Black pepper, groundWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2024median.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Black pepper (n = 13)Collection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 8-67 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in ChinaCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 8-33 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in IndiaCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 12-54 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in MalaysiaCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in Sri LankaCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in VietnamCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 9-9 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundZiyaina et al. 2014Piper nigrum, Retailer (n = 36)2011mean.Same samples: 250-390 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundZiyaina et al. 2014Piper nigrum, Wholesale (n = 24)2011mean.Same samples: 110-190 µg/kg (range)
6 findings · 4 studies
Black pepper, wholeWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2004median.
Black pepper, wholeWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region PAHO2017median.
Black pepper, wholeWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2024median.
Black pepper, wholeCicero et al. 2022Grown in VietnamCollection date unreportedmean.
Black pepper, wholeMatloob 2016Black pepper (fruit), n = 5Collection date unreportedmean.
Black pepper, wholeOsei-Safo et al. 2024Grown in MalaysiaCollection date unreportedmean.
10 findings · 2 studies · 4 spread figures folded in
Black pepper, ground, bulk or looseWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2023median.
Black pepper, ground, packagedWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2017-2023median.
Black pepper, groundWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2017-2023median.
Black pepper, groundWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2024median.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Black pepper (n = 13)Collection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 7-1,700 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in ChinaCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 22-1,700 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in IndiaCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 7-81 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in MalaysiaCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in Sri LankaCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in VietnamCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 15-17 µg/kg (range)
16 findings · 6 studies · 1 spread figure folded in
Black pepper, packagedWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2017-2023median.
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2016-2023median.
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2016median.
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2021median.
Black and white pepper (not separated)WHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2007-2015median.
Black and white pepper (not separated)WHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2010-2011median.
Black pepperAmmar et al. 2023Black pepperCollection date unreportedmean.
Black pepperKowalska 2021Black pepper samples with2015-2018range.
Black pepperKowalska 2021Black pepper2015-2018mean.Same samples: up to 863 µg/kg (range maximum)
Black pepper, bulk or looseMercan 2022Black pepper, n = 202018not detected.
Black pepper, bulk or looseMoussa et al. 2024Bulk (sold unpackaged)2020mean.
Black pepper, packagedMoussa et al. 2024Imported (packaged in France)2020mean.
Black pepper, packagedMoussa et al. 2024Local brands with FSMS2020mean.
Black pepper, packagedMoussa et al. 2024Local brands without FSMS2020mean.
Black pepper, bulk or looseSabri et al. 2025Black pepper2025mean.
Black pepper, bulk or looseSabri et al. 2025Black pepper2025range.
4 findings · 3 studies
Black pepper, wholeWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2018-2022median.
Black pepper, wholeWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2024median.
Black pepper, wholeCicero et al. 2022Grown in VietnamCollection date unreportedmean.
Black pepper, wholeOsei-Safo et al. 2024Grown in MalaysiaCollection date unreportedmean.
1 finding · 1 study
Black pepper, ground, packagedWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2017-2023median.
4 findings · 1 study
Black pepper, packagedWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2017median.
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2017median.
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2016median.
Black and white pepper (not separated)WHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2011median.
1 finding · 1 study
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2016median.
8 findings · 3 studies
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2021median.
Black and white pepper (not separated)WHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2004-2017median.
Black and white pepper (not separated)WHO GEMS/FoodWHO region EURO2011-2017median.
Black pepperKowalska 2021Black pepper2015-2018not detected.
Black pepper, bulk or looseMoussa et al. 2024Bulk (sold unpackaged)2020mean.
Black pepper, packagedMoussa et al. 2024Imported (packaged in France)2020mean.
Black pepper, packagedMoussa et al. 2024Local brands with FSMS2020mean.
Black pepper, packagedMoussa et al. 2024Local brands without FSMS2020mean.
7 findings · 2 studies
Black pepper, groundWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2024median.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Black pepper (n = 13)Collection date unreportedrange.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in ChinaCollection date unreportedbelow LOD.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in IndiaCollection date unreportedrange.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in MalaysiaCollection date unreportedbelow LOD.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in Sri LankaCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in VietnamCollection date unreportedrange.
3 findings · 3 studies
Black pepper, wholeWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2024median.
Black pepper, wholeCicero et al. 2022Grown in VietnamCollection date unreportedmean.
Black pepper, wholeMatloob 2016Black pepper (fruit), n = 5Collection date unreportedmean.
4 findings · 4 studies · 1 spread figure folded in
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2021median.
Black pepperIslam et al. 2023S-19 Gool Morich / Black PepperCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepper, bulk or looseSabri et al. 2025Black pepper2025mean.Same samples: 899-6,580 µg/kg (range)
Black pepperSavić et al. 2019Black pepperCollection date unreportednot detected.
2 findings · 2 studies
Black pepper, wholeCicero et al. 2022Grown in VietnamCollection date unreportedmean.
Black pepper, wholeMatloob 2016Black pepper (fruit), n = 5Collection date unreportedmean.
6 findings · 1 study · 4 spread figures folded in
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Black pepper (n = 13)Collection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 50-2,700 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in ChinaCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 270-1,000 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in IndiaCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 110-2,700 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in MalaysiaCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in Sri LankaCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in VietnamCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 190-280 µg/kg (range)
2 findings · 2 studies
Black pepper, wholeCicero et al. 2022Grown in VietnamCollection date unreportedmean.
Black pepper, wholeMatloob 2016Black pepper (fruit), n = 5Collection date unreportedmean.
4 findings · 3 studies
Black pepper, bulk or looseMercan 2022Black pepper, n = 202018mean.
Black pepper, bulk or looseSabri et al. 2025Black pepper2025mean.
Black pepper, bulk or looseSabri et al. 2025Black pepper2025range.
Black pepperSavić et al. 2019Black pepperCollection date unreportednot detected.
6 findings · 1 study · 4 spread figures folded in
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Black pepper (n = 13)Collection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 850-4,800 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in ChinaCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 1,600-2,700 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in IndiaCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 1,700-4,800 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in MalaysiaCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in Sri LankaCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in VietnamCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 2,400-2,700 µg/kg (range)
7 findings · 2 studies · 4 spread figures folded in
Black pepper, groundWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2024median.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Black pepper (n = 13)Collection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 29,000-540,000 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in ChinaCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 120,000-130,000 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in IndiaCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 29,000-540,000 µg/kg (range)
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in MalaysiaCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in Sri LankaCollection date unreportedsample value.
Black pepper, groundTinggi et al. 2025Grown in VietnamCollection date unreportedmean.Same samples: 59,000-110,000 µg/kg (range)
2 findings · 2 studies
Black pepper, wholeWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2024median.
Black pepper, wholeCicero et al. 2022Grown in VietnamCollection date unreportedmean.
3 findings · 3 studies
Black pepperAmmar et al. 2023Black pepperCollection date unreportedmean.
Black pepper, bulk or looseMercan 2022Black pepper, n = 202018mean.
Black pepperSavić et al. 2019Black pepperCollection date unreportedsample value.
1 finding · 1 study
Black pepperWHO GEMS/FoodWHO region WPRO2021median.
1 finding · 1 study
Black pepper, wholeCicero et al. 2022Grown in VietnamCollection date unreportedmean.
Shared dataset methods and interpretation

Source summaries retain their original statistic, material, basis and censoring. Each source drawer identifies methods and overlapping samples. No matched reference or pooled distribution is inferred.

HMI black pepper Pb reference · 6 sampling families

Reference and scope

HMI black pepper Pb reference · 6 sampling families. Dried black pepper as sold or dry weight, µg/kg; no moisture conversion. Distribution of subgroup median concentration values.

Reference (µg/kg)Q1MedianQ3
Primary HMI reference46.4-53 (bounded)239282
Alternative weighting48-56.5 (bounded)239282

45 reference units; 6 sampling families. Counts describe evidence units, not independent studies or certainty.

Contributing familyReference unitsWeight
WHO GEMS/Food2817%
Ammar et al. 2023117%
Cantoral et al. 2024117%
Cicero et al. 2022117%
Moussa et al. 2024817%
Tinggi et al. 2025617%

Methods

HMI pools subgroup medians from every compatible black pepper sampling family in the evidence ledger: WHO GEMS/Food region-by-year medians (black pepper, random sampling only) and per-sample or per-composite results printed by individual surveys. Each family has equal total weight; subgroups have equal weight within a family. Non-detects stay as zero-to-limit intervals, so quartiles carry lower and upper bounds. Means, ranges and maxima never enter as observations. Black pepper is a dried spice; results reported as sold and on a dry-weight basis are pooled without moisture conversion.

Inverse weighted empirical CDF; midpoint at exact cumulative-weight boundaries. At least four reference units and a definitely positive Q1-Q3 spread are required. This is a display eligibility rule, not statistical validation.

Limitations

An international evidence-library reference, not a probability sample of the world pepper market. GEMS/Food regions are reporting regions, not growing origins. Many submissions are non-detects with differing limits, which widens the bounds. Pooling as-sold and dry-weight results without moisture conversion adds a small, unquantified basis difference. A position is descriptive concentration, not a safety or compliance judgment.

Admitted source families

Reference version and interpretation

Frozen evidence selection: 2026-10-22. Method: hmi-pooled-reference-v2.

hmi-pooled-reference-v2:black-pepper-pooled-Pb:907f943aee69

The reference is computed by HMI from admitted evidence, not copied from a study baseline. It describes the evidence currently in this scope; it is not a worldwide or current-lot benchmark. Source, year and region filters do not change it. Different HMI scopes are not one common ranking.

HMI black pepper Cd reference · 6 sampling families

Reference and scope

HMI black pepper Cd reference · 6 sampling families. Dried black pepper as sold or dry weight, µg/kg; no moisture conversion. Distribution of subgroup median concentration values.

Reference (µg/kg)Q1MedianQ3
Primary HMI reference1.5-7 (bounded)9.5-12.7 (bounded)16.9
Alternative weighting1.5-7 (bounded)10-12.7 (bounded)17

23 reference units; 6 sampling families. Counts describe evidence units, not independent studies or certainty.

Contributing familyReference unitsWeight
WHO GEMS/Food617%
Ammar et al. 2023117%
Cicero et al. 2022117%
Moussa et al. 2024817%
Savić et al. 2019117%
Tinggi et al. 2025617%

Methods

HMI pools subgroup medians from every compatible black pepper sampling family in the evidence ledger: WHO GEMS/Food region-by-year medians (black pepper, random sampling only) and per-sample or per-composite results printed by individual surveys. Each family has equal total weight; subgroups have equal weight within a family. Non-detects stay as zero-to-limit intervals, so quartiles carry lower and upper bounds. Means, ranges and maxima never enter as observations. Black pepper is a dried spice; results reported as sold and on a dry-weight basis are pooled without moisture conversion.

Inverse weighted empirical CDF; midpoint at exact cumulative-weight boundaries. At least four reference units and a definitely positive Q1-Q3 spread are required. This is a display eligibility rule, not statistical validation.

Limitations

An international evidence-library reference, not a probability sample of the world pepper market. GEMS/Food regions are reporting regions, not growing origins. Many submissions are non-detects with differing limits, which widens the bounds. Pooling as-sold and dry-weight results without moisture conversion adds a small, unquantified basis difference. A position is descriptive concentration, not a safety or compliance judgment.

Admitted source families

Reference version and interpretation

Frozen evidence selection: 2026-10-22. Method: hmi-pooled-reference-v2.

hmi-pooled-reference-v2:black-pepper-pooled-Cd:a9a857b19497

The reference is computed by HMI from admitted evidence, not copied from a study baseline. It describes the evidence currently in this scope; it is not a worldwide or current-lot benchmark. Source, year and region filters do not change it. Different HMI scopes are not one common ranking.

HMI black pepper tAs reference · 5 sampling families

Reference and scope

HMI black pepper tAs reference · 5 sampling families. Dried black pepper as sold or dry weight, µg/kg; no moisture conversion. Distribution of subgroup median concentration values.

Reference (µg/kg)Q1MedianQ3
Primary HMI reference2-15 (bounded)32.8-43.6 (bounded)72-100 (bounded)
Alternative weighting2-15 (bounded)43.672-100 (bounded)

23 reference units; 5 sampling families. Counts describe evidence units, not independent studies or certainty.

Contributing familyReference unitsWeight
WHO GEMS/Food720%
Ammar et al. 2023120%
Cicero et al. 2022120%
Moussa et al. 2024820%
Tinggi et al. 2025620%

Methods

HMI pools subgroup medians from every compatible black pepper sampling family in the evidence ledger: WHO GEMS/Food region-by-year medians (black pepper, random sampling only) and per-sample or per-composite results printed by individual surveys. Each family has equal total weight; subgroups have equal weight within a family. Non-detects stay as zero-to-limit intervals, so quartiles carry lower and upper bounds. Means, ranges and maxima never enter as observations. Black pepper is a dried spice; results reported as sold and on a dry-weight basis are pooled without moisture conversion.

Inverse weighted empirical CDF; midpoint at exact cumulative-weight boundaries. At least four reference units and a definitely positive Q1-Q3 spread are required. This is a display eligibility rule, not statistical validation.

Limitations

An international evidence-library reference, not a probability sample of the world pepper market. GEMS/Food regions are reporting regions, not growing origins. Many submissions are non-detects with differing limits, which widens the bounds. Pooling as-sold and dry-weight results without moisture conversion adds a small, unquantified basis difference. A position is descriptive concentration, not a safety or compliance judgment.

Admitted source families

Reference version and interpretation

Frozen evidence selection: 2026-10-22. Method: hmi-pooled-reference-v2.

hmi-pooled-reference-v2:black-pepper-pooled-tAs:b4208c1126e8

The reference is computed by HMI from admitted evidence, not copied from a study baseline. It describes the evidence currently in this scope; it is not a worldwide or current-lot benchmark. Source, year and region filters do not change it. Different HMI scopes are not one common ranking.

HMI black pepper iAs reference · 1 sampling families

Reference and scope

HMI black pepper iAs reference · 1 sampling families. Dried black pepper as sold or dry weight, µg/kg; no moisture conversion. Distribution of subgroup median concentration values.

Reference (µg/kg)Q1MedianQ3
Primary HMI reference≤10≤13.8≤17.6
Alternative weighting≤10≤13.8≤17.6

2 reference units; 1 sampling family. Counts describe evidence units, not independent studies or certainty.

Contributing familyReference unitsWeight
WHO GEMS/Food2100%

Methods

HMI pools subgroup medians from every compatible black pepper sampling family in the evidence ledger: WHO GEMS/Food region-by-year medians (black pepper, random sampling only) and per-sample or per-composite results printed by individual surveys. Each family has equal total weight; subgroups have equal weight within a family. Non-detects stay as zero-to-limit intervals, so quartiles carry lower and upper bounds. Means, ranges and maxima never enter as observations. Black pepper is a dried spice; results reported as sold and on a dry-weight basis are pooled without moisture conversion.

Inverse weighted empirical CDF; midpoint at exact cumulative-weight boundaries. At least four reference units and a definitely positive Q1-Q3 spread are required. This is a display eligibility rule, not statistical validation.

Limitations

An international evidence-library reference, not a probability sample of the world pepper market. GEMS/Food regions are reporting regions, not growing origins. Many submissions are non-detects with differing limits, which widens the bounds. Pooling as-sold and dry-weight results without moisture conversion adds a small, unquantified basis difference. A position is descriptive concentration, not a safety or compliance judgment.

Admitted source families

Reference version and interpretation

Frozen evidence selection: 2026-10-22. Method: hmi-pooled-reference-v2.

hmi-pooled-reference-v2:black-pepper-pooled-iAs:8543c12fd67b

The reference is computed by HMI from admitted evidence, not copied from a study baseline. It describes the evidence currently in this scope; it is not a worldwide or current-lot benchmark. Source, year and region filters do not change it. Different HMI scopes are not one common ranking.

HMI black pepper tHg reference · 4 sampling families

Reference and scope

HMI black pepper tHg reference · 4 sampling families. Dried black pepper as sold or dry weight, µg/kg; no moisture conversion. Distribution of subgroup median concentration values.

Reference (µg/kg)Q1MedianQ3
Primary HMI reference≤43-8 (bounded)9.5-11.5 (bounded)
Alternative weighting≤43-8 (bounded)9.5-11.5 (bounded)

16 reference units; 4 sampling families. Counts describe evidence units, not independent studies or certainty.

Contributing familyReference unitsWeight
WHO GEMS/Food125%
Cicero et al. 2022125%
Moussa et al. 2024825%
Tinggi et al. 2025625%

Methods

HMI pools subgroup medians from every compatible black pepper sampling family in the evidence ledger: WHO GEMS/Food region-by-year medians (black pepper, random sampling only) and per-sample or per-composite results printed by individual surveys. Each family has equal total weight; subgroups have equal weight within a family. Non-detects stay as zero-to-limit intervals, so quartiles carry lower and upper bounds. Means, ranges and maxima never enter as observations. Black pepper is a dried spice; results reported as sold and on a dry-weight basis are pooled without moisture conversion.

Inverse weighted empirical CDF; midpoint at exact cumulative-weight boundaries. At least four reference units and a definitely positive Q1-Q3 spread are required. This is a display eligibility rule, not statistical validation.

Limitations

An international evidence-library reference, not a probability sample of the world pepper market. GEMS/Food regions are reporting regions, not growing origins. Many submissions are non-detects with differing limits, which widens the bounds. Pooling as-sold and dry-weight results without moisture conversion adds a small, unquantified basis difference. A position is descriptive concentration, not a safety or compliance judgment.

Admitted source families

Reference version and interpretation

Frozen evidence selection: 2026-10-22. Method: hmi-pooled-reference-v2.

hmi-pooled-reference-v2:black-pepper-pooled-tHg:5cb04d0f3c32

The reference is computed by HMI from admitted evidence, not copied from a study baseline. It describes the evidence currently in this scope; it is not a worldwide or current-lot benchmark. Source, year and region filters do not change it. Different HMI scopes are not one common ranking.

HMI black pepper Cr reference · 4 sampling families

Reference and scope

HMI black pepper Cr reference · 4 sampling families. Dried black pepper as sold or dry weight, µg/kg; no moisture conversion. Distribution of subgroup median concentration values.

Reference (µg/kg)Q1MedianQ3
Primary HMI reference25-46.8 (bounded)96700
Alternative weighting25-46.8 (bounded)96700

9 reference units; 4 sampling families. Counts describe evidence units, not independent studies or certainty.

Contributing familyReference unitsWeight
WHO GEMS/Food125%
Cicero et al. 2022125%
Savić et al. 2019125%
Tinggi et al. 2025625%

Methods

HMI pools subgroup medians from every compatible black pepper sampling family in the evidence ledger: WHO GEMS/Food region-by-year medians (black pepper, random sampling only) and per-sample or per-composite results printed by individual surveys. Each family has equal total weight; subgroups have equal weight within a family. Non-detects stay as zero-to-limit intervals, so quartiles carry lower and upper bounds. Means, ranges and maxima never enter as observations. Black pepper is a dried spice; results reported as sold and on a dry-weight basis are pooled without moisture conversion.

Inverse weighted empirical CDF; midpoint at exact cumulative-weight boundaries. At least four reference units and a definitely positive Q1-Q3 spread are required. This is a display eligibility rule, not statistical validation.

Limitations

An international evidence-library reference, not a probability sample of the world pepper market. GEMS/Food regions are reporting regions, not growing origins. Many submissions are non-detects with differing limits, which widens the bounds. Pooling as-sold and dry-weight results without moisture conversion adds a small, unquantified basis difference. A position is descriptive concentration, not a safety or compliance judgment.

Admitted source families

Reference version and interpretation

Frozen evidence selection: 2026-10-22. Method: hmi-pooled-reference-v2.

hmi-pooled-reference-v2:black-pepper-pooled-Cr:73dd01621445

The reference is computed by HMI from admitted evidence, not copied from a study baseline. It describes the evidence currently in this scope; it is not a worldwide or current-lot benchmark. Source, year and region filters do not change it. Different HMI scopes are not one common ranking.

HMI black pepper Ni reference · 3 sampling families

Reference and scope

HMI black pepper Ni reference · 3 sampling families. Dried black pepper as sold or dry weight, µg/kg; no moisture conversion. Distribution of subgroup median concentration values.

Reference (µg/kg)Q1MedianQ3
Primary HMI reference≤47.411901600
Alternative weighting≤47.411901400

8 reference units; 3 sampling families. Counts describe evidence units, not independent studies or certainty.

Contributing familyReference unitsWeight
Cicero et al. 2022133%
Savić et al. 2019133%
Tinggi et al. 2025633%

Methods

HMI pools subgroup medians from every compatible black pepper sampling family in the evidence ledger: WHO GEMS/Food region-by-year medians (black pepper, random sampling only) and per-sample or per-composite results printed by individual surveys. Each family has equal total weight; subgroups have equal weight within a family. Non-detects stay as zero-to-limit intervals, so quartiles carry lower and upper bounds. Means, ranges and maxima never enter as observations. Black pepper is a dried spice; results reported as sold and on a dry-weight basis are pooled without moisture conversion.

Inverse weighted empirical CDF; midpoint at exact cumulative-weight boundaries. At least four reference units and a definitely positive Q1-Q3 spread are required. This is a display eligibility rule, not statistical validation.

Limitations

An international evidence-library reference, not a probability sample of the world pepper market. GEMS/Food regions are reporting regions, not growing origins. Many submissions are non-detects with differing limits, which widens the bounds. Pooling as-sold and dry-weight results without moisture conversion adds a small, unquantified basis difference. A position is descriptive concentration, not a safety or compliance judgment.

Admitted source families

Reference version and interpretation

Frozen evidence selection: 2026-10-22. Method: hmi-pooled-reference-v2.

hmi-pooled-reference-v2:black-pepper-pooled-Ni:0953665fe55d

The reference is computed by HMI from admitted evidence, not copied from a study baseline. It describes the evidence currently in this scope; it is not a worldwide or current-lot benchmark. Source, year and region filters do not change it. Different HMI scopes are not one common ranking.

HMI black pepper Al reference · 3 sampling families

Reference and scope

HMI black pepper Al reference · 3 sampling families. Dried black pepper as sold or dry weight, µg/kg; no moisture conversion. Distribution of subgroup median concentration values.

Reference (µg/kg)Q1MedianQ3
Primary HMI reference4310084500134000
Alternative weighting4310058000134000

8 reference units; 3 sampling families. Counts describe evidence units, not independent studies or certainty.

Contributing familyReference unitsWeight
Ammar et al. 2023133%
Cicero et al. 2022133%
Tinggi et al. 2025633%

Methods

HMI pools subgroup medians from every compatible black pepper sampling family in the evidence ledger: WHO GEMS/Food region-by-year medians (black pepper, random sampling only) and per-sample or per-composite results printed by individual surveys. Each family has equal total weight; subgroups have equal weight within a family. Non-detects stay as zero-to-limit intervals, so quartiles carry lower and upper bounds. Means, ranges and maxima never enter as observations. Black pepper is a dried spice; results reported as sold and on a dry-weight basis are pooled without moisture conversion.

Inverse weighted empirical CDF; midpoint at exact cumulative-weight boundaries. At least four reference units and a definitely positive Q1-Q3 spread are required. This is a display eligibility rule, not statistical validation.

Limitations

An international evidence-library reference, not a probability sample of the world pepper market. GEMS/Food regions are reporting regions, not growing origins. Many submissions are non-detects with differing limits, which widens the bounds. Pooling as-sold and dry-weight results without moisture conversion adds a small, unquantified basis difference. A position is descriptive concentration, not a safety or compliance judgment.

Admitted source families

Reference version and interpretation

Frozen evidence selection: 2026-10-22. Method: hmi-pooled-reference-v2.

hmi-pooled-reference-v2:black-pepper-pooled-Al:4d78f06dd657

The reference is computed by HMI from admitted evidence, not copied from a study baseline. It describes the evidence currently in this scope; it is not a worldwide or current-lot benchmark. Source, year and region filters do not change it. Different HMI scopes are not one common ranking.

HMI black pepper Sn reference · 2 sampling families

Reference and scope

HMI black pepper Sn reference · 2 sampling families. Dried black pepper as sold or dry weight, µg/kg; no moisture conversion. Distribution of subgroup median concentration values.

Reference (µg/kg)Q1MedianQ3
Primary HMI reference≤100587-637 (bounded)1170
Alternative weighting≤100587-637 (bounded)1170

2 reference units; 2 sampling families. Counts describe evidence units, not independent studies or certainty.

Contributing familyReference unitsWeight
WHO GEMS/Food150%
Cicero et al. 2022150%

Methods

HMI pools subgroup medians from every compatible black pepper sampling family in the evidence ledger: WHO GEMS/Food region-by-year medians (black pepper, random sampling only) and per-sample or per-composite results printed by individual surveys. Each family has equal total weight; subgroups have equal weight within a family. Non-detects stay as zero-to-limit intervals, so quartiles carry lower and upper bounds. Means, ranges and maxima never enter as observations. Black pepper is a dried spice; results reported as sold and on a dry-weight basis are pooled without moisture conversion.

Inverse weighted empirical CDF; midpoint at exact cumulative-weight boundaries. At least four reference units and a definitely positive Q1-Q3 spread are required. This is a display eligibility rule, not statistical validation.

Limitations

An international evidence-library reference, not a probability sample of the world pepper market. GEMS/Food regions are reporting regions, not growing origins. Many submissions are non-detects with differing limits, which widens the bounds. Pooling as-sold and dry-weight results without moisture conversion adds a small, unquantified basis difference. A position is descriptive concentration, not a safety or compliance judgment.

Admitted source families

Reference version and interpretation

Frozen evidence selection: 2026-10-22. Method: hmi-pooled-reference-v2.

hmi-pooled-reference-v2:black-pepper-pooled-Sn:e83c13bde4e3

The reference is computed by HMI from admitted evidence, not copied from a study baseline. It describes the evidence currently in this scope; it is not a worldwide or current-lot benchmark. Source, year and region filters do not change it. Different HMI scopes are not one common ranking.

1 dataset

How metals reach black pepper

Metals reach black pepper through the vine’s uptake from soil and through surfaces and equipment that contact the berries during drying and grinding.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →9Matloob MH · 2016Using Stripping Voltammetry to Determine Heavy Metals in Cooking Spices Used in IraqPolish Journal of Environmental StudiesRead source → The very high aluminum in pepper (29-540 mg/kg in Queensland retail samples) is attributed by those authors to aluminum utensils and containers in processing and to accumulation by the plant, and an Iraqi survey names drying on bare ground and wear of milling machinery as routes.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →9Matloob MH · 2016Using Stripping Voltammetry to Determine Heavy Metals in Cooking Spices Used in IraqPolish Journal of Environmental StudiesRead source →

Grinding and handling after import are plausible additions. In Libya, ground pepper bought at retail averaged 320 µg/kg cadmium against 150 µg/kg in wholesale lots sampled on arrival, and lead was also higher at retail (820 against 730 µg/kg).4Ziyaina M, Rajab A, Alkhweldi K, Algami W, Al-Toumi O, Rasco B · 2014Lead and cadmium residue determination in spices available in Tripoli City markets (Libya)African Journal of Biochemistry ResearchRead source → Stainless steel and aluminum equipment are discussed as possible sources of chromium, nickel and aluminum, but no source measured them in pepper processing.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →

Deliberate lead adulteration, reported for turmeric, has not been shown for black pepper in this evidence.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →16Ericson B, Gabelaia L, Keith J, Kashibadze T, Beraia N, Sturua L, Kazzi Z · 2020Elevated Levels of Lead (Pb) Identified in Georgian SpicesAnnals of Global HealthRead source → A Georgian household survey found one black pepper sample at 48 mg/kg lead by handheld X-ray fluorescence, but four of five were below its 4-8 mg/kg detection limit, and the paper does not say whether that sample was among those confirmed by laboratory analysis.16Ericson B, Gabelaia L, Keith J, Kashibadze T, Beraia N, Sturua L, Kazzi Z · 2020Elevated Levels of Lead (Pb) Identified in Georgian SpicesAnnals of Global HealthRead source →

Which forms and origins measured lower

For lead, the clearest comparison is form: in GEMS/Food, whole black pepper had a median of 30-52 µg/kg (28 results) against 61-68 µg/kg for ground or cracked pepper (211 results).1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source → Cadmium and arsenic medians in both forms sat below the reporting limits, so form does not change those comparisons.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source → This is a descriptive difference across many laboratories, not a controlled grinding experiment.

Within one study, origin comparisons are more reliable. Among Queensland retail pepper, Vietnamese-grown pepper (two samples) had the lowest means of any origin for lead (60 µg/kg), cadmium (9) and arsenic (16), while Indian pepper (four samples) had the highest chromium (840) and aluminum (162,000 µg/kg) and Chinese pepper the highest arsenic (860 µg/kg, driven by one sample at 1,700).5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source → For chromium and aluminum, Vietnamese pepper (240 and 85,000 µg/kg) was also lower than Chinese (640 and 125,000) and Indian pepper (840 and 162,000), and single samples from Sri Lanka (50 and 39,000) and Malaysia (140 and 57,000) were lowest of all.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source → A single Vietnamese whole pepper bought in Saudi Arabia measured 8 µg/kg lead and 3 µg/kg cadmium.6Cicero N, Gervasi T, Durazzo A, Lucarini M, Macrì A, Nava V, Giarratana F, Tardugno R, Vadalà R, Santini A · 2022Mineral and Microbiological Analysis of Spices and Aromatic HerbsFoodsRead source → With one to four samples per origin these are tentative patterns, not a supported preference for a country.

Retail and packaging comparisons point in different directions by metal. In Lebanon, bulk pepper had the highest cadmium (154 µg/kg against 121-136 for packaged) but the lowest arsenic (126 against 189-200), and lead was similar (284-346 µg/kg).10Moussa L, Hassan HF, Savvaidis IN, Karam L · 2024Impact of source, packaging and presence of food safety management system on heavy metals levels in spices and herbsPLoS ONERead source → Ten packaged US retail products all fell in the lowest concern band of a consumer test for arsenic, cadmium and lead, while unpackaged pepper from eastern turkey averaged 2,470 µg/kg lead.17Gill LL, Christian TA · 2021The Trouble With Spices: Heavy Metals in 15 Herbs and SpicesConsumer ReportsRead source →8Mercan Yucel U · 2022Determination of Aflatoxin and Heavy Metal Levels in Some Spices Sold as Unpackaged in Van Province and Health Risks Assessment of Heavy MetalsBalikesir Health Sciences JournalRead source → Chromium varied widely, from 96 µg/kg in one Vietnamese sample to a 3,620 µg/kg mean in bulk Moroccan pepper.6Cicero N, Gervasi T, Durazzo A, Lucarini M, Macrì A, Nava V, Giarratana F, Tardugno R, Vadalà R, Santini A · 2022Mineral and Microbiological Analysis of Spices and Aromatic HerbsFoodsRead source →14Sabri S, Sabri C, Salam MR, El Mellouli F, Lafram A, Khallouki H, Hassane YA, Kabine M · 2025Essential and Toxic Element Profiles in Selected Spices from Greater Casablanca, MoroccoWorld’s Veterinary Journal 15(4): 863-881Read source →

Is whole black pepper lower in metals than ground pepper?

For lead, yes in monitoring data: whole black pepper had a GEMS/Food median of 30-52 µg/kg against 61-68 µg/kg for ground or cracked pepper.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source → Cadmium and arsenic medians in both forms were below reporting limits, and no single study compared whole and ground pepper from the same lots.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →

Which growing countries measured lowest?

Within one Queensland study, Vietnamese-grown pepper had the lowest lead (60 µg/kg), cadmium (9) and arsenic (16 µg/kg) means of five origins.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source → Across studies, Malaysian-grown pepper measured 100 µg/kg lead in Australia but 714 µg/kg in Ghana, so the market and handling chain matter as much as the origin.3Osei-Safo I, Miezah K, Sackey LNA, Adusei-Gyamf J, Abdul AM · 2024Trace and Heavy Metals in Locally and Imported Spices Sold on Markets in Accra Metropolis, GhanaThe Scientific World JournalRead source →5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →

Is bulk or loose pepper higher than packaged pepper?

Not consistently. In Lebanon bulk pepper had more cadmium (154 against 121-136 µg/kg) but less arsenic (126 against 189-200), and lead was similar.10Moussa L, Hassan HF, Savvaidis IN, Karam L · 2024Impact of source, packaging and presence of food safety management system on heavy metals levels in spices and herbsPLoS ONERead source → The highest lead means came from unpackaged pepper in eastern turkey (2,470 µg/kg) and ground pepper in Libya (730-820 µg/kg), while ten packaged US products were all lowest concern.4Ziyaina M, Rajab A, Alkhweldi K, Algami W, Al-Toumi O, Rasco B · 2014Lead and cadmium residue determination in spices available in Tripoli City markets (Libya)African Journal of Biochemistry ResearchRead source →17Gill LL, Christian TA · 2021The Trouble With Spices: Heavy Metals in 15 Herbs and SpicesConsumer ReportsRead source →8Mercan Yucel U · 2022Determination of Aflatoxin and Heavy Metal Levels in Some Spices Sold as Unpackaged in Van Province and Health Risks Assessment of Heavy MetalsBalikesir Health Sciences JournalRead source →

Processing, grinding and handling

No source measured a pepper processing step against a control for metals. Across 23 Iraqi spices pooled, unwashed portions carried 7% more lead and 14% more cadmium than washed portions, but no pepper-specific effect was reported.9Matloob MH · 2016Using Stripping Voltammetry to Determine Heavy Metals in Cooking Spices Used in IraqPolish Journal of Environmental StudiesRead source → Steam treatment, irradiation and sterilisation were not assessed for metals in any source here.

Grinding is the processing step most likely to matter.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →9Matloob MH · 2016Using Stripping Voltammetry to Determine Heavy Metals in Cooking Spices Used in IraqPolish Journal of Environmental StudiesRead source → Ground pepper had a higher lead median than whole pepper in monitoring data, and one survey author avoided commercially milled spices because milling machinery can add trace elements.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →9Matloob MH · 2016Using Stripping Voltammetry to Determine Heavy Metals in Cooking Spices Used in IraqPolish Journal of Environmental StudiesRead source → White pepper, made by removing the outer layer, is outside this page; the Lebanese survey measured it separately.10Moussa L, Hassan HF, Savvaidis IN, Karam L · 2024Impact of source, packaging and presence of food safety management system on heavy metals levels in spices and herbsPLoS ONERead source →

Mitigation from farm to grinder

Controls for black pepper act at drying and handling, at grinding, at procurement and at the release test. The only measured comparisons are observational: retail lots in Libya carried more cadmium than wholesale lots on arrival, and a food safety management system at Lebanese packers did not lower lead or cadmium.4Ziyaina M, Rajab A, Alkhweldi K, Algami W, Al-Toumi O, Rasco B · 2014Lead and cadmium residue determination in spices available in Tripoli City markets (Libya)African Journal of Biochemistry ResearchRead source →10Moussa L, Hassan HF, Savvaidis IN, Karam L · 2024Impact of source, packaging and presence of food safety management system on heavy metals levels in spices and herbsPLoS ONERead source → Drying off the ground, controlled milling and lot testing are guidance without measured pepper effects, and testing detects metals without removing them.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →9Matloob MH · 2016Using Stripping Voltammetry to Determine Heavy Metals in Cooking Spices Used in IraqPolish Journal of Environmental StudiesRead source →16Ericson B, Gabelaia L, Keith J, Kashibadze T, Beraia N, Sturua L, Kazzi Z · 2020Elevated Levels of Lead (Pb) Identified in Georgian SpicesAnnals of Global HealthRead source →

About this table
ControlMaterialEffectsEvidence
Controls by production stage, retaining all paired analyte outcomes. Seasons and reused guidance do not add independent studies. No effectiveness ranking is implied.
ControlMaterialEffectsEvidence
Dry pepper off bare groundprimary production · As reportedBlack pepper
Pb · Context
Guidance

Matloob 2016

HMI source record · Original source

Official guidance; not an independent experimental dataset. Reused across actions without adding studies.

Effects and comparators

LeadGuidance; effect not measuredDrying surfaceGround versus raised dryingDried pepper as reportedContext · No supported numerical treatment contrast is retained for this finding. A direction, market association, source-selection strategy or guidance statement alone does not establish a percentage change.

Guidance; no measured comparison.

How magnitude is classified

HMI editorial magnitude bands: Low is a change greater than 0% and below 25%; Moderate is 25% to below 50%; High is 50% or more, relative to that control’s own comparator. Direction is shown separately. These are descriptive display bands, not validated efficacy cutoffs, occurrence-baseline positions, statistical significance, evidence certainty, safety or net benefit. A range spanning bands retains both labels; a qualitative label has no implied percentage.

Control in context

The author names drying on the ground as a contamination route for spices; not measured for pepper.

ContextSelected control
Materialspices including black pepper, Babil, Iraq
Stageprimary production
AudienceIngredient suppliers · Brands
PeriodAs reported
ConditionsApplies to post-harvest drying.
Tested scaleAuthor guidance
Sample unitsSource sampling units; no independent intervention units unless stated.
Trade-offsOther metals, flavour and cost not quantified.
VerificationConfirm with lot-specific lead results using an adequate quantification limit.

Design, applicability and operating conditions

Author guidance. Applies to post-harvest drying.

One study family.

As reported by the source

Reduces metal reaching or added to the pepper, or detects it before release.

Source measurements and linked outcomes

AnalytePeriodEffectConverted valuesOriginal means (SD)BasisLocator
Lead (Pb)As reportedGuidance; effect not measuredNumerical baseline not extractedAbsolute values unextractedDried pepper as reportedWashed and Unwashed spices, p. 2067

No measured effect size.

No percentage calculated unless shown in outcomes.

Not applicable.

Trade-offs and implementation

Not assessed.

Not assessed.

Not assessed.

Not quantified.

Not assessed.

Applicability and verification

Applies to post-harvest drying.

Lot testing.

See source.

Extraction limits and next actions

Unresolved fieldNext action
controlled intervention effectNo controlled black pepper intervention study in the library; keep effect unquantified unless measured.

Provenance and assessment

As disclosed by the source.

Source facts and HMI calculations are distinguished above. These selected source findings do not constitute a systematic review; outcome-level appraisal remains incomplete.

Clean surface soil from spices before grindingfood processing · As reportedBlack pepper
Pb · Decreased
Cd · Decreased
1

Matloob 2016

HMI source record · Original source

One dataset family. Linked analytes, repeated seasons and reports are not independent studies.

Effects and comparators

LeadDecreasedUnwashed about 7% higher than washed (23 spices pooled)Spice leadUnwashed versus washedDried pepper as reportedNot quantified · No supported numerical treatment contrast is retained for this finding. A direction, market association, source-selection strategy or guidance statement alone does not establish a percentage change.

CadmiumDecreasedUnwashed about 14% higher than washed (23 spices pooled)Spice cadmiumUnwashed versus washedDried pepper as reportedNot quantified · No supported numerical treatment contrast is retained for this finding. A direction, market association, source-selection strategy or guidance statement alone does not establish a percentage change.

Washed versus unwashed portions of the same spices.

How magnitude is classified

HMI editorial magnitude bands: Low is a change greater than 0% and below 25%; Moderate is 25% to below 50%; High is 50% or more, relative to that control’s own comparator. Direction is shown separately. These are descriptive display bands, not validated efficacy cutoffs, occurrence-baseline positions, statistical significance, evidence certainty, safety or net benefit. A range spanning bands retains both labels; a qualitative label has no implied percentage.

Control in context

Unwashed spices carried more lead (7%), cadmium (14%) and mercury (11%) than washed spices across 23 spices pooled; no black-pepper-specific effect reported.

ContextSelected control
Material23 spices pooled, Iraq
Stagefood processing
AudienceIngredient suppliers · Brands
PeriodAs reported
ConditionsPooled across spice types; washing is not a usual commercial step for pepper.
Tested scaleLaboratory
Sample unitsSource sampling units; no independent intervention units unless stated.
Trade-offsOther metals, flavour and cost not quantified.
VerificationConfirm with lot-specific lead results using an adequate quantification limit.

Design, applicability and operating conditions

Measured comparison. Pooled across spice types; washing is not a usual commercial step for pepper.

One study family.

As reported by the source

Reduces metal reaching or added to the pepper, or detects it before release.

Source measurements and linked outcomes

AnalytePeriodEffectConverted valuesOriginal means (SD)BasisLocator
Lead (Pb)As reportedUnwashed about 7% higher than washed (23 spices pooled)Numerical baseline not extractedAbsolute values unextractedDried pepper as reportedWashed and Unwashed spices; Fig. 1
Cadmium (Cd)As reportedUnwashed about 14% higher than washed (23 spices pooled)Numerical baseline not extractedAbsolute values unextractedDried pepper as reportedWashed and Unwashed spices; Fig. 1

Pepper-specific effect unknown; mercury values from this study are held.

No percentage calculated unless shown in outcomes.

Not applicable.

Trade-offs and implementation

Not assessed.

Not assessed.

Not assessed.

Not quantified.

Not assessed.

Applicability and verification

Pooled across spice types; washing is not a usual commercial step for pepper.

Lot testing.

See source.

Extraction limits and next actions

Unresolved fieldNext action
controlled intervention effectNo controlled black pepper intervention study in the library; keep effect unquantified unless measured.

Provenance and assessment

As disclosed by the source.

Source facts and HMI calculations are distinguished above. These selected source findings do not constitute a systematic review; outcome-level appraisal remains incomplete.

Control milling equipment wearfood processing · As reportedBlack pepper
Pb · Context
Guidance

Matloob 2016

HMI source record · Original source

Official guidance; not an independent experimental dataset. Reused across actions without adding studies.

Effects and comparators

LeadGuidance; effect not measured in one lotMilling contactMilled versus unmilledDried pepper as reportedContext · No supported numerical treatment contrast is retained for this finding. A direction, market association, source-selection strategy or guidance statement alone does not establish a percentage change.

Guidance; no same-lot comparison.

How magnitude is classified

HMI editorial magnitude bands: Low is a change greater than 0% and below 25%; Moderate is 25% to below 50%; High is 50% or more, relative to that control’s own comparator. Direction is shown separately. These are descriptive display bands, not validated efficacy cutoffs, occurrence-baseline positions, statistical significance, evidence certainty, safety or net benefit. A range spanning bands retains both labels; a qualitative label has no implied percentage.

Control in context

The author avoided commercially milled spices because milling machinery can add trace elements; whole pepper had a lower lead median than ground pepper in monitoring data.

ContextSelected control
MaterialCommercially milled spices, Iraq
Stagefood processing
AudienceIngredient suppliers · Brands
PeriodAs reported
ConditionsApplies to grinding and cracking.
Tested scaleAuthor guidance
Sample unitsSource sampling units; no independent intervention units unless stated.
Trade-offsOther metals, flavour and cost not quantified.
VerificationConfirm with lot-specific lead results using an adequate quantification limit.

Design, applicability and operating conditions

Author guidance. Applies to grinding and cracking.

One study family.

As reported by the source

Reduces metal reaching or added to the pepper, or detects it before release.

Source measurements and linked outcomes

AnalytePeriodEffectConverted valuesOriginal means (SD)BasisLocator
Lead (Pb)As reportedGuidance; effect not measured in one lotNumerical baseline not extractedAbsolute values unextractedDried pepper as reportedSampling and Classification

No measured pepper effect.

No percentage calculated unless shown in outcomes.

Not applicable.

Trade-offs and implementation

Not assessed.

Not assessed.

Not assessed.

Not quantified.

Not assessed.

Applicability and verification

Applies to grinding and cracking.

Lot testing.

See source.

Extraction limits and next actions

Unresolved fieldNext action
controlled intervention effectNo controlled black pepper intervention study in the library; keep effect unquantified unless measured.

Provenance and assessment

As disclosed by the source.

Source facts and HMI calculations are distinguished above. These selected source findings do not constitute a systematic review; outcome-level appraisal remains incomplete.

Control handling between import and retailstorage and handling · As reportedBlack pepper
Cd · Increased
Pb · Increased
1

Ziyaina et al. 2014

HMI source record · Original source

One dataset family. Linked analytes, repeated seasons and reports are not independent studies.

Effects and comparators

CadmiumIncreasedHigher at retail than wholesale (observational)Mean pepper cadmiumWholesale versus retailDried pepper as reportedHigh · HMI calculates the relative change from the retained source means: (320 − 150) / 150 × 100 = 113.3%. This is a descriptive contrast of means; no confidence interval or significance test is inferred.

LeadIncreasedHigher at retail than wholesale (observational)Mean pepper leadWholesale versus retailDried pepper as reportedLow · HMI calculates the relative change from the retained source means: (820 − 730) / 730 × 100 = 12.3%. This is a descriptive contrast of means; no confidence interval or significance test is inferred.

Retail (36 samples) versus wholesale (24 samples) in the same survey.

How magnitude is classified

HMI editorial magnitude bands: Low is a change greater than 0% and below 25%; Moderate is 25% to below 50%; High is 50% or more, relative to that control’s own comparator. Direction is shown separately. These are descriptive display bands, not validated efficacy cutoffs, occurrence-baseline positions, statistical significance, evidence certainty, safety or net benefit. A range spanning bands retains both labels; a qualitative label has no implied percentage.

Control in context

Retail ground pepper averaged 320 µg/kg cadmium and 820 µg/kg lead against 150 and 730 µg/kg in wholesale lots sampled on arrival.

ContextSelected control
MaterialGround black pepper, Libya, 2011
Stagestorage and handling
AudienceIngredient suppliers · Brands
PeriodAs reported
ConditionsOne country and year; lots were not tracked from wholesale to retail.
Tested scaleMarket survey
Sample unitsSource sampling units; no independent intervention units unless stated.
Trade-offsOther metals, flavour and cost not quantified.
VerificationConfirm with lot-specific lead results using an adequate quantification limit.

Design, applicability and operating conditions

Observational survey. One country and year; lots were not tracked from wholesale to retail.

One study family.

As reported by the source

Reduces metal reaching or added to the pepper, or detects it before release.

Source measurements and linked outcomes

AnalytePeriodEffectConverted valuesOriginal means (SD)BasisLocator
Cadmium (Cd)As reportedHigher at retail than wholesale (observational)150 → 320 µg/kgAbsolute values unextractedDried pepper as reportedTable 3
Lead (Pb)As reportedHigher at retail than wholesale (observational)730 → 820 µg/kgAbsolute values unextractedDried pepper as reportedTable 3

Observational; printed SDs are inconsistent with the ranges.

No percentage calculated unless shown in outcomes.

Not applicable.

Trade-offs and implementation

Not assessed.

Not assessed.

Not assessed.

Not quantified.

Not assessed.

Applicability and verification

One country and year; lots were not tracked from wholesale to retail.

Lot testing.

See source.

Extraction limits and next actions

Unresolved fieldNext action
controlled intervention effectNo controlled black pepper intervention study in the library; keep effect unquantified unless measured.

Provenance and assessment

As disclosed by the source.

Source facts and HMI calculations are distinguished above. These selected source findings do not constitute a systematic review; outcome-level appraisal remains incomplete.

Do not rely on packaging alonesourcing and procurement · As reportedBlack pepper
Cd · Decreased
tAs · Increased
Pb · Increased
1

Moussa et al. 2024

HMI source record · Original source

One dataset family. Linked analytes, repeated seasons and reports are not independent studies.

Effects and comparators

CadmiumDecreasedLower cadmium in imported packaged pepper (observational)Mean pepper cadmiumBulk versus imported packagedDried pepper as reportedLow · HMI calculates the relative change from the retained source means: (127 − 154) / 154 × 100 = -17.5%. This is a descriptive contrast of means; no confidence interval or significance test is inferred.

Total arsenicIncreasedHigher arsenic in imported packaged pepper (observational)Mean pepper total arsenicBulk versus imported packagedDried pepper as reportedHigh · HMI calculates the relative change from the retained source means: (197 − 126) / 126 × 100 = 56.3%. This is a descriptive contrast of means; no confidence interval or significance test is inferred.

LeadIncreasedHigher lead in imported packaged pepper (observational)Mean pepper leadBulk versus imported packagedDried pepper as reportedLow · HMI calculates the relative change from the retained source means: (346 − 295) / 295 × 100 = 17.3%. This is a descriptive contrast of means; no confidence interval or significance test is inferred.

Bulk versus three packaged groups, two composites of five brands each.

How magnitude is classified

HMI editorial magnitude bands: Low is a change greater than 0% and below 25%; Moderate is 25% to below 50%; High is 50% or more, relative to that control’s own comparator. Direction is shown separately. These are descriptive display bands, not validated efficacy cutoffs, occurrence-baseline positions, statistical significance, evidence certainty, safety or net benefit. A range spanning bands retains both labels; a qualitative label has no implied percentage.

Control in context

Bulk pepper had more cadmium (154 µg/kg) than packaged pepper (121-136) but less arsenic (126 against 189-200), and lead was similar (284-346 µg/kg).

ContextSelected control
MaterialBlack pepper composites, Lebanon, 2020
Stagesourcing and procurement
AudienceIngredient suppliers · Brands · Consumers
PeriodAs reported
ConditionsOne country; composites of five brands; two collections.
Tested scaleMarket survey
Sample unitsSource sampling units; no independent intervention units unless stated.
Trade-offsOther metals, flavour and cost not quantified.
VerificationConfirm with lot-specific lead results using an adequate quantification limit.

Design, applicability and operating conditions

Observational survey. One country; composites of five brands; two collections.

One study family.

As reported by the source

Reduces metal reaching or added to the pepper, or detects it before release.

Source measurements and linked outcomes

AnalytePeriodEffectConverted valuesOriginal means (SD)BasisLocator
Cadmium (Cd)As reportedLower cadmium in imported packaged pepper (observational)154 → 127 µg/kgAbsolute values unextractedDried pepper as reportedTable 1; S1 Table
Total arsenic (tAs)As reportedHigher arsenic in imported packaged pepper (observational)126 → 197 µg/kgAbsolute values unextractedDried pepper as reportedTable 1; S1 Table
Lead (Pb)As reportedHigher lead in imported packaged pepper (observational)295 → 346 µg/kgAbsolute values unextractedDried pepper as reportedTable 1; S1 Table

Two composites per group; no significance test for pepper alone.

No percentage calculated unless shown in outcomes.

Not applicable.

Trade-offs and implementation

Not assessed.

Not assessed.

Not assessed.

Not quantified.

Not assessed.

Applicability and verification

One country; composites of five brands; two collections.

Lot testing.

See source.

Extraction limits and next actions

Unresolved fieldNext action
controlled intervention effectNo controlled black pepper intervention study in the library; keep effect unquantified unless measured.

Provenance and assessment

As disclosed by the source.

Source facts and HMI calculations are distinguished above. These selected source findings do not constitute a systematic review; outcome-level appraisal remains incomplete.

Do not rely on a packer food safety system alonesourcing and procurement · As reportedBlack pepper
Pb · Increased
1

Moussa et al. 2024

HMI source record · Original source

One dataset family. Linked analytes, repeated seasons and reports are not independent studies.

Effects and comparators

LeadIncreasedNo reduction with a management system (observational)Mean pepper leadWithout versus with systemDried pepper as reportedLow · HMI calculates the relative change from the retained source means: (330 − 284) / 284 × 100 = 16.2%. This is a descriptive contrast of means; no confidence interval or significance test is inferred.

Local packers with versus without a food safety management system.

How magnitude is classified

HMI editorial magnitude bands: Low is a change greater than 0% and below 25%; Moderate is 25% to below 50%; High is 50% or more, relative to that control’s own comparator. Direction is shown separately. These are descriptive display bands, not validated efficacy cutoffs, occurrence-baseline positions, statistical significance, evidence certainty, safety or net benefit. A range spanning bands retains both labels; a qualitative label has no implied percentage.

Control in context

Local packers with a food safety management system had lead of 330 µg/kg against 284 µg/kg without one; across all spices the share above limits did not differ.

ContextSelected control
MaterialBlack pepper composites, Lebanon, 2020
Stagesourcing and procurement
AudienceIngredient suppliers · Brands · Consumers
PeriodAs reported
ConditionsOne country; raw material judged the main contributor by the authors.
Tested scaleMarket survey
Sample unitsSource sampling units; no independent intervention units unless stated.
Trade-offsOther metals, flavour and cost not quantified.
VerificationConfirm with lot-specific lead results using an adequate quantification limit.

Design, applicability and operating conditions

Observational survey. One country; raw material judged the main contributor by the authors.

One study family.

As reported by the source

Reduces metal reaching or added to the pepper, or detects it before release.

Source measurements and linked outcomes

AnalytePeriodEffectConverted valuesOriginal means (SD)BasisLocator
Lead (Pb)As reportedNo reduction with a management system (observational)284 → 330 µg/kgAbsolute values unextractedDried pepper as reportedTable 1; Discussion

Observational; two composites per group.

No percentage calculated unless shown in outcomes.

Not applicable.

Trade-offs and implementation

Not assessed.

Not assessed.

Not assessed.

Not quantified.

Not assessed.

Applicability and verification

One country; raw material judged the main contributor by the authors.

Lot testing.

See source.

Extraction limits and next actions

Unresolved fieldNext action
controlled intervention effectNo controlled black pepper intervention study in the library; keep effect unquantified unless measured.

Provenance and assessment

As disclosed by the source.

Source facts and HMI calculations are distinguished above. These selected source findings do not constitute a systematic review; outcome-level appraisal remains incomplete.

Screen with handheld XRF only alongside laboratory confirmationlot acceptance and release · As reportedBlack pepper
Pb · Context
Context

Ericson et al. 2020

HMI source record · Original source

Contextual literature cited by this report; not a new intervention dataset.

Effects and comparators

LeadDetection, not removalMethod detection limitXRF versus required sensitivityDried pepper as reportedContext · No supported numerical treatment contrast is retained for this finding. A direction, market association, source-selection strategy or guidance statement alone does not establish a percentage change.

XRF versus ICP-MS on the same spices.

How magnitude is classified

HMI editorial magnitude bands: Low is a change greater than 0% and below 25%; Moderate is 25% to below 50%; High is 50% or more, relative to that control’s own comparator. Direction is shown separately. These are descriptive display bands, not validated efficacy cutoffs, occurrence-baseline positions, statistical significance, evidence certainty, safety or net benefit. A range spanning bands retains both labels; a qualitative label has no implied percentage.

Control in context

Handheld X-ray fluorescence tracked laboratory ICP-MS results closely in 15 spices (R² 0.98) but its 4-8 mg/kg detection limit is far above the 0.6 mg/kg lead limit for pepper; testing detects lead and does not remove it.

ContextSelected control
MaterialHousehold spices, Georgia, 2019
Stagelot acceptance and release
AudienceIngredient suppliers · Brands
PeriodAs reported
ConditionsAny lot-release testing for lead.
Tested scaleLaboratory method
Sample unitsSource sampling units; no independent intervention units unless stated.
Trade-offsOther metals, flavour and cost not quantified.
VerificationConfirm with lot-specific lead results using an adequate quantification limit.

Design, applicability and operating conditions

Author guidance. Any lot-release testing for lead.

One study family.

As reported by the source

Reduces metal reaching or added to the pepper, or detects it before release.

Source measurements and linked outcomes

AnalytePeriodEffectConverted valuesOriginal means (SD)BasisLocator
Lead (Pb)As reportedDetection, not removalNumerical baseline not extractedAbsolute values unextractedDried pepper as reportedResults; Figs 1-2

Method fitness only.

No percentage calculated unless shown in outcomes.

Not applicable.

Trade-offs and implementation

Not assessed.

Not assessed.

Not assessed.

Not quantified.

Not assessed.

Applicability and verification

Any lot-release testing for lead.

Lot testing.

See source.

Extraction limits and next actions

Unresolved fieldNext action
controlled intervention effectNo controlled black pepper intervention study in the library; keep effect unquantified unless measured.

Provenance and assessment

As disclosed by the source.

Source facts and HMI calculations are distinguished above. These selected source findings do not constitute a systematic review; outcome-level appraisal remains incomplete.

Intervention evidence

Trade-offs and limits of controls

Packaging is not a guaranteed fix.10Moussa L, Hassan HF, Savvaidis IN, Karam L · 2024Impact of source, packaging and presence of food safety management system on heavy metals levels in spices and herbsPLoS ONERead source → Packaged Lebanese pepper had less cadmium than bulk but more arsenic, and imported packaged pepper had the highest lead mean of the four groups (346 µg/kg).10Moussa L, Hassan HF, Savvaidis IN, Karam L · 2024Impact of source, packaging and presence of food safety management system on heavy metals levels in spices and herbsPLoS ONERead source → The survey authors note that packaging helps only if the material itself is food grade and does not release metals.10Moussa L, Hassan HF, Savvaidis IN, Karam L · 2024Impact of source, packaging and presence of food safety management system on heavy metals levels in spices and herbsPLoS ONERead source →

Choosing an origin for lower lead can raise another metal or simply move the risk.3Osei-Safo I, Miezah K, Sackey LNA, Adusei-Gyamf J, Abdul AM · 2024Trace and Heavy Metals in Locally and Imported Spices Sold on Markets in Accra Metropolis, GhanaThe Scientific World JournalRead source →5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source → In Queensland, the origin lowest in lead was not lowest in nickel, and Malaysian-grown pepper measured 100 µg/kg lead in Australia but 714 µg/kg in Ghana.3Osei-Safo I, Miezah K, Sackey LNA, Adusei-Gyamf J, Abdul AM · 2024Trace and Heavy Metals in Locally and Imported Spices Sold on Markets in Accra Metropolis, GhanaThe Scientific World JournalRead source →5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source → Cheaper screening has its own trade-off: handheld X-ray fluorescence found lead in spices quickly, but its 4-8 mg/kg detection limit is far above the EU limit of 0.6 mg/kg.2European Commission · 2023Commission Regulation (EU) 2023/915 of 25 April 2023 on maximum levels for certain contaminants in food and repealing Regulation (EC) No 1881/2006Official Journal of the European UnionRead source →16Ericson B, Gabelaia L, Keith J, Kashibadze T, Beraia N, Sturua L, Kazzi Z · 2020Elevated Levels of Lead (Pb) Identified in Georgian SpicesAnnals of Global HealthRead source →

Testing black pepper for metals

A useful black pepper test must see well below the applicable limit, which for lead in the EU is 600 µg/kg.2European Commission · 2023Commission Regulation (EU) 2023/915 of 25 April 2023 on maximum levels for certain contaminants in food and repealing Regulation (EC) No 1881/2006Official Journal of the European UnionRead source → Laboratory methods in the evidence reached 2-5 µg/kg for lead (ICP-MS in Queensland and Poland), while handheld X-ray fluorescence could not see below about 4,000 µg/kg.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →11Kowalska G · 2021The Safety Assessment of Toxic Metals in Commonly Used Herbs, Spices, Tea, and Coffee in PolandInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public HealthRead source →16Ericson B, Gabelaia L, Keith J, Kashibadze T, Beraia N, Sturua L, Kazzi Z · 2020Elevated Levels of Lead (Pb) Identified in Georgian SpicesAnnals of Global HealthRead source → Several surveys reported means outside their own ranges or below their own detection limits, so method, limits and reference-material checks should come with every result.3Osei-Safo I, Miezah K, Sackey LNA, Adusei-Gyamf J, Abdul AM · 2024Trace and Heavy Metals in Locally and Imported Spices Sold on Markets in Accra Metropolis, GhanaThe Scientific World JournalRead source →11Kowalska G · 2021The Safety Assessment of Toxic Metals in Commonly Used Herbs, Spices, Tea, and Coffee in PolandInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public HealthRead source →14Sabri S, Sabri C, Salam MR, El Mellouli F, Lafram A, Khallouki H, Hassane YA, Kabine M · 2025Essential and Toxic Element Profiles in Selected Spices from Greater Casablanca, MoroccoWorld’s Veterinary Journal 15(4): 863-881Read source →

Report non-detects with their limit, keep the method and laboratory, and separate total arsenic from inorganic arsenic.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source → Only 14 GEMS/Food pepper results measured inorganic arsenic; eight of nine black pepper results were below detection limits of 5-18 µg/kg and one was 31 µg/kg, so total arsenic results cannot be read as inorganic arsenic.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source → Mercury, when measured after dry ashing at 550 °C, can be lost, which makes such results unreliable.9Matloob MH · 2016Using Stripping Voltammetry to Determine Heavy Metals in Cooking Spices Used in IraqPolish Journal of Environmental StudiesRead source →

Why do some studies report very high lead in black pepper?

Some high or inconsistent values do not survive a check against their own papers. A Moroccan survey printed a lead mean below its own minimum, and a Serbian survey reported lead below the detection limit implied by its own method.14Sabri S, Sabri C, Salam MR, El Mellouli F, Lafram A, Khallouki H, Hassane YA, Kabine M · 2025Essential and Toxic Element Profiles in Selected Spices from Greater Casablanca, MoroccoWorld’s Veterinary Journal 15(4): 863-881Read source →15Savić S, Petrović S, Petronijević M, Cvetanović A, Petronijević Ž · 2019Determination of the mineral content of spices by ICP-OESAdvanced TechnologiesRead source → Others are genuine but come from small market surveys with wide spread, such as 2,470 ± 3,510 µg/kg in eastern turkey.8Mercan Yucel U · 2022Determination of Aflatoxin and Heavy Metal Levels in Some Spices Sold as Unpackaged in Van Province and Health Risks Assessment of Heavy MetalsBalikesir Health Sciences JournalRead source →

Buying and verifying black pepper

The EU sets a lead maximum level of 0.60 mg/kg for fruit spices under Regulation (EU) 2023/915; black pepper is not named as its own row, but fruit spices is the commodity class that covers dried fruit spices.2European Commission · 2023Commission Regulation (EU) 2023/915 of 25 April 2023 on maximum levels for certain contaminants in food and repealing Regulation (EC) No 1881/2006Official Journal of the European UnionRead source → The Codex Alimentarius lead schedule (CXS 193-1995, amended 2025) sets 0.6 mg/kg for “Spices, dried fruit and berries” (whole, ground, powder or crushed), with a note that the ML does not apply to dried Sichuan pepper, star anise, dried paprika and sumac.7Codex Alimentarius Commission · 1995General Standard for Contaminants and Toxins in Food and Feed (CXS 193-1995)Codex Alimentarius (Joint FAO/WHO Food Standards Programme)Read source → Food Standards Australia New Zealand Schedule 19 does not include a spice or black-pepper metal row. No cadmium or nickel maximum level for black pepper or dried spices was found in any of these instruments. Buyers should confirm the limit that applies in the destination market.

Ask for lot-specific lead results with the laboratory’s quantification limit, compared with the EU fruit-spice maximum of 600 µg/kg or the limit in the destination market, and cadmium results where that market sets a cadmium limit. Limits differ by market: China sets 1.5 mg/kg lead for spices, and Vietnam 2.0 mg/kg lead, 1.0 mg/kg cadmium, 5.0 mg/kg arsenic and 0.05 mg/kg mercury.18National Health Commission, State Administration for Market Regulation · 2025GB 2762-2025: National Food Safety Standard: Maximum Levels of Contaminants in FoodsNational Food Safety Standard of the People’s Republic of ChinaRead source →19Vietnam Ministry of Health · 2011QCVN 8-2:2011/BYT National technical regulation on the safety limits of heavy metal contamination in food (English)Circular No. 02/2011/TT-BYT, QCVN 8-2:2011/BYTRead source →

Record the growing origin separately from the packing country and the market where the pepper was bought, because most datasets identify only the market.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →3Osei-Safo I, Miezah K, Sackey LNA, Adusei-Gyamf J, Abdul AM · 2024Trace and Heavy Metals in Locally and Imported Spices Sold on Markets in Accra Metropolis, GhanaThe Scientific World JournalRead source →5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source → Blends of several origins can hide a high-lead lot that a single average will not reveal.

Specify the form and keep control of grinding.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source → Whole pepper had a lower lead median in monitoring data, and retail ground pepper in Libya had more cadmium than the wholesale pepper it came from.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →4Ziyaina M, Rajab A, Alkhweldi K, Algami W, Al-Toumi O, Rasco B · 2014Lead and cadmium residue determination in spices available in Tripoli City markets (Libya)African Journal of Biochemistry ResearchRead source → Ask whether the supplier screens imported lots: several survey authors recommend routine monitoring of imported spices, and one notes that its market did not test them at the point of entry.4Ziyaina M, Rajab A, Alkhweldi K, Algami W, Al-Toumi O, Rasco B · 2014Lead and cadmium residue determination in spices available in Tripoli City markets (Libya)African Journal of Biochemistry ResearchRead source →5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →10Moussa L, Hassan HF, Savvaidis IN, Karam L · 2024Impact of source, packaging and presence of food safety management system on heavy metals levels in spices and herbsPLoS ONERead source →

Exposure from black pepper

Black pepper is eaten in small amounts, so its typical results add little to most diets.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source → Assuming 1.9 g of all spices and herbs a day, a Queensland study estimated that spices supplied about 0.65% of the lead reference point and 1.0% of the cadmium tolerable weekly intake for an adult, without singling out black pepper.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source → A consumer test classed all ten packaged US black pepper products as lowest concern at three quarters of a teaspoon a day.17Gill LL, Christian TA · 2021The Trouble With Spices: Heavy Metals in 15 Herbs and SpicesConsumer ReportsRead source →

No source measured metals in a pepper-containing food together with the pepper that went into it. Seasoned foods in GEMS/Food, such as cod and peanuts with black pepper, were excluded because the pepper’s contribution cannot be separated.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →

Recalls and enforcement

Formal recall and enforcement database queries were run on 14 November 2026. The openFDA food enforcement API returned one spice-mix recall listing black pepper as an ingredient: F-2099-2019 (Makzemo LLC, BALQEES Yemeni Spices Mix, “Product contains high levels of lead,” Class I, terminated); this is a spice mix, not a standalone black-pepper product. Black pepper combined with cadmium, arsenic, mercury or “heavy metal” returned zero records. A broader reason_for_recall:lead AND product_description:spice query returned 9 records (cinnamon, ginger, turmeric, five-spice powder and others), providing adjacent spice-lead context but none a standalone black-pepper product. Health Canada and CFIA Recalls and Safety Alerts (34,376 records) returned zero results for black pepper with any metal issue term. The EU RASFF Window returned zero metal-subject notifications from 271 total “black pepper” notifications (predominantly pesticides, Salmonella and ethylene oxide). The GOV.UK Food Standards Agency alert search returned zero results for black pepper.

The following browser portal sources were queried on 14 November 2026 but only listing titles and reasons were checked; letter or notice bodies were not read. No metal terms appeared in any listing title or excerpt examined: FSANZ food recalls (“black pepper,” 1 listing), ACCC Product Safety (“black pepper,” 6 listings). The FDA Warning Letters search returned 17 listings, but only 10 were captured in the PDF; the metal-term check is partial and does not cover the 7 unread rows. The UK FSA Food Alerts portal could not be reached and was not queried.

Evidence review and remaining gaps

This assessment covers every source record in the HMI library that is tagged to black pepper or mentions it, plus every black pepper row in WHO GEMS/Food and other indexed datasets; each has a recorded decision based on its content.

No black-pepper food row was found in the FDA Total Diet Study FY2018 to FY2020 (the only pepper food in that dataset is “Pepper, bell, green, raw,” which is not black pepper).20U.S. Food and Drug Administration · 2022FY2018-FY2020 TDS Elements Analytical ResultsFDA Total Diet StudyRead source → The Health Canada Total Diet Study 1993 to 2018 has no black-pepper-only food name; the mixed “Herbs and Spices Mixed” composite (product code PP06) covers pepper, oregano, basil and cinnamon together and is not a black-pepper-only series.21Health Canada · 2018Health Canada Total Diet Study trace element results, 1993 to 2018Health Canada, Open Government PortalRead source →

The FDA Total Diet Study therefore contributes no results. Six sources are held in part because their values could not be reconciled with their own methods or figures.3Osei-Safo I, Miezah K, Sackey LNA, Adusei-Gyamf J, Abdul AM · 2024Trace and Heavy Metals in Locally and Imported Spices Sold on Markets in Accra Metropolis, GhanaThe Scientific World JournalRead source →11Kowalska G · 2021The Safety Assessment of Toxic Metals in Commonly Used Herbs, Spices, Tea, and Coffee in PolandInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public HealthRead source →9Matloob MH · 2016Using Stripping Voltammetry to Determine Heavy Metals in Cooking Spices Used in IraqPolish Journal of Environmental StudiesRead source →10Moussa L, Hassan HF, Savvaidis IN, Karam L · 2024Impact of source, packaging and presence of food safety management system on heavy metals levels in spices and herbsPLoS ONERead source →14Sabri S, Sabri C, Salam MR, El Mellouli F, Lafram A, Khallouki H, Hassane YA, Kabine M · 2025Essential and Toxic Element Profiles in Selected Spices from Greater Casablanca, MoroccoWorld’s Veterinary Journal 15(4): 863-881Read source →15Savić S, Petrović S, Petronijević M, Cvetanović A, Petronijević Ž · 2019Determination of the mineral content of spices by ICP-OESAdvanced TechnologiesRead source →

The main gaps are speciation and origin. Inorganic arsenic was measured in only 14 monitoring results and chromium species not at all, and only three studies report where pepper was grown.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →3Osei-Safo I, Miezah K, Sackey LNA, Adusei-Gyamf J, Abdul AM · 2024Trace and Heavy Metals in Locally and Imported Spices Sold on Markets in Accra Metropolis, GhanaThe Scientific World JournalRead source →5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →6Cicero N, Gervasi T, Durazzo A, Lucarini M, Macrì A, Nava V, Giarratana F, Tardugno R, Vadalà R, Santini A · 2022Mineral and Microbiological Analysis of Spices and Aromatic HerbsFoodsRead source →

References identify the sources used in these answers. The Sources index preserves additional discovery links; inclusion there does not mean a source has been reviewed for this assessment. Corrections, completed searches, new direct evidence and changes in requirements should reopen the relevant answer.

Black pepper FAQs

What heavy metals are found in black pepper?

Lead is the metal most often found at levels that matter; cadmium, arsenic and mercury are usually low or below detection.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →11Kowalska G · 2021The Safety Assessment of Toxic Metals in Commonly Used Herbs, Spices, Tea, and Coffee in PolandInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public HealthRead source → Black pepper also carries much more aluminum, nickel and chromium than lead or cadmium, in the hundreds to hundreds of thousands of µg/kg.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →6Cicero N, Gervasi T, Durazzo A, Lucarini M, Macrì A, Nava V, Giarratana F, Tardugno R, Vadalà R, Santini A · 2022Mineral and Microbiological Analysis of Spices and Aromatic HerbsFoodsRead source →

How do heavy metals get into black pepper?

Through the vine’s uptake from soil, contact with the ground during drying, and equipment during grinding and handling.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →9Matloob MH · 2016Using Stripping Voltammetry to Determine Heavy Metals in Cooking Spices Used in IraqPolish Journal of Environmental StudiesRead source → In Libya, retail ground pepper had twice the cadmium of the wholesale lots it came from (320 against 150 µg/kg).4Ziyaina M, Rajab A, Alkhweldi K, Algami W, Al-Toumi O, Rasco B · 2014Lead and cadmium residue determination in spices available in Tripoli City markets (Libya)African Journal of Biochemistry ResearchRead source →

Is organic black pepper free from heavy metals?

No. In GEMS/Food, 15 organic black pepper lead results had a median of 53 µg/kg, close to 60 µg/kg for 63 conventional results.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source → The organic label describes how pepper was grown, not a metal test of the lot.

Is whole or ground black pepper lower in heavy metals?

Whole pepper was lower in lead in monitoring data, with a median of 30-52 µg/kg against 61-68 µg/kg for ground or cracked pepper.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source → Grinding is a plausible source, but no study compared whole and ground pepper from the same lot.9Matloob MH · 2016Using Stripping Voltammetry to Determine Heavy Metals in Cooking Spices Used in IraqPolish Journal of Environmental StudiesRead source →

Which countries grow black pepper with the lowest heavy metals?

In the one study that compared growing origins, Vietnamese pepper had the lowest lead, cadmium and arsenic, and Indian pepper the highest chromium and aluminum, from one to four samples each.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source → The same origin can measure very differently in different markets, as Malaysian pepper did in Australia (100 µg/kg lead) and Ghana (714 µg/kg).3Osei-Safo I, Miezah K, Sackey LNA, Adusei-Gyamf J, Abdul AM · 2024Trace and Heavy Metals in Locally and Imported Spices Sold on Markets in Accra Metropolis, GhanaThe Scientific World JournalRead source →5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →

Do foods seasoned with black pepper also contain heavy metals?

No study in the ledger measured both a pepper and the food made with it. Monitoring records for pepper-seasoned cod and peanuts exist, but their metals cannot be attributed to the pepper.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →

What do the levels in black pepper mean for health?

Because pepper is eaten in small amounts, it contributes little to most diets: a Queensland estimate for all spices and herbs together put lead at about 0.65% of the reference point for adults.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source → A consumer test classed all ten packaged US pepper products as lowest concern at three quarters of a teaspoon a day.17Gill LL, Christian TA · 2021The Trouble With Spices: Heavy Metals in 15 Herbs and SpicesConsumer ReportsRead source →

Can washing or processing remove heavy metals from black pepper?

No study measured metal removal from black pepper itself. Across 23 Iraqi spices pooled, unwashed portions carried 7% more lead and 14% more cadmium than washed portions, consistent with part of the load sitting on the surface.9Matloob MH · 2016Using Stripping Voltammetry to Determine Heavy Metals in Cooking Spices Used in IraqPolish Journal of Environmental StudiesRead source →

Is the arsenic in black pepper inorganic?

Mostly unknown: nearly all studies measured total arsenic only.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →11Kowalska G · 2021The Safety Assessment of Toxic Metals in Commonly Used Herbs, Spices, Tea, and Coffee in PolandInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public HealthRead source → Eight of nine black pepper inorganic arsenic results in GEMS/Food were below detection limits of 5-18 µg/kg, and the ninth was 31 µg/kg.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →

Is white pepper lower in heavy metals than black pepper?

The evidence here cannot say. White pepper was measured separately in the Lebanese survey and is outside this page, and the EU monitoring category mixes the two.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source →10Moussa L, Hassan HF, Savvaidis IN, Karam L · 2024Impact of source, packaging and presence of food safety management system on heavy metals levels in spices and herbsPLoS ONERead source →

Is bulk or loose pepper riskier than packaged pepper?

Not consistently: bulk pepper in Lebanon had more cadmium but less arsenic than packaged, and similar lead.10Moussa L, Hassan HF, Savvaidis IN, Karam L · 2024Impact of source, packaging and presence of food safety management system on heavy metals levels in spices and herbsPLoS ONERead source → The highest lead means came from unpackaged pepper in eastern turkey and retail ground pepper in Libya.4Ziyaina M, Rajab A, Alkhweldi K, Algami W, Al-Toumi O, Rasco B · 2014Lead and cadmium residue determination in spices available in Tripoli City markets (Libya)African Journal of Biochemistry ResearchRead source →8Mercan Yucel U · 2022Determination of Aflatoxin and Heavy Metal Levels in Some Spices Sold as Unpackaged in Van Province and Health Risks Assessment of Heavy MetalsBalikesir Health Sciences JournalRead source →

How common is black pepper above the EU lead limit?

In GEMS/Food, 9 of 362 black pepper lead results (2.5%) were definitely above 600 µg/kg, and 20 of 409 results (4.9%) in the mixed black and white pepper category.1World Health Organization · 2026GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsGEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment ProgrammeRead source → Several small market surveys reported means near or above the limit, including 714 µg/kg in Ghana and 730-820 µg/kg in Libya.3Osei-Safo I, Miezah K, Sackey LNA, Adusei-Gyamf J, Abdul AM · 2024Trace and Heavy Metals in Locally and Imported Spices Sold on Markets in Accra Metropolis, GhanaThe Scientific World JournalRead source →4Ziyaina M, Rajab A, Alkhweldi K, Algami W, Al-Toumi O, Rasco B · 2014Lead and cadmium residue determination in spices available in Tripoli City markets (Libya)African Journal of Biochemistry ResearchRead source →

Is lead added to black pepper on purpose?

There is no evidence of that in the sources here. Lead chromate adulteration has been reported for turmeric, and a Georgian survey concluded that lead is likely added to some spices to enhance color, but its single high black pepper reading was not shown to be adulteration.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →16Ericson B, Gabelaia L, Keith J, Kashibadze T, Beraia N, Sturua L, Kazzi Z · 2020Elevated Levels of Lead (Pb) Identified in Georgian SpicesAnnals of Global HealthRead source →

Why is black pepper so high in aluminum?

Aluminum in Queensland retail pepper ranged from 29 to 540 mg/kg, far above lead or cadmium.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source → The Queensland authors attribute it to aluminum utensils and containers in processing and to accumulation by the plant, and put all spices together at about 3.4% of the tolerable weekly aluminum intake for adults.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →

How can I tell whether a black pepper lead test is good enough?

Check that the laboratory’s quantification limit is far below 600 µg/kg; ICP-MS in the surveys here reached 2-5 µg/kg.2European Commission · 2023Commission Regulation (EU) 2023/915 of 25 April 2023 on maximum levels for certain contaminants in food and repealing Regulation (EC) No 1881/2006Official Journal of the European UnionRead source →5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →11Kowalska G · 2021The Safety Assessment of Toxic Metals in Commonly Used Herbs, Spices, Tea, and Coffee in PolandInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public HealthRead source → Handheld X-ray fluorescence could not see below about 4,000 µg/kg, too high to check the limit.16Ericson B, Gabelaia L, Keith J, Kashibadze T, Beraia N, Sturua L, Kazzi Z · 2020Elevated Levels of Lead (Pb) Identified in Georgian SpicesAnnals of Global HealthRead source →

Does black pepper contain mercury?

Very little: all 26 Polish samples were below 5 µg/kg and Queensland pepper reached at most 17 µg/kg.5Tinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, Jurd S · 2025Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureJournal of Environmental Exposure AssessmentRead source →11Kowalska G · 2021The Safety Assessment of Toxic Metals in Commonly Used Herbs, Spices, Tea, and Coffee in PolandInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public HealthRead source → One Iraqi study reported 311 µg/kg, but it measured mercury after ashing at 550 °C, which drives mercury off, so that value is not used.9Matloob MH · 2016Using Stripping Voltammetry to Determine Heavy Metals in Cooking Spices Used in IraqPolish Journal of Environmental StudiesRead source →

References

Works cited on this page, in citation-number order. See Sources for this page’s source inventory. Each title links to a source record with bibliographic details, reported findings, and document provenance.

  1. GEMS/Food Contaminants database heavy-metal exportsWorld Health Organization · GEMS/Food Contamination Monitoring and Assessment Programme · 2026 · extranet.who.intDataset
  2. Commission Regulation (EU) 2023/915 of 25 April 2023 on maximum levels for certain contaminants in food and repealing Regulation (EC) No 1881/2006European Commission · Official Journal of the European Union · 2023 · eur-lex.europa.euRegulation
  3. Trace and Heavy Metals in Locally and Imported Spices Sold on Markets in Accra Metropolis, GhanaOsei-Safo I, Miezah K, Sackey LNA, Adusei-Gyamf J, and Abdul AM · The Scientific World Journal · 2024 · doi.org/10.1155/2024/3168279Peer-reviewed
  4. Lead and cadmium residue determination in spices available in Tripoli City markets (Libya)Ziyaina M, Rajab A, Alkhweldi K, Algami W, Al-Toumi O, and Rasco B · African Journal of Biochemistry Research · 2014 · doi.org/10.5897/AJBR2014.0766Peer-reviewed
  5. Heavy metal analysis in commercial spices and herbs by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and estimated dietary exposureTinggi U, Farrell M, Porter J, Mitchell S, and Jurd S · Journal of Environmental Exposure Assessment · 2025 · doi.org/10.20517/jeea.2025.10Peer-reviewed
  6. Mineral and Microbiological Analysis of Spices and Aromatic HerbsCicero N, Gervasi T, Durazzo A, Lucarini M, Macrì A, Nava V, et al. · Foods · 2022 · doi.org/10.3390/foods11040548Peer-reviewed
  7. General Standard for Contaminants and Toxins in Food and Feed (CXS 193-1995)Codex Alimentarius Commission · Codex Alimentarius (Joint FAO/WHO Food Standards Programme) · 1995 · www.fao.orgGovernment
  8. Determination of Aflatoxin and Heavy Metal Levels in Some Spices Sold as Unpackaged in Van Province and Health Risks Assessment of Heavy MetalsMercan Yucel U · Balikesir Health Sciences Journal · 2022 · doi.org/10.53424/balikesirsbd.1160866Peer-reviewed
  9. Using Stripping Voltammetry to Determine Heavy Metals in Cooking Spices Used in IraqMatloob MH · Polish Journal of Environmental Studies · 2016 · doi.org/10.15244/pjoes/62401Peer-reviewed
  10. Impact of source, packaging and presence of food safety management system on heavy metals levels in spices and herbsMoussa L, Hassan HF, Savvaidis IN, and Karam L · PLoS ONE · 2024 · doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0307884Peer-reviewed
  11. The Safety Assessment of Toxic Metals in Commonly Used Herbs, Spices, Tea, and Coffee in PolandKowalska G · International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health · 2021 · doi.org/10.3390/ijerph18115779Peer-reviewed
  12. Lead Levels in the Most Consumed Mexican Foods: First Monitoring EffortCantoral A, Betanzos-Robledo L, Collado-López S, García-Martínez BA, Lamadrid-Figueroa H, Mariscal-Moreno RM, et al. · Toxics · 2024 · doi.org/10.3390/toxics12050318Peer-reviewed
  13. Investigation of Element Migration from Aluminum Cooking Pots Using ICP-MSAmmar HR, Saleh SM, Sivasankaran S, Albadri AEAE, and Al-Mufadi FA · Applied Sciences (MDPI) · 2023 · doi.org/10.3390/app132413119Peer-reviewed
  14. Essential and Toxic Element Profiles in Selected Spices from Greater Casablanca, MoroccoSabri S, Sabri C, Salam MR, El Mellouli F, Lafram A, Khallouki H, et al. · World’s Veterinary Journal 15(4): 863-881 · 2025 · doi.org/10.54203/scil.2025.wvj88Peer-reviewed
  15. Determination of the mineral content of spices by ICP-OESSavić S, Petrović S, Petronijević M, Cvetanović A, and Petronijević Ž · Advanced Technologies · 2019 · doi.org/10.5937/savteh1901027sPeer-reviewed
  16. Elevated Levels of Lead (Pb) Identified in Georgian SpicesEricson B, Gabelaia L, Keith J, Kashibadze T, Beraia N, Sturua L, et al. · Annals of Global Health · 2020 · doi.org/10.5334/aogh.3044Peer-reviewed
  17. The Trouble With Spices: Heavy Metals in 15 Herbs and SpicesGill LL and Christian TA · Consumer Reports · 2021 · www.consumerreports.orgNGO
  18. GB 2762-2025: National Food Safety Standard: Maximum Levels of Contaminants in FoodsNational Health Commission and State Administration for Market Regulation · National Food Safety Standard of the People’s Republic of China · 2025 · www.fzmq.gov.cnStandard
  19. QCVN 8-2:2011/BYT National technical regulation on the safety limits of heavy metal contamination in food (English)Vietnam Ministry of Health · Circular No. 02/2011/TT-BYT, QCVN 8-2:2011/BYT · 2011Regulation
  20. FY2018-FY2020 TDS Elements Analytical ResultsU.S. Food and Drug Administration · FDA Total Diet Study · 2022 · fda.govDataset
  21. Health Canada Total Diet Study trace element results, 1993 to 2018Health Canada · Health Canada, Open Government Portal · 2018 · open.canada.caDataset

Sources

Browse black pepper Sources for sources cited on this page and additional discovery candidates. The searchable index distinguishes verified citation use from discovery relationships whose relevance has not been established.

Update history

November 14, 2026 - Added EU, Codex and FSANZ regulatory detail to procurement section; added recalls and enforcement section from openFDA, Health Canada, RASFF, GOV.UK, FSANZ and ACCC queries; added FDA TDS and Health Canada TDS negative-result statements to evidence review; added references 20 and 21.

October 22, 2026 - Rebuilt from every black pepper record in the library: WHO GEMS/Food monitoring results, fifteen survey sources, pooled black pepper comparisons, form, packaging and origin contrasts, verified limits and stage-led controls.