Overview
This study quantified lead (Pb), cadmium (Cd), total arsenic (As), and total mercury (Hg) in 24 frequently consumed crop types — 11 vegetables and 13 fruits/legumes — grown on farms surrounding the industrialized city of Solapur in Maharashtra, India, and in native soil at six sampling locations within a roughly 10 km radius of the city’s industrial hub. Samples were collected during winter (January) and summer (April) of 2017. Crops were analysed by ICP-MS (Agilent 7500) after acid digestion following EPA Method 3050B and FSSAI guidance. Mean concentrations across all 24 commodities were Pb 0.17 ± 0.38 mg/kg > Hg 0.06 ± 0.09 mg/kg > Cd 0.02 ± 0.007 mg/kg > As 0.002 ± 0.003 mg/kg. Vegetables accumulated more metal than fruits across all four analytes; the authors attribute this to higher transpiration rates, greater leaf surface area and physical contamination from dust and rainwater. Garlic exhibited the highest Cd concentration (0.37 mg/kg, exceeding the WHO/FAO standard of 0.2 mg/kg), sugarcane the highest Pb (1.741 mg/kg), and sorghum the highest Hg (0.356 mg/kg). Hazard Index exceeded 1 for garlic (HI ≈ 3.00, driven by Cd then Pb) and sugarcane (HI ≈ 2.22, driven by Pb), indicating non-carcinogenic health concern at modeled intakes. Soil concentrations at all six sites remained below Indian and EU regulatory thresholds.
Key numbers
- n = 24 commodity types (11 vegetables, 13 fruits/legumes); 6 soil sampling sites (winter + summer 2017).
- Analytical method: ICP-MS Agilent 7500; acid digestion per EPA Method 3050B (conc. HNO3 + conc. HCl + 30% H2O2 with heating); 1–2 g sample digested, diluted to 100 mL, centrifuged.
- Sample preparation: rinsed with distilled then deionized water, air-dried, crushed, stored at room temperature.
- Reporting basis: mg/kg, basis not explicitly stated. Paper compares directly to WHO/FAO and Indian standards (which are fresh-weight basis), and reports values consistent with fresh-weight figures; the air-dried preparation step likely represents surface-drying for storage rather than drying to constant weight.
- Speciation: total metals only (tAs and total mercury (tHg); no inorganic arsenic or methylmercury speciation reported).
- Detection: Hg, As, Cd, chromium (Cr) below detection limit (<0.01, <0.5, <0.01, <0.1 mg/kg respectively) in soil at most sites; censored values reported as “<LOD” or “Nil” in Table 2.
Whole-corpus means (mg/kg, Figure 2):
- Total (all 24): Pb 0.173, Cd 0.022, As 0.002, Hg 0.064.
- Vegetables only: Pb 0.344, Cd 0.043, As 0.004, Hg 0.095.
- Fruits/legumes only: Pb 0.052, Cd 0.006, As 0.002, Hg 0.041.
Per-commodity Pb, Cd, As, Hg (mg/kg, Table 4) — highest accumulators:
- Garlic (Allium sativum): Pb 0.774, Cd 0.37, As 0.007, Hg 0.123.
- Sugarcane (Saccharum officinarum): Pb 1.741, Cd 0.001, As 0.001, Hg 0.035.
- Potato (Solanum tuberosum): Pb 0.542, Cd 0.023, As 0.007, Hg 0.013.
- Sorghum (Sorghum arundinaceum): Pb 0.034, Cd 0.001, As 0.001, Hg 0.356.
- Fenugreek (Trigonella foenum-graecum, methi leaves): Pb 0.001, Cd 0.003, As 0.001, Hg 0.235.
- Tamarind (Tamarindus indica): Pb 0.244, Cd 0.001, As 0.001, Hg 0.147.
- Ginger (Zingiber officinale): Pb 0.11, Cd 0.001, As 0.005, Hg 0.14.
- Cabbage (Brassica oleracea): Pb 0.003, Cd 0.006, As 0.002, Hg 0.001.
Standards comparison (paper’s analysis, fresh-weight basis assumed):
- Cd in garlic (0.37 mg/kg) exceeds WHO/FAO 0.2 mg/kg but within Indian 1.5 mg/kg.
- Hg in garlic (0.123), sugarcane (0.035), tamarind (0.147), sorghum (0.356), ginger (0.14) and fenugreek (0.235) all exceed WHO/FAO 0.03 mg/kg standard.
- Pb in all sampled commodities within both Indian (2.5 mg/kg) and WHO/FAO (5.0 mg/kg) standards.
- Soil heavy metals at all six sites below Indian and EU standards.
Human health risk (Table 4, exposure model):
- Daily intake of metal (DIM) modeled with food intake 0.280 kg/person/day and body weight 56 kg/person.
- Oral RfD: As 0.0003, Cd 0.001, Hg 0.01, Pb 0.004 mg/kg/day (USEPA).
- HRI > 1 (single metal): garlic Cd HRI = 1.85; sugarcane Pb HRI = 2.176.
- HI (sum of HRIs across Pb, Cd, As, Hg): garlic 2.996, sugarcane 2.215, potato 0.916, fenugreek 0.150, tamarind 0.400; HI < 1 for all other commodities. HI > 1 indicates non-carcinogenic health risk.
Methods (brief)
ICP-MS quantification (Agilent 7500) of Pb, Cd, As, and Hg in vegetable, fruit, and soil samples. Crop digestion used the repeated-infusion EPA 3050B procedure (conc. HNO3, conc. HCl, 30% H2O2 with heating), aligned with FSSAI Manual of Methods of Analysis of Foods — Metals. Laboratory glassware was rinsed with 1.5% v/v HNO3 and distilled water between uses to prevent carryover. Soil samples (1 kg per site) collected with a stainless steel auger at 50, 150, and 300 cm depths and mixed for a composite sample. Soil also analysed for pH, bulk density, porosity, texture, sand/clay/silt percentages, and additional metals (Ni, Cu, Zn, Mn, Cr). Crops sourced from Chandrahal (SQ-1) farms. No formal LOD/LOQ values stated; censored soil values reported as “<0.01”, “<0.5”, “<0.05”, “<0.1” or “Nil”. No analyte speciation: total As and total Hg only.
The exposure model assumes a fixed daily intake of 0.280 kg/person/day across all commodities and an average body weight of 56 kg/person — likely a per-person aggregate for all 24 commodities combined rather than per-commodity, though the paper does not disambiguate. HRI and HI values in Table 4 are therefore upper-bound estimates if each commodity is treated as the sole dietary contributor.
Implications
Certification (program-only context, not for public wiki): Garlic and sugarcane are flagged as commodities with HI > 1 in this Indian dataset. The Cd value for garlic (0.37 mg/kg, fresh weight assumed) is the most actionable single-commodity finding — it exceeds the WHO/FAO standard by ~85% and is supported by an independent biological mechanism (garlic is a documented Cd hyperaccumulator used in phytoremediation). The widespread Hg exceedances across multiple commodities (sorghum, fenugreek, garlic, ginger, tamarind) are noteworthy because Hg is rarely the primary concern in vegetable/fruit surveillance and may reflect industrial atmospheric deposition near Solapur’s textile and power-loom industries.
Courses: Useful for illustrating (1) multi-commodity occurrence surveillance methodology, (2) coupling soil and produce sampling to test the soil-to-plant translocation hypothesis, (3) the HRI/HI exposure framework with explicit RfD values and a worked example, and (4) how a single commodity (garlic) with hyperaccumulator biology can dominate dietary risk even when other commodities are clean.
App: Garlic, sugarcane, sorghum, fenugreek, tamarind, and ginger add Indian-context data points for the regional contamination layer. The model can flag garlic specifically as a Cd-concern commodity when ingredient lists include garlic from Indian-sourced supply chains.
Wiki pages this source touches
- Lead
- Cadmium
- Arsenic
- Mercury
- Vegetables
- Fruit
- Potatoes
- Root and Tuber Vegetables
- Non-Root Vegetables
- Leafy / Green Vegetables, Other
- Fresh Fruit
- Legumes and Pulses, Other
- Other grain products (oat, millet, quinoa, barley)
Related evidence
Update history
No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.
