Skip to content
Heavy Metal Index

Mineral Constituents of Conserved White Button Mushrooms: Similarities and Differences

Overview

This study characterised the multi-element composition of commercially conserved (pickled and canned) white button mushrooms (Agaricus bisporus) available on the Polish market in 2016, measuring 23 elements — mercury (Hg), Li, Mg, aluminum (Al), Co, nickel (Ni), Cu, arsenic (As), Se, Rb, Sr, Ag, cadmium (Cd), Cs, Sb, Tl, lead (Pb), uranium (U), Ba, chromium (Cr), Zn, Mn, V — across 100 unit packages drawn from 10 product batches and six manufacturers. The toxicologically critical analytes Pb, Cd, total mercury (tHg), and total arsenic (tAs) were present at overall medians of 0.072, 0.040, 0.043, and 0.030 mg/kg dry mass (dm) respectively, all well below the EU maximum levels of 0.30 mg/kg fresh weight (fw) for Pb and 0.20 mg/kg fw for Cd in cultivated Agaricus bisporus under Commission Regulation (EC) No 629/2008 (which, assuming the paper’s ~90% moisture conversion, correspond to roughly 3.0 and 2.0 mg/kg dm). Significant inter-producer variability was observed for Li, As, Rb, Sr, Ag, Ba, and Cs (PC1 of the PCA, 42% of total variance), which the authors attribute to differences in marinade quality (water, salt, vinegar) rather than mushroom substrate. Industrial conserving substantially reduces toxic-element content relative to fresh A. bisporus, particularly for tAs (roughly 10-fold reduction attributed to water-soluble arsenical species leaching during blanching and pickling) and Cd/Pb (roughly an order of magnitude lower medians than fresh).

Key numbers

All values reported as mg/kg dry mass (dm). The paper assumes approximately 90% moisture content in fresh mushrooms when comparing to fresh-weight regulatory limits; the conversions below use that assumption.

Overall median values across all 10 batches (Table 2, with paper text confirming As, Hg, Cd, Ag, Pb, Co, Mn, Cu medians):

ElementOverall median (mg/kg dm)Range of per-batch medians (mg/kg dm)
arsenic (As) (total)0.0300.006–0.19
mercury (Hg) (total)0.0430.028–0.065
cadmium (Cd)0.0400.020–0.080
lead (Pb)0.0720.006–0.18
Ag0.0200.002–0.090
uranium (U)0.0010.0004–0.003
nickel (Ni)1.00.10–1.1
Co0.0150.004–0.02
aluminum (Al)2.81.4–24
chromium (Cr)0.200.071–0.88
V0.0200.007–0.059
Se0.600.19–1.6
Mg330220–560
Mn3.02.4–4.8
Cu108.3–19
Zn2613–71
Li0.0450.01–0.40
Cs0.15 (see verification note)0.004–0.02
Rb1.81.1–4.1
Ba0.650.40–2.9
Sr2.71.6–11

Sb and Tl were measured but the paper does not report overall medians. Sb was detectable in roughly half the batches at per-batch medians of about 0.001–0.009 mg/kg dm; Tl was at or near detection (≈0.001–0.002 mg/kg dm) with “WD” (without data) in several batches. See Table 2 for per-batch detail.

One sliced-pickled batch in glass jars (PC1, 42% of total variance; corresponds to paper’s Batch ID 1) showed statistically elevated Li, As, Rb, Sr, Ag, Cs, and Ba — the authors interpret these as a marinade-quality contribution (water, vinegar, salt mineral content), not substrate contamination. One whole-pickled-in-natural-marinade batch in glass jars (PC2, 19%; Batch ID 9) showed elevated Se, Cr, Zn. Another whole-pickled batch in glass jars (PC3, 18%; Batch ID 2) showed elevated Al, U, V. One canned whole-pickled batch (PC4, 8.9%; Batch ID 4) showed elevated Mn. Two batches (PC5, 5.6%; Batch IDs 5 and 7) had relatively elevated Cd and Hg. Manufacturer identifiers from the paper’s Materials and Methods are omitted per Part 12; the paper’s Polish product-form descriptors (sliced vs whole; in marinade vs in natural marinade) carry the analytically informative content.

Comparison with fresh A. bisporus (from the paper’s literature comparison): fresh Polish A. bisporus showed Cd 0.36 ± 0.47 mg/kg dm (range 0.08–1.2), Pb 0.54 ± 0.54 mg/kg dm (range 0.15–27), Ag 0.19 ± 0.05 mg/kg dm — roughly an order of magnitude higher than the conserved medians in this study. Fresh A. bisporus (Poland) tAs was 0.63 ± 0.37 mg/kg dm versus < 0.05 mg/kg dm in sliced and whole pickled product in this study (roughly a 10-fold reduction). Fresh Hg in Polish A. bisporus has been reported at 0.069, 0.080, 0.11 mg/kg dm (n = 3); this study’s conserved-mushroom median (0.043 mg/kg dm) is roughly half that level.

Aluminum showed the widest inter-batch variability (overall median 2.8 mg/kg dm, batch medians 1.4–24 mg/kg dm). The authors attribute the high-Al batch to marinade quality, noting that Al is not efficiently leached from mushrooms during industrial marinating.

EU regulatory reference: Commission Regulation (EC) No 629/2008 amending 1881/2006 sets cultivated Agaricus bisporus maximum levels at 0.20 mg/kg fw for Cd and 0.30 mg/kg fw for Pb (paper §“As, Hg, Cd, Ag, Pb and Se”, referencing the 2.0 and 3.0 mg/kg dm equivalents assuming 90% moisture). All 10 batches in this study were well below these limits on both bases.

Methods

ICP-MS DRC (PerkinElmer SCIEX ELAN 6100 DRC II, dynamic reaction chamber with NH3 and O2 reaction gases) for 22 elements; CV-AAS thermal-decomposition direct mercury analyser (MA-2000, Nippon Instruments Corporation, Takatsuki, Japan) for Hg. Sample preparation: drained mushrooms were rinsed in 10% HNO3-soaked / DI-water-rinsed glassware, frozen at −30 °C, lyophilised (Steris LYOVAC GT2), and ground to fine powder in porcelain mortars. Subsamples of 300–400 mg were digested in 5 ml concentrated HNO3 (65%, Suprapur, Merck) in closed PTFE vessels under microwave (CEM MARSXpress: 1.2 kW, ramp 1–10 min to 100 °C, hold 1–10 min, ramp 2–10 min to −800 psi, hold 2–10 min at 100 °C, 5 min cooling); digests diluted to 10 ml with double-deionised water. Internal standards: 45Sc, 74Ge, 103Rh, 159Tb. QA/QC verified using Polish certified reference materials CS-M-2 (dried Agaricus campestris powder) and CS-M-3 (dried Boletus edulis powder), Institute of Nuclear Chemistry and Technology, Warsaw.

Sampling design: 10 product batches representing 6 manufacturers (brand identifiers omitted per Part 12; the paper’s Materials and Methods names each producer). 80 unit packages were in glass jars and 20 were in cans (canned packages all from one of the six manufacturers); samples were drawn randomly from retail shops in the city of Gdańsk in 2016.

Statistical analysis: Statistica v8.0 (StatSoft). Principal Component Analysis with Varimax rotation on 18 elements × 10 batches; factor-loading thresholds 0.75 (strong), 0.75–0.5 (moderate), 0.5–0.3 (weak). Five statistically significant PCs accounted for 93% of variability.

Basis: dry mass throughout. The paper performs fresh-weight conversions where comparing to EU limits or external studies, using an assumed ≈ 90% moisture content for fresh A. bisporus.

Implications

Certification: Conserved/pickled mushrooms appear to be a low-risk product for the four primary regulated analytes (Pb, Cd, tHg, tAs) on the Polish market under this 2016 sampling. The pickling process itself functions as a partial decontamination step: water-soluble arsenical species and ionic Cd/Pb leach into the marinade during blanching and brining, yielding roughly 10-fold lower tAs and order-of-magnitude lower Cd/Pb medians relative to fresh A. bisporus. The dominant within-product variability source is marinade quality (water, vinegar, salt mineral composition), not mushroom substrate. Al is the highest-concentration non-essential element (per-batch medians up to 24 mg/kg dm) and is not efficiently removed by pickling.

Courses: Strong worked example for “processing changes the heavy-metal risk profile” — useful for teaching the distinction between substrate-driven contamination (mushroom growing medium) and processing-driven contamination (marinade ingredients). The PC1 vs PC2 vs PC3 vs PC4 vs PC5 decomposition illustrates how analytical chemistry plus PCA can attribute contamination to ingredient inputs vs raw material.

App: Pickled and canned white button mushrooms can be assigned low-risk contamination profiles for Pb, Cd, tHg, and tAs on the basis of this study, with the caveat that inter-batch variability of up to roughly 10× was observed for several elements (Li, As, Rb, Sr, Ag, Ba, Cs). Al is the highest-concentration trace contaminant and is driven by marinade quality. Lot-to-lot variation is real and relevant for any per-serving estimator.

Microbiome: Not addressed.

Update history

No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.