Skip to content
Heavy Metal Index
A pale semi-firm cheese block and slices beside a cut white mozzarella ball illustrating al sidawi2021 heavy metals milk cheese kvemo kartli georgia research context.

Heavy Metal Levels in Milk and Cheese Produced in the Kvemo Kartli Region, Georgia

Overview

This study characterized 11 elements (Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, nickel (Ni), Cu, Zn, Se, Mo, cadmium (Cd), Pb) in raw cow’s milk (n=195, 9 villages) and traditional Georgian cheeses (n=25; 16 Imeruli, 9 Sulguni) from the Kvemo Kartli region of Georgia, an agricultural area along the Mashavera River with documented soil, water, and pasture contamination from the Madneuli polymetallic mining plant (operating since 1975) and the RMG gold/copper mine (since 2014). Quantification was by ICP-MS (Agilent 7800) on samples ashed with concentrated HNO3 (65%) in a muffle furnace, with quality control via ISO 17034 traceable CRMs and the GOST 26929-94 Georgian national method. Mean Cd in milk was below LOD (<0.001 mg/L) in all villages. Mean lead (Pb) in milk ranged 0.004–0.048 mg/L across villages, with seven individual samples exceeding the EU limit of 0.020 mg/L in Kvemo Bolnisi, Bolnisi, Mtskneti, and Ratawani. Cu means in Sabereti and Vanati (0.568 and 0.592 mg/L) exceeded the EU limit of 0.4 mg/L. In cheese, Pb in both Imeruli (mean 0.121 mg/kg ww) and Sulguni (mean 0.258 mg/kg ww) exceeded the EU/Codex maximum level of 0.020 mg/kg but were below the Georgian regulation MPC of 0.500 mg/kg; Mn, chromium (Cr), Se, Mo, Zn, and Fe in both cheeses also exceeded the cited permissible limits. A t-test showed Sulguni cheese had significantly higher Cr, Se, Mn, Pb, Co, Cu, and Ni than Imeruli cheese, consistent with the fact that Sulguni is made by re-processing Imeruli curd and that heavy metals partition preferentially into the casein/curd fraction. A second t-test on milk samples grouped by river basin showed significantly higher Fe, Mn, Cu, Pb, and Cr in the Mashavera-region villages than in the Khrami-region villages.

Key numbers

All milk values in mg/L; cheese values in mg/kg wet weight (ww). Method: ICP-MS (Agilent 7800). n=195 milk samples; n=25 cheese samples (16 Imeruli, 9 Sulguni).

Table 1 — Raw cow’s milk by village (mean ± SD, mg/L):

VillagenCrMnFeCoNiCuZnSeMoCdPb
Bolnisi220.002 ± 0.00160.036 ± 0.0260.987 ± 0.841<0.0010.001 ± 0.00070.274 ± 0.3702.975 ± 1.4230.007 ± 0.01060.014 ± 0.0022<0.0010.006 ± 0.0079
Chapala220.004 ± 0.0020.075 ± 0.0101.541 ± 1.2840.0056 ± 0.0030.017 ± 0.0040.173 ± 0.0793.458 ± 2.0540.042 ± 0.0230.022 ± 0.009<0.0010.008 ± 0.006
Daba Kazreti240.002 ± 0.00360.044 ± 0.06171.391 ± 2.03870.004 ± 0.01070.002 ± 0.00160.133 ± 0.14042.411 ± 1.71290.005 ± 0.00380.009 ± 0.0068<0.0010.005 ± 0.0039
Kvemo Bolnisi240.003 ± 0.0020.036 ± 0.0110.717 ± 0.5250.003 ± 0.0030.007 ± 0.0050.133 ± 0.0553.116 ± 0.9590.020 ± 0.0200.034 ± 0.025<0.0010.048 ± 0.204
Khidiskuri220.001 ± 0.00130.023 ± 0.02290.502 ± 0.38150.007 ± 0.01720.006 ± 0.00750.120 ± 0.08112.223 ± 1.97520.020 ± 0.01420.011 ± 0.0092<0.0010.009 ± 0.0067
Mtskneti220.003 ± 0.00140.049 ± 0.01851.089 ± 1.55860.005 ± 0.00300.002 ± 0.00260.142 ± 0.05443.916 ± 0.52270.006 ± 0.00220.022 ± 0.0138<0.0010.008 ± 0.0114
Ratawani230.003 ± 0.0020.058 ± 0.0232.650 ± 2.1370.002 ± 0.0010.003 ± 0.0030.404 ± 0.1894.209 ± 1.6710.011 ± 0.0060.035 ± 0.025<0.0010.013 ± 0.015
Sabereti120.002 ± 0.00060.032 ± 0.00595.537 ± 0.5251<0.0010.002 ± 0.00090.568 ± 0.14452.862 ± 0.34140.011 ± 0.00630.004 ± 0.0017<0.0010.004 ± 0.0029
Vanati240.004 ± 0.00250.079 ± 0.03616.150 ± 2.53170.002 ± 0.00170.004 ± 0.00290.592 ± 0.26984.294 ± 1.07830.007 ± 0.00340.047 ± 0.0108<0.0010.012 ± 0.0115

Permissible limits cited (milk, mg/L): Cr 0.02 [Flynn 1992]; Mn 0.02–0.05 [Knowles et al. 2006]; Fe 0.7 [Storelli et al. 2007; Safonov 2020]; Co 0.006 [Flynn 1992; Storelli et al. 2007; Hurley 1997]; Ni 0.027 [Flynn 1992; European Commission 2001]; Cu 0.4 [European Commission, EU [68]]; Zn 3–5 [WHO 1996], 2–6 [Pechovà et al. 2008]; Se 0.5 [EFSA 2011]; Mo 0.05 [Flynn 1992]; Cd 0.2 [Georgian Ministry of Labour and Health, Social Affairs 2001]; Pb 0.020 [Codex Alimentarius 1995; European Commission 2006] and 0.500 [Georgian regulation 2001].

LOD, milk (mg/L): Cr 0.00013; Mn 0.00010; Fe 0.00041; Co 0.00001; Ni 0.00007; Cu 0.00010; Zn 0.00033; Se 0.00533; Mo 0.00005; Cd 0.00001; Pb 0.00006.

Table 2 — Cheese (mean ± SD, mg/kg wet weight):

ElementImeruli (n=16)Sulguni (n=9)LOD
chromium (Cr)0.035 ± 0.0170.079 ± 0.0570.0013
Mn0.886 ± 0.5952.348 ± 2.2670.00033
Fe69.09 ± 64.918101.1 ± 91.1660.00349
Co0.013 ± 0.0110.03 ± 0.0260.00003
nickel (Ni)0.011 ± 0.0070.026 ± 0.0290.00034
Cu1.261 ± 0.7392.463 ± 2.3140.00106
Zn75.86 ± 52.528124.8 ± 97.7750.00092
Se1.003 ± 0.9013.06 ± 3.1440.01107
Mo0.289 ± 0.1110.401 ± 0.2540.00023
cadmium (Cd)0.002 ± 0.00150.007 ± 0.0030.00024
lead (Pb)0.121 ± 0.0930.258 ± 0.2150.00018

Lead exceedance in milk. Seven individual milk samples exceeded the EU/Codex Pb limit of 0.020 mg/L (Section 4 Conclusions), in the villages Kvemo Bolnisi, Bolnisi, Mtskneti, and Ratawani. The Kvemo Bolnisi village mean (0.048 ± 0.204 mg/L) carries an SD several times the mean, indicating that the exceedance is driven by a small number of high-end samples within an otherwise low-Pb local distribution. The abstract reports an individual-sample Pb range of “0.027 to 1003 mg L⁻¹” in the exceedance subset; the 1003 mg L⁻¹ upper bound is two to four orders of magnitude above any per-village mean reported in Table 1 and is treated as a typographical error in the abstract (likely intended 1.003 mg L⁻¹). The per-village means in Table 1 remain the authoritative summary of the milk Pb distribution.

Copper exceedance in milk. Mean Cu in Sabereti (0.568 mg/L) and Vanati (0.592 mg/L) exceeded the EU permissible limit of 0.4 mg/L (European Commission [68]); the abstract’s per-village range for Cu in these villages is given as 0.42–1.28 mg/L (individual samples). Cu was below the EU limit at the village-mean level in the other seven villages.

Cheese vs milk: Pb and Cd partitioning. Pb in Imeruli (mean 0.121 mg/kg ww) and Sulguni (mean 0.258 mg/kg ww) exceeded the EU/Codex Pb ML of 0.020 mg/kg ww but were below the Georgian MPC of 0.500 mg/kg. Cd in cheese (Imeruli 0.002, Sulguni 0.007 mg/kg ww) was below the Georgian MPC of 0.2 mg/kg. The authors note that during cheesemaking κ-casein hydrolysis partitions Pb and Cd preferentially into the casein/curd fraction (citing Maas et al. 2011: 60% of Cd to curd, 14% to whey), concentrating these metals in the finished cheese relative to the source milk.

Other element exceedances in cheese (paper’s own classification, Section 4 Conclusions): Mn, Cr, Se, Mo, Zn, and Fe in both Imeruli and Sulguni exceeded the cited permissible limits. Co, Ni, and Cu in both cheeses were below their cited permissible limits.

Table 3 — t-test, Imeruli vs Sulguni cheese (alt. hypothesis: Imeruli < Sulguni; df=23):

ElementtpMean diffCohen’s d
chromium (Cr)2.9020.0040.0441.209
Mn2.4680.0111.4611.028
Fe1.0240.15832.030—
Co2.2100.0190.0160.921
nickel (Ni)1.8320.0400.0130.763
Cu1.9360.0331.2020.807
Zn1.6420.05748.973—
Se2.6270.0082.1821.095
Mo1.5740.0650.112—
cadmium (Cd)1.4890.0750.002—
lead (Pb)2.2290.0180.1370.929

The authors emphasise Cr (Cohen’s d 1.209) and Se (Cohen’s d 1.095) as showing the largest effect sizes; Pb, Mn, and Co also showed large effects.

Table 4 — t-test, milk Mashavera vs Khrami river basin (alt. hypothesis: Khrami < Mashavera; df=189; means in mg/L; n=146 Mashavera, n=45 Khrami):

ElementtpMean MashaveraMean KhramiCohen’s d
chromium (Cr)1.7070.0450.0030.0030.291
Mn2.8760.0020.0530.0370.490
Fe4.118<0.0012.4930.8550.702
Co1.3830.084———
nickel (Ni)0.7700.221———
Cu2.0070.0230.2870.2020.342
Zn1.2260.111———
Se0.0830.467———
Mo-0.0160.506———
cadmium (Cd)-0.2060.582———
lead (Pb)1.7490.0410.0090.0060.298

Fe shows the largest river-basin effect (Cohen’s d 0.702); Mn second (0.490). Pb, Cr, and Cu also significantly higher in Mashavera-basin milk despite small effect sizes.

Methods (brief)

ICP-MS quantification on an Agilent 7800 (Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA, USA). Sample preparation: milk samples 50.0 mL in duplicate placed in open porcelain crucibles treated with 1 mL concentrated HNO3 (65%) and heated on a hot plate (IKA, Germany) until fumes stopped, then dry-ashed in a muffle furnace (Naberthem L15/11, Germany) ramped from 250 °C to 450 °C (50 °C every 30 min); residue dissolved in dilute HNO3, dried at 140 °C, and re-ashed at 300 °C for 30 min until white ash was obtained; final dissolution in 5 mL concentrated HNO3 and dilution to 25 mL. Cheese samples 10.0 g in duplicate were treated with 1 mL HNO3 (65%) diluted 1:1 with deionized water, ashed by the same protocol, and diluted to 50 mL. Two reagent blanks were run with each batch.

Quality control: 10-point calibration curves per element (nine standards + one blank) with R ≥ 0.9999 before analysis; daily internal control materials; duplicate analyses every 20 samples; participation in inter-laboratory proficiency testing; CRMs prepared per ISO 17034 and traceable to NIST. Method conformed to GOST 26929-94 (Georgian national standard for analysis of toxic elements in food). Measurement uncertainty calculated per the EURACHEM/CITAC guide. The state research institute laboratory participates in proficiency programs but is not independently accredited. Statistics: SPSS 27.0 (IBM, Armonk, NY, USA); independent-samples t-test; Cohen’s d for effect size; Vovk–Sellke maximum p-ratio also reported.

LOD (milk, mg/L) and LOD (cheese, mg/kg ww) are listed in ## Key numbers above.

Implications

Certification: Kvemo Kartli is a documented heavy-metal-contaminated agricultural zone driven by adjacent active mining (Madneuli polymetallic plant since 1975; RMG gold/copper mine since 2014) and Mashavera River pollution. Pb in the finished cheese exceeded the EU/Codex ML of 0.020 mg/kg ww in both traditional cheese types by 6× (Imeruli) and 13× (Sulguni); milk Pb passed the EU limit on a village-mean basis in all 9 villages but had 7 individual-sample exceedances. The cheese-vs-milk Pb concentration ratio (Sulguni 0.258 mg/kg ww vs Kvemo Bolnisi milk 0.048 mg/L mean) demonstrates that fermentation/curd-formation concentrates Pb from milk by a factor of several × on a wet-weight basis, consistent with the casein-binding mechanism the authors cite. Sourcing dairy from mining-adjacent regions for HMTc-relevant categories requires sample-level Pb and Cd testing at the finished-cheese stage, not only at the milk stage, because the cheese matrix is the binding endpoint.

The river-basin t-test (Table 4) shows that the milk supply along the Mashavera River basin carries significantly higher Pb, Cu, Fe, Mn, and Cr loads than the Khrami basin within the same Kvemo Kartli region. This is an explicit geographic-supply-chain stratification within a single national jurisdiction.

Courses: Demonstrates the soil → pasture → animal → milk → cheese contamination pathway in an active mining region, and the casein-mediated metal partitioning that concentrates Pb in cheese during processing. The Madneuli/RMG mining context provides a well-documented point-source case study. The paper also documents that Imeruli and Sulguni are traditional Georgian cheeses that cannot be exported (do not meet international standards) and are consumed only domestically, which is the relevant exposure framing.

App: Contributes per-village raw cow’s milk and traditional Georgian cheese occurrence data under a mining-adjacent contamination scenario to the Milk and Dairy contamination profile. Per-element and per-village means with SD are usable as a regional reference for the Caucasus mining belt.

Update history

No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.