Skip to content
Heavy Metal Index

Organic versus Conventional Wheat Bran Content in Some Heavy Metals

Overview

Aioanei and Pop compared lead, cadmium, copper and zinc in wheat bran from one conventional and one organic production system in North-East Romania over two years, using AAS after dry ashing. Results are means on a dry-matter basis with n=5 per group per year. The paper follows animal-feed sampling standards and compares results with an EU feed limit.

Key numbers

  • Cadmium: conventional 0.007 mg/kg DM in both 2011 and 2012; organic 0.005 (2011) and 0.006 (2012) mg/kg DM (Tab. 1, p. 184).
  • Lead: rows labelled “Org.” 0.04 (2011) and 0.06 (2012) mg/kg DM; rows labelled “Eco.” 0.02 and 0.04 mg/kg DM (Tab. 1). The table has no “Conv.” lead row although the text says lead was higher in conventional bran.
  • Feed maximum limits cited: lead 30 mg/kg, cadmium 1 mg/kg (Regulation (EU) No 574/2011).

Methods (brief)

AAS after dry ashing (SR EN ISO 14082:2003); sampling and preparation per feed standards SR EN ISO 6497 and 6498. One-way ANOVA and point biserial correlation in SPSS. No LOD, certified reference material or recovery is reported.

Evidence Fitness

Small two-site comparison (20 samples in total) with means and standard errors only. The lead row labels conflict with the text, so which system had higher lead cannot be confirmed; values are used as printed. The bran appears to be feed-grade material. Wheat bran is a proxy for wheat flour and for the wheat-cereal-biscuits page, which is not linked. No DOI is printed in the PDF; peer review is unverified (the journal states double-blind review, but no record for this article was seen).