Overview
Tu and colleagues conducted a three-year field trial in Xingan County, Jiangxi Province, China, testing whether combined application of biochar and lime (BL treatment) could remediate acidic red soil, reduce exchangeable aluminum toxicity, and sustain peanut yield under continuous monoculture cropping. The study compared four treatments: a no-amendment control (CK), biochar alone (BC at 6,000 kg per hectare per year in year 1, reduced in subsequent years), lime alone (LM at 900 kg per hectare per year), and combined biochar-lime (BL) across four replicated 30-square-meter plots per treatment. The key finding is that BL synergistically outperformed either amendment alone on soil chemistry, microbial activity, peanut antioxidant physiology, and pod yield, while allowing a 53% reduction in amendment inputs by year 3.
This paper is agronomic-mitigation and soil-pathway evidence for aluminum toxicity in peanut production, not a retail food occurrence survey.
Study design
The experimental site is red soil formed from Quaternary red clay in Baima Village, Sanfu Town, Xingan County, Jiangxi Province (115 degrees 24 minutes 52 seconds E, 27 degrees 51 minutes 47 seconds N). At baseline, soil pH was 4.78, soil organic matter was 18.3 g per kg, alkali-hydrolyzable nitrogen content was 81.36 mg per kg, available phosphorus 26.69 mg per kg, available potassium 89 mg per kg, and exchangeable aluminum (Ex-Al3+) was 10.57 and 2.32 cmol per kg. The site had been under continuous peanut monoculture for three years prior to the study and had never received biochar or lime amendments. The growing season in year 1 (Y2022) was notably drier than years 2 and 3, with precipitation approximately 20% below the ten-year average during the pod-filling stage.
Biochar was produced from rice straw and husk feedstock pyrolyzed at 500 degrees Celsius under oxygen-limited conditions, with pH 9.30, total carbon 605.7 g per kg, total N/P/K contents of 7.6, 4.23, and 0.88 g per kg respectively, specific surface area 6.25 m2 per g, average pore volume 0.15 cm3 per g, cation exchange capacity (CEC) 33.22 cmol per kg, and ash content 32.16%. Cadmium content of the biochar was 0.10 mg per kg. Lime was calcium oxide (CaO, 75% purity, pH 12.2). Basal fertilization was identical across all treatments: 120 kg N, 75 kg P2O5, and 120 kg K2O per hectare per year. Soil conditioner application rates (Table 1 of the paper) were reduced in Y2023 and Y2024 for the BL treatment to assess residual effects, with biochar declining from 9,000 to 4,500 to 3,000 kg per hectare and lime from 1,200 to 750 to 300 kg per hectare across the three years.
Key numbers
Soil pH and exchangeable aluminum
BL elevated soil pH by 19.25 to 25.31% relative to initial conditions, outperforming CK, BC, and LM across all three years (Figure 1a). Soil Ex-Al3+ content under BL was lower than CK, BC, and LM by 40.05%, 68.47%, and 78.01% respectively in Y2022, and remained the lowest of all treatments across all three years (Figure 1d). CEC under BL increased by 36.29% per year (Figure 1c), strongly correlated with soil organic matter (SOM) accumulation (R2 = 0.81, p less than 0.001; Figure 1b).
Soil organic matter and cation exchange capacity
BL increased SOM by 31.17 to 46.67% annually compared to CK, establishing a positive feedback between SOM accumulation and pH stabilization. CEC correlated strongly with SOM (R2 = 0.81, p less than 0.001).
Soil nutrient availability (Table 2)
Soil available phosphorus (mg per kg) and potassium (mg per kg) under different treatments across years (mean):
| Treatment | Avail. P Y2022 | Avail. P Y2023 | Avail. P Y2024 | Avail. K Y2022 | Avail. K Y2023 | Avail. K Y2024 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CK | 24.96 | 23.98 | 25.02 | 79.98 | 74.36 | 77.98 |
| BC | 31.97 | 30.07 | 28.03 | 105.08 | 100.90 | 95.05 |
| LM | 28.06 | 26.56 | 25.09 | 85.02 | 80.94 | 80.94 |
| BL | 53.03 | 32.05 | 30.00 | 113.06 | 108.00 | 100.90 |
(Within each column, means followed by different lowercase letters differ significantly per LSD post-hoc test at p less than or equal to 0.05; large effect sizes, eta-squared greater than or equal to 0.14.)
The authors note that biochar’s porous structure retained potassium, reducing leaching losses, while lime prevented iron and aluminum oxides from fixing phosphorus.
Soil microbial biomass carbon
BL enhanced soil microbial biomass carbon (SMBC) by 60.00%, 50.72%, and 48.99% compared to CK in Y2022, Y2023, and Y2024, respectively (Table 3). BL exceeded BC alone by 14.08%, 13.22%, and 17.27% in the same years, and exceeded LM alone by 39.13%, 40.15%, and 40.46% across the three years. SOM and SMBC were strongly linearly correlated (R2 = 0.77, p less than 0.001; Figure 2b), confirming that carbon availability is a key driver of microbial activity.
Soil enzyme activity
Urease activity increased by 49.84% under BL relative to CK (Figure 3a); phosphatase activity rose by 46.14% under BL relative to CK (Figure 3b). The authors attribute urease increases to lime-facilitated urea-hydrolyzing microorganism growth, and phosphatase increases to enhanced microbial P demand driven by biochar carbon supply.
Peanut antioxidant physiology (Table 4)
Malondialdehyde (MDA) in peanut leaves, a marker of lipid peroxidation and oxidative stress, decreased under all treatments relative to CK. BL reduced MDA by 15.46%, 21.86%, and 22.71% compared to CK in Y2022, Y2023, and Y2024, respectively; and by 6.94%, 8.33%, and 8.33% compared to BC; and by 3.94%, 4.68%, and 5.34% compared to LM. BL also increased superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity by 29.24% and peroxidase (POD) activity by 37.53% relative to CK.
Peanut pod yield (Table 6)
Pod yield (kg per hectare, mean with 95% confidence interval) across treatments and years:
| Treatment | Y2022 | Y2023 | Y2024 |
|---|---|---|---|
| CK | 3,429 (3,392 to 3,466) | 3,086 (3,031 to 3,140) | 2,759 (2,697 to 2,821) |
| BC | 3,620 (3,559 to 3,656) | 3,433 (3,378 to 3,487) | 3,300 (3,328 to 3,362) |
| LM | 3,831 (3,594 to 3,883) | 3,494 (3,440 to 3,549) | 2,960 (2,334 to 3,358) |
| BL | 4,005 (3,968 to 4,042) | 3,884 (3,830 to 3,939) | 3,819 (3,757 to 3,881) |
BL increased pod yield relative to CK by 16.80%, 26.59%, and 38.39% in Y2022, Y2023, and Y2024, respectively (Table 6). BL exceeded BC alone by 10.65%, 13.16%, and 15.70%, and exceeded LM by 6.18%, 11.16%, and 15.86% across the three years. The year-to-year yield reduction rate under BL was approximately -4.66% from Y2022 to Y2024, compared to CK’s -19.53% over the same period.
Number of fruits per plant and kernel percentage (Table 5)
BL produced the highest number of full fruits per plant and highest kernel percentage across all three years. Full fruit counts (mean) for BL were 14.13, 13.79, and 13.41 per plant in Y2022, Y2023, and Y2024, compared to CK values of 9.81, 9.04, and 8.22, respectively. Kernel percentages under BL were 72.94%, 72.77%, and 72.31% versus CK values of 72.10%, 70.07%, and 70.05% (all treatment differences statistically significant at p less than 0.001; large effect sizes).
Economic analysis (Table 7)
Three-year net income (Chinese yuan per hectare): BL 105,044; LM 88,058; BC 71,392. Although BL had higher total costs (111,127 CNY per hectare) than LM (89,624 CNY), the yield premium (peanut price 8.6 CNY per kg) generated sufficient return to exceed LM net income by 22.91%. Economic calculations used local market prices from Jiangxi Province (2022 to 2024): biochar 800 CNY per tonne, lime 500 CNY per tonne, transportation 50 CNY per tonne, application 30 CNY per tonne, labor 30 CNY per hour.
Methods (brief)
Experimental site. Baima Village, Sanfu Town, Xingan County, Jiangxi Province, China. Mid-subtropical climate, mean annual temperature 17.7 degrees Celsius, mean annual rainfall 1627 mm, annual evaporation 1268 mm, frost-free period 274 days. Red soil from Quaternary red clay; baseline soil pH 4.78, SOM 18.3 g per kg, Ex-Al3+ 10.57 and 2.32 cmol per kg.
Treatments. Randomized complete block design; four treatments (CK, BC, LM, BL), four replicate plots each (30 m2 per plot). Peanut Ganhua 5 cultivar, planted at 20 cm by 40 cm spacing, two seeds per hole. Mid-April planting, late-August harvest, three growing seasons (Y2022, Y2023, Y2024).
Soil sampling. Post-harvest composite 0 to 20 cm depth samples from five random points per plot, air-dried, sieved to less than 2 mm. pH by PB-10 pH meter (soil:water 1:2.5 ratio). SOM by potassium permanganate oxidation capacity method. Available N, P, K, and CEC by standard methods cited in the paper. Ex-Al3+ by potassium chloride extraction. SMBC by chloroform fumigation-extraction. Urease by indophenol colorimetry. Phosphatase by sodium phenylphosphate colorimetric method.
Plant sampling. Fully expanded leaves at podding stage analyzed for SOD (NBT photoreduction), POD (guaiacol oxidation), and MDA (thiobarbituric acid reaction). Yield components at maturity: pods per plant, 100-pod weight, kernel percentage. Pod yield in kg per hectare calculated from plot area.
Instrument and LOD/LOQ. The paper does not report the specific analytical instrument used for soil chemistry measurements, nor does it report formal LOD/LOQ values.
CRM recovery. Certified reference material recovery is not reported.
Statistical analysis. Microsoft Excel 2019 and SPSS 26.0. One-way ANOVA with LSD post-hoc tests (p less than 0.05). Results presented as means plus or minus standard deviation, n = 4 (independent field plot replicates).
Evidence fitness
This source provides context-only and agronomic-mitigation mechanism evidence. It is not a retail food occurrence survey and reports no measured aluminum or other metal concentrations in peanut kernels or finished food products. The biochar cadmium content (0.10 mg per kg) is noted by the authors as low, suggesting inherent safety of the feedstock, but no analysis of peanut kernel metal concentrations was performed. The study’s value to the wiki is as soil-pathway evidence documenting how exchangeable aluminum toxicity in acidic red soils affects peanut productivity, and how combined biochar-lime amendment reduces that toxicity over multiple growing seasons. Evidence tier A reflects the peer-reviewed journal quality and three-year replicated field design; evidence fitness is context-only for contamination profiling.
Limitations
The authors identify several limitations. Microbial analysis was confined to biomass carbon and enzyme activity; molecular community structure analysis would provide deeper mechanistic understanding. Microbial community dynamics were not quantitatively monitored over time, so the specific role of biochar in community succession during peanut monoculture remediation remains unresolved. The biochar used in this study had low heavy metal content; feedstock source dictates inherent safety, and high-application-rate biochar from other feedstocks warrants further investigation. Future research priorities identified by the authors include: (i) determining optimal BL application rates for soils with varying initial acidification levels; (ii) quantifying long-term (greater than 5 years) soil carbon sequestration potential; and (iii) evaluating adaptability across diverse agro-ecological zones. The study was conducted in a single agro-ecological zone (Jiangxi red soils), and applicability to other soil types, climates, and biochar feedstocks requires local validation. The authors also note that the high biochar application rate in year 1 (6,000 to 9,000 kg per hectare) presents an economic barrier to initial adoption.
Regulatory context
No regulatory maximum levels for exchangeable soil aluminum in China or internationally are cited by this study. The EU, Codex, and FDA do not set soil aluminum limits relevant to this study design. The paper cites published agronomic thresholds stating that exchangeable aluminum exceeding 2 cmol per kg is phytotoxic to peanuts, referencing soil science literature rather than food safety regulations.
Implications
Certification: This paper is not direct peanut-product occurrence evidence and contributes no data to the HMT&C threshold pool. It is agronomic-mitigation evidence on aluminum toxicity in the peanut production environment.
Courses: Useful for illustrating how acidic red soils create aluminum toxicity stress in peanut monoculture systems, how combined biochar-lime amendments address both chemical and biological constraints over multiple seasons, and how residual amendment effects allow reduced input rates in later years without yield loss. The economic analysis (22.91% higher three-year net income for BL versus LM alone) provides a practical cost-benefit framing for amendment adoption.
App: No contamination_profile blocks are modified. The cadmium content of the biochar feedstock (0.10 mg per kg) is noted but does not constitute peanut occurrence data.
Microbiome: The paper documents SMBC increases and urease/phosphatase enzyme activity responses under biochar-lime amendment. These findings are relevant to WikiBiome content on how soil amendment affects microbial nutrient cycling in acidic agricultural soils, particularly the feedback loop between SOM, SMBC, and enzyme activity.
Provenance notes
Open access under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0). Published online 7 November 2025. DOI 10.1038/s41598-025-24775-1. PMC ID PMC12594868, PMID 41203708. Source retrieved from PMC Open Access S3. SHA-256: 8674932758816a506dcf4692431840748b92f3b443f6ac124ff932f76b3edc90. Corresponding author: Q. Tu (qihu@163.com). Funded by the Jiangxi “Double Thousand Plan” Long-term Innovation and Leading Talents Fund Project in Natural Sciences (202212800004). Author affiliations: School of Earth Sciences, East China University of Technology, Nanchang; Department of Economics, Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa, USA; Xingan County Agricultural Industry Development Center, Ji’an, Jiangxi.
Related evidence
- Remediation evidence; drivers and interventions
- Soil-to-plant transfer of heavy metals
- Aluminum
- Peanuts
Update history
No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.
