Overview
This study measured lead (Pb), cadmium (Cd), chromium (Cr), mercury (Hg), and As in 93 imported cat and dog food products collected from Chinese supermarkets and store chains (Beijing, Shenzhen, Wuhan) in 2021-2022 and conducted an acute hazard index (aHI) assessment for cats and dogs across body-weight categories. Flame atomic absorption spectrometry (FAAS) quantified Pb, Cd, Cr; atomic fluorescence spectrometry (AFS) quantified Hg and arsenic (As). Cr and As were detected in 100% of samples; Hg in 97.85%. Cr had the highest average concentrations of the five metals. Against the Chinese Hygienical Standard for Pet Feed (Announcement No. 20 of 2018), 8.60% of samples exceeded the Pb limit and 26.88% exceeded the Cr limit; Cd, Hg, and As remained within their limits across all 93 samples. Dry food showed higher contamination rates and higher mean concentrations of Pb, Cd, Cr, and As than canned food. Combined contamination by three or more metals was the norm; Cr+Hg+As was the dominant triad. aHI values for Cr, Pb, and As exceeded the safety threshold (>1) across all simulated body weights.
Key numbers
93 samples total: 45 cat food, 48 dog food; 79 dry, 14 canned. Imports from USA (32), Spain (29), Thailand (17), Germany (10), New Zealand (5).
Chinese Hygienical Standard for Pet Feed legal limits (mg/kg, per published Table 2): Pb 5, Cd 2, Cr 5, Hg 0.3, As 10.
All samples (n=93; published Table 2):
- Pb: 39 contaminated (41.94% above LOQ 2 mg/kg); 8 above legal limit (8.60%); min 2.07, max 5.80, mean 3.63 mg/kg
- Cd: 29 contaminated (31.18% above LOQ 0.20 mg/kg); 0 above limit; min 0.0200, max 0.279, mean 0.138 mg/kg
- Cr: 93 contaminated (100% above LOD 150 µg/kg); 25 above limit (26.88%); min 0.48, max 15.47, mean 3.47 mg/kg
- Hg: 91 contaminated (97.85% above LOD 0.15 µg/kg); 0 above limit; min 0.001, max 0.027, mean 0.011 mg/kg
- As: 93 contaminated (100% above LOD 0.010 mg/kg); 0 above limit; min 0.02, max 1.89, mean 0.21 mg/kg
Cat food (n=45) vs dog food (n=48), contamination rate / mean (mg/kg):
- Pb: cat 42.22% / 3.93; dog 41.67% / 3.34. Exceedance: cat 8.89%, dog 8.33%.
- Cd: cat 33.33% / 0.142; dog 29.17% / 0.134. Exceedance: 0 / 0.
- Cr: cat 100% / 3.31; dog 100% / 3.62. Exceedance: cat 22.22%, dog 31.25%.
- Hg: cat 95.56% / 0.011; dog 100% / 0.012. Exceedance: 0 / 0.
- As: cat 100% / 0.16; dog 100% / 0.26. Exceedance: 0 / 0.
Mean Pb and Cd were higher in cat food than dog food; mean Cr and As were higher in dog food than cat food.
Canned cat food (n=12) vs dry cat food (n=33) (published Table 4):
- Pb: canned 0% contamination; dry 57.58% contamination, 12.12% above limit.
- Cd: canned 16.67%; dry 39.40%; 0 above limit either form.
- Cr: 100% both; canned 0 above limit; dry 30.30% above limit.
- Hg: canned 83.33%; dry 100%.
- As: 100% both.
Canned dog food (n=2) vs dry dog food (n=46) (published Table 5):
- Pb: canned 0%; dry 43.48%, 8.70% above limit.
- Cd: canned 0%; dry 30.43%; 0 above limit either form.
- Cr: 100% both; canned 0 above limit; dry 32.61% above limit.
- Hg: 100% both.
- As: 100% both.
(The Research Square preprint reports the canned/dry split pooled across cat+dog: canned n=14 with 0% Pb, 14.29% Cd, 100% Cr, 85.71% Hg, 100% As contamination; dry n=79 with 49.37% Pb [10.13% above limit], 34.18% Cd, 100% Cr [31.65% above limit], 100% Hg, 100% As. The published version splits these by species, as captured above.)
Combined contamination (n=93; Fig 1 published):
- All samples contained at least two metals.
- 2.15% contained two metals (Cr + As).
- The largest fraction contained three metals (Cr, Hg, As dominant).
- 19.35% contained four metals (Pb, Cr, Hg, As).
- 26.88% contained all five metals.
- In dog food specifically, every sample contained ≥3 metals.
Acute hazard index (aHI = ESTI / ARfD; US EPA non-carcinogen RfDs as ARfD surrogate) for the highest observed concentration of each metal (published Table 6, dimensionless; threshold of concern = 1):
- Pb (RfD 6 µg/kg/day): cat 2 kg 21.82, cat 5 kg 16.13; dog 5 kg 17.36, dog 10 kg 14.60, dog 30 kg 11.09.
- Cd (RfD 1 µg/kg/day): cat 2 kg 5.86, cat 5 kg 4.33; dog 5 kg 5.41, dog 10 kg 4.55, dog 30 kg 3.45.
- Cr (RfD 0.3 µg/kg/day): cat 2 kg 1040.14, cat 5 kg 768.73; dog 5 kg 404.03, dog 10 kg 339.75, dog 30 kg 258.15.
- Hg (RfD 0.1 µg/kg/day): cat 2 kg 13.28, cat 5 kg 9.81; dog 5 kg 4.32, dog 10 kg 3.78, dog 30 kg 2.88.
- As (RfD 0.3 µg/kg/day): cat 2 kg 124.97, cat 5 kg 92.36; dog 5 kg 94.50, dog 10 kg 88.20, dog 30 kg 67.20.
Ranking by aHI (highest concentration scenario): Cr ≫ As > Pb > Hg > Cd across both cats and dogs. The authors explicitly state As ranks second after Cr, followed by Pb. Lighter-weight animals had higher aHI values across all metals.
Methods (brief)
Sample preparation: Dry samples ground to pass 20-mesh sieve (TAISITE FW100 mill); canned samples homogenized (Precision Labs HM-7300). Pb (GB/T 13080-2018), Cd (GB/T 13082-2021), Cr (GB/T 13088-2006), As (GB/T 13079-2006) digested by dry ashing (5 g sample, DK-98-II furnace, then Nabertherm L9/11/B170 muffle furnace). Hg (GB/T 13081-2006) digested by microwave (0.20-1.0 g sample, 69-70% HNO₃ + 30% H₂O₂ in SINEO MASTER 40 system, three-stage program to 190 °C at 2100 W).
Analytical instruments: Pb, Cd, Cr by flame atomic absorption spectrometry (ZEEnit 700 P, Analytik Jena AG; wavelengths Pb 283.3 nm, Cd 228.8 nm, Cr 359.3 nm). Hg, As by atomic fluorescence spectrometry (AFS-8530, Beijing Haiguang Instrument Co.). Calibration standards from Guobiao (Beijing) Testing & Certification Co. (1000 µg/mL).
LOD/LOQ (published Table 1): Pb LOQ 2 mg/kg; Cd LOD 0.08 / LOQ 0.20 mg/kg; Cr LOD 150 µg/kg; Hg LOD 0.15 µg/kg; As LOD 0.010 mg/kg.
Quality control (Sci Reports published version only — not in preprint): each batch of 21 samples included parallel samples, reagent blanks, and certified reference materials. Spike recovery rates: Pb 105.28%, Cr 117.93%, Cd 102.52%, Hg 89.9%, As 107.6%. RSD across 4 replicate determinations: 2.88-4.16%.
No As speciation reported (total As only). No Hg speciation reported (total Hg only). The authors discuss methylmercury toxicity in cats but do not measure methylmercury (MeHg).
Health risk model: ESTI = HER × K where HER is the highest observed concentration in the sample set for each metal and K is the manufacturer’s recommended daily food intake. K values (Table 2 preprint, published Table not directly accessible but consistent): 33 g/day (2 kg cat), 63 g/day (5 kg cat), 106 g/day (5 kg dog), 179 g/day (10 kg dog), 408 g/day (30 kg dog). aHI = ESTI / ARfD; ARfD = US EPA non-carcinogen RfD (mammalian; no pet-specific ARfD exists for these metals).
Statistical analysis: Microsoft Excel 2016 and PowerPoint 2016 for descriptive statistics (contamination rate, min, max, mean of positive samples).
Implications
Certification: HMT&C does not certify pet food. The relevance to HMT&C threshold work is indirect: pet-food ingredient supply chains (meat and bone meal, fish meal, poultry by-products, cereal grains, tubers) draw from the same primary commodity streams as human-food ingredients; metal levels in pet food provide an indirect indicator of supply-chain contamination for those shared inputs. The 26.88% Cr exceedance rate against a 5 mg/kg pet-feed limit is striking but uses a much looser limit than human-food Cr standards.
Courses: Useful as a case study of (1) total vs speciated metal reporting (the paper measures total Cr without hexavalent chromium (Cr-VI) speciation despite explicitly noting Cr-VI’s toxicity), (2) processing-form effects on contamination (dry kibble carries more metal than canned wet food across Pb, Cd, Cr, As; the authors attribute this to puffing/granulating/baking and to packaging considerations), and (3) the acute-hazard-index framework with mammalian RfD surrogates when species-specific reference doses are absent.
App: Pet-food matrix; not applicable to the human-food contamination-profile data the app consumes.
Related evidence
- Lead
- Cadmium
- Chromium
- Mercury, Total
- Arsenic, Total
- Complete & balanced dry (kibble)
- Complete & balanced canned/wet
Update history
No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.
