Skip to content

Wang et al. 2019 - Dietary lead exposure in Guangzhou foods

Wang and colleagues estimated dietary lead exposure for Guangzhou residents using lead concentrations from the local food safety risk monitoring system. The occurrence dataset included 6339 samples across 27 food categories collected in 2014-2017. The paper reports lead only; it does not measure arsenic, cadmium, mercury, chromium, or tin.

Key numbers

Table 2 reports lead concentrations in food in mg/kg:

Food categorySamplesMeanSDP50P95>LOD, %
Rice and rice products9900.03410.04300.01510.134173.2
Wheat flour and products11650.05090.06340.02600.170781.7
Flour products with fillings260.01580.01180.01300.042788.5
Other cereals4790.02060.02640.00900.082057.6
Pulses1100.02720.02620.02000.070080.0
Bean products1100.01510.02450.00890.064574.5
Preserved eggs340.03410.16460.00400.266064.7
Eggs3060.00990.01150.00600.030768.6
Pig meat2210.01270.01220.01000.030069.7
Livestock meat excluding pork860.00830.01130.00450.035662.8
Poultry990.01150.01620.00900.028083.8
Edible offal1400.02400.03190.01900.070089.3
Meat products720.03940.02620.03450.0837100.0
Milk powder1450.00710.00810.00500.020022.8
Milk2080.00360.00230.05000.00503.4
Leafy vegetables3560.03540.04640.01700.143277.2
Fruiting vegetables1630.01300.01670.00600.046862.0
Root and tuber vegetables50.02300.01240.02200.3500100.0
Legume vegetables1150.02090.03600.00500.109662.6
Bulb vegetables420.05050.06160.02700.214064.3
Fruit2230.01600.01810.00900.059467.3
Fish5360.01340.01780.00680.048370.9
Crustaceans1430.01090.01010.00740.032268.5
Mollusks3180.13840.11170.12000.335199.7
Dried seafood240.32190.26030.23650.9000100.0
Algae1750.39470.43490.34000.893878.9
Edible fungi480.07290.01470.07500.0900100.0
Total63390.04330.11040.01300.171071.6

The source states that lead concentrations were below the LOD in 28.4% of samples, for an overall detection rate of 71.6%. It identifies the highest average lead concentrations as algae (dry) at 0.3947 mg/kg, dried seafood at 0.3219 mg/kg, mollusks at 0.1384 mg/kg, edible fungi at 0.0729 mg/kg, wheat flour and products at 0.0509 mg/kg, bulb vegetables at 0.0505 mg/kg, meat products at 0.0394 mg/kg, leafy vegetables at 0.0354 mg/kg, rice and rice products at 0.0341 mg/kg, and preserved eggs at 0.0341 mg/kg.

The abstract and Tables 3-4 report these exposure/risk summary values:

Population groupMean dietary Pb intake, µg/kg bw/dayP95 dietary Pb intake, µg/kg bw/dayMOE at mean exposureMOE at P95 exposure
3-6 years0.74662.45250.80.2
7-17 years0.47391.55221.30.4
18-59 years0.37591.18323.21.0
>=60 years0.40311.35893.00.9
Total population0.40331.3049not reported in extracted textnot reported in extracted text

Table 3 reports total-population contribution fractions of 21.42% for rice and rice products, 20.01% for leafy vegetables, 11.75% for wheat flour and products, 5.45% for pig meat, 5.33% for fruiting vegetables, 4.74% for algae, 3.64% for flour products with fillings, and 3.47% for fruit.

Methods (brief)

Lead concentration data came from the Guangzhou food safety risk monitoring system for 2014-2017. Investigators acting as consumers purchased samples from retailers including supermarkets, restaurants, agricultural product wholesale markets, and stores. After edible-portion preparation, samples were homogenized, digested in acid, and analyzed by ICP-MS. Non-detected results were assigned a value of 1/2 LOD for occurrence and dietary exposure calculations; the authors report a lead LOD of 0.003 mg/kg.

Implications

This source contributes Guangzhou market-food occurrence data for Pb across rice, wheat flour products, vegetables, meats, dairy, fish, shellfish/seafood, algae, and fungi. It is routeable to broad food-product pages as a multi-category monitoring dataset. The source supports lead occurrence and dietary-exposure context only; it does not provide per-brand contamination values or other HMTc analytes.

Verification notes

  • PDF text extracted with pdftotext -layout; title page, methods, Table 2, Table 3, Table 4, conclusions, and license text were readable.
  • DOI 10.3390/ijerph16081417, raw handle MFK_wang2019, and cite-key checks found no existing source page before creation.
  • Table 2 values were checked against the extracted text and a rendered page image. The milk row is internally anomalous in the source table (P50 0.0500 and P95 0.0050); this page preserves the printed values and does not correct them.
  • Units are copied as reported: concentrations in mg/kg and dietary intake in µg/kg bw/day. No unit conversion was performed.
  • Speciation: the paper reports lead only.
  • Brand firewall: sampling locations are broad retail channels; no brand-level contamination values are reported.
  • Frontmatter product and ingredient slugs were checked against docs/gpt-collaboration/taxonomy-snapshot.md; no new slug was invented. Milk and milk-powder findings remain represented by the [[ingredients/milk-and-dairy]] ingredient because the current product snapshot does not list a dairy product slug.

Page history

The five most recent substantive edits to this page. The full version history lives in git; when DOI minting comes online (see schema docs), each entry below will also link to a version-pinned DataCite DOI.

CommitDateDescription
97920102026-06-08ingest: garrity1990-mt1-tissue-specific-promoter fresh from MFK/heavy_metals_peptides