CIRS 2023 — REACH Annex XVII consolidated reproduction (last update 2023-07-17)
This 64-page document is a third-party reproduction by CIRS – C&K Testing (Hangzhou C&K Testing Technic Co., Ltd) of Annex XVII to EU REACH Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006 — the consolidated list of restrictions on the manufacture, placing on the market, and use of certain dangerous substances, mixtures, and articles within the European Union. The header states “Last update: 2023-07-17”, and the reproduction covers entries 1 through 77 of the Annex in the canonical “Column 1 (substance) / Column 2 (conditions of restriction)” tabular format. The Appendices internally referenced by the entries (notably Appendix 8–14: the lists of aromatic amines released from azodyes, of substances restricted in clothing/textiles, of substances restricted in tattoo inks, and of formaldehyde-emission test conditions) are not reproduced in this PDF — the reproduction is the entries table only. The document is not a measurement study; it is reproduced regulatory text whose value to HMI is as a single consolidated reading of the heavy-metal-relevant restrictions (entries 16, 17, 18, 18a, 19, 20, 21, 23, 27, 47, 62, 63, 75) as of mid-2023. The canonical citation for any operative HMI claim remains the EUR-Lex consolidated version of Annex XVII or the specific amending Commission Regulation; this source is the working consolidation for cross-reference.
Key numbers — heavy-metal restrictions reproduced
The table below extracts the HMI-relevant numerical restrictions from the heavy-metal entries reproduced in the document. Concentrations are given in the basis the entry uses (% by weight of the substance or article, or release/migration rates where applicable). Entry numbers correspond to the reproduction’s entry numbers, which match the canonical REACH Annex XVII entry numbering.
Lead and lead compounds
| Entry | Substance / scope | Concentration / migration limit | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 16 | Lead carbonates: (a) Neutral anhydrous PbCO₃ (CAS 598-63-0; EC 209-943-4); (b) Trilead-bis(carbonate)-dihydroxide 2PbCO₃·Pb(OH)₂ (CAS 1319-46-6; EC 215-290-6) | Shall not be placed on the market or used as substances or in mixtures intended for use as paint | Derogation: Member States may permit use for restoration and maintenance of works of art and historic buildings and their interiors under ILO Convention 13. |
| 17 | Lead sulphates: (a) PbSO₄ (CAS 7446-14-2; EC 231-198-9); (b) Pb_x_SO₄ (CAS 15739-80-7; EC 239-831-0) | Shall not be placed on the market or used as substances or in mixtures intended for use as paint | Same ILO Convention 13 derogation as entry 16. |
| 63.1 | Lead (CAS 7439-92-1; EC 231-100-4) and its compounds — in jewellery articles | ≥ 0.05 % by weight (expressed as metal) in any individual part | ”Jewellery articles” defined to include jewellery and imitation jewellery and hair accessories: bracelets, necklaces, rings, piercing jewellery, wrist watches and wrist-wear, brooches and cufflinks. Paragraph 1 also applies to individual parts when placed on the market or used for jewellery-making. Derogations: crystal glass (Directive 69/493/EEC categories 1–4), internal components of watch timepieces inaccessible to consumers, non-synthetic precious and semi-precious stones unless treated with lead, enamels melted at ≥ 500 °C. Pre-application date: 9 October 2013 articles and jewellery produced before 10 December 1961. |
| 63.7 | Lead and its compounds — in articles supplied to the general public placed in mouth by children | ≥ 0.05 % by weight (expressed as metal) in those articles or accessible parts thereof | An article or accessible part is considered placeable in mouth by children if it is smaller than 5 cm in one dimension or has a detachable or protruding part of that size. The limit does not apply where the article demonstrably has a lead release rate of ≤ 0.05 µg/cm² per hour (equivalent to 0.05 µg/g/h), and for coated articles the coating must ensure release is not exceeded for ≥ 2 years of normal or reasonably foreseeable use. Derogations enumerated in paragraph 8: jewellery covered by paragraph 1; crystal glass; non-synthetic precious/semi-precious stones; enamels ≥ 500 °C; keys and locks including padlocks; musical instruments; brass-alloy articles where lead does not exceed 0.5 % by weight in the brass alloy; tips of writing instruments; religious articles; portable zinc-carbon and button-cell batteries; articles within scope of Directives 94/62/EC, 1935/2004, 2009/48/EC (Toy Safety Directive), and 2011/65/EU (RoHS). Pre-application date: 1 June 2016. |
| 63.11 | Lead — in or within 100 metres of wetlands, gunshot use | Discharging gunshot ≥ 1 % by weight (expressed as metal) prohibited; carrying such gunshot while wetland shooting prohibited | ”Wetlands” defined per the entry; in force from 15 February 2023. |
| 63.12 | Lead — placing on market of gunshot ≥ 1 % by weight; Member State option for territories ≥ 20 % wetlands | Member State may, from 15 February 2024, prohibit placing on market plus discharging and carrying of gunshot ≥ 1 % by weight throughout their territory | Member State notification required by 15 August 2021; national-measure text by 15 August 2023. |
Cadmium and cadmium compounds
Entry 23. Cadmium (CAS 7440-43-9; EC 231-152-8) and its compounds.
| Sub-entry | Scope | Concentration limit (expressed as Cd metal) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 23.1 | Synthetic organic polymers (PVC, PUR, LDPE except for coloured masterbatch, cellulose acetate CA, CAB, epoxy resins, MF and UF resins, unsaturated polyesters, PET, PBT, transparent/general-purpose polystyrene, AMMA, VPE, high-impact polystyrene, PP); mixtures and articles produced from these plastics | ≥ 0.01 % by weight of the plastic material | Derogation: second subparagraph does not apply to articles placed on market before 10 December 2011. Without prejudice to Council Directive 94/62/EC. |
| 23.2 | Paints with customs codes [3208] [3209] | ≥ 0.01 % by weight (general); ≥ 0.1 % by weight for paints with zinc content > 10 % by weight of paint; ≥ 0.1 % by weight of paint on painted articles | — |
| 23.3 | Articles coloured with cadmium-containing mixtures for safety reasons | Paragraphs 1 and 2 derogated | — |
| 23.4 | Recovered PVC in specified rigid PVC applications (profiles/rigid sheets for building, doors/windows/shutters/walls/blinds/fences/roof gutters, decks/terraces, cable ducts, non-drinking-water pipes with newly produced PVC overlayer) | Does not exceed 0.1 % by weight of plastic material | ”Contains recovered PVC” labelling required; PVC recycling pictogram. |
| 23.5 | Cadmium plating of metallic articles in specified sectors (equipment/machinery for food production, agriculture, cooling/freezing, printing and book-binding) and equipment/machinery for production of household goods, furniture, sanitary ware, central heating and air conditioning plant | Cadmium plating prohibited (no concentration threshold — outright prohibition for the listed sector applications) | “Cadmium plating” defined as any deposit or coating of metallic cadmium on a metallic surface. |
| 23.6 | Cadmium-plated articles in further sectors (paper and board production [8419 32] etc., textile and clothing equipment, industrial handling equipment, road and agricultural vehicles [ch. 87], rolling stock [ch. 86], vessels [ch. 89]) | Prohibited (no concentration threshold) | Paragraphs 5 and 6 do not apply to aeronautical, aerospace, mining, offshore, nuclear sectors with high safety standards, and to electrical contacts where reliability requires. |
| 23.8 | Brazing fillers | ≥ 0.01 % by weight | ”Brazing” defined as a joining technique using alloys above 450 °C. Defence and aerospace and safety-critical brazing fillers derogated. |
| 23.10 | Metal beads and metal components for jewellery-making; metal parts of jewellery and imitation jewellery and hair accessories (bracelets, necklaces, rings, piercing jewellery, wrist watches and wrist-wear, brooches, cufflinks) | ≥ 0.01 % by weight of the metal | Articles placed on market before 10 December 2011 and jewellery more than 50 years old on 10 December 2011 derogated. |
Mercury and mercury compounds
| Entry | Substance / scope | Restriction | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 18 | Mercury compounds | Shall not be placed on market or used as substances/mixtures intended for: (a) preventing fouling by micro-organisms, plants or animals of boat hulls, fish/shellfish cages/floats/nets/appliances/submerged equipment; (b) preservation of wood; (c) impregnation of heavy-duty industrial textiles and yarn intended for their manufacture; (d) treatment of industrial waters | No concentration threshold — outright prohibition for the listed uses |
| 18a | Mercury (CAS 7439-97-6; EC 231-106-7) — measuring devices | Shall not be placed on market: (a) in fever thermometers; (b) in other measuring devices intended for sale to the general public (manometers, barometers, sphygmomanometers, thermometers other than fever thermometers) | Devices in use in the Community before 3 April 2009 derogated; devices > 50 years old on 3 October 2007 derogated; barometers (excluding point (a)) until 3 October 2009 derogated. Industrial and professional measuring devices listed in paragraph 5 prohibited after 10 April 2014: barometers, hygrometers, manometers, sphygmomanometers, strain gauges with plethysmographs, tensiometers, thermometers and other non-electrical thermometric applications. Sphygmomanometers in epidemiological studies ongoing on 10 October 2012 derogated; mercury triple-point cells for platinum-resistance-thermometer calibration derogated. Mercury pycnometers and mercury metering devices for determining softening point prohibited after 10 April 2014 in paragraph 7. |
| 62 | Phenylmercury compounds: (a) phenylmercury acetate (CAS 62-38-4; EC 200-532-5); (b) phenylmercury propionate (CAS 103-27-5; EC 203-094-3); (c) phenylmercury 2-ethylhexanoate (CAS 13302-00-6; EC 236-326-7); (d) phenylmercury octanoate (CAS 13864-38-5); (e) phenylmercury neodecanoate (CAS 26545-49-3; EC 247-783-7) | Shall not be manufactured, placed on market, or used as substances or in mixtures after 10 October 2017 if mercury concentration in the mixtures is ≥ 0.01 % by weight. Articles or any parts thereof containing one or more of these substances shall not be placed on market after 10 October 2017 if mercury concentration in the articles or any part thereof is ≥ 0.01 % by weight | — |
Arsenic and arsenic compounds
Entry 19. Arsenic compounds.
| Sub-entry | Scope | Restriction |
|---|---|---|
| 19.1 | Antifouling of boat hulls, fish/shellfish appliances, submerged equipment | Shall not be placed on market or used as substances or mixtures intended for this use |
| 19.2 | Treatment of industrial waters, irrespective of their use | Shall not be placed on market or used |
| 19.3 | Preservation of wood (substances/mixtures and treated wood) | Shall not be used; treated wood shall not be placed on market |
| 19.4 | Derogation — CCA Type C wood treatment in industrial vacuum/pressure installations | Inorganic copper-chromium-arsenic (CCA) Type C solutions authorised under Directive 98/8/EC Article 5(1); fixation must be completed before placing on market; treated wood may be placed for professional/industrial use where structural integrity is required and skin contact during service life is unlikely (structural timber in buildings/agricultural premises, bridges, freshwater/brackish constructional timber, noise barriers, avalanche control, highway fencing, debarked round conifer livestock fence posts, earth-retaining structures, electric power transmission and telecommunications poles, underground railway sleepers); labelling “For professional and industrial installation and use only, contains arsenic” plus gloves/dust-mask/eye-protection handling instructions; waste treated as hazardous |
| 19.4(d) | CCA-treated wood usage exclusions | Shall not be used: in residential or domestic constructions, in any application with risk of repeated skin contact, in marine waters, for agricultural purposes other than livestock fence posts and structural uses, in any application where the treated wood may come into contact with intermediate or finished products intended for human and/or animal consumption |
Organostannic (organotin) compounds
Entry 20. Organostannic compounds.
| Sub-entry | Scope | Concentration / restriction |
|---|---|---|
| 20.1 | Antifouling biocide in free-association paint | Prohibited |
| 20.2 | Antifouling biocide for hulls, cages/floats/nets, submerged equipment, craft (marine, coastal, estuarine, inland waterways and lakes) | Prohibited |
| 20.3 | Treatment of industrial waters | Prohibited |
| 20.4 | Tri-substituted organostannic (TBT, TPT) in articles after 1 July 2010 | > 0.1 % by weight of tin prohibited; articles placed before that date derogated |
| 20.5 | Dibutyltin (DBT) compounds in mixtures and articles for supply to general public after 1 January 2012 | > 0.1 % by weight of tin prohibited; articles before that date derogated; derogations until 1 January 2015 for: RTV-1/RTV-2 sealants and adhesives; paints/coatings with DBT catalysts on articles; soft PVC profiles and PVC-coated fabrics for outdoor; outdoor rainwater pipes/gutters/fittings/façade coverings; food-contact materials under Reg. 1935/2004 |
| 20.6 | Dioctyltin (DOT) compounds in articles for supply to/use by general public after 1 January 2012 | > 0.1 % by weight of tin prohibited in: textile articles intended to come into contact with the skin; gloves; footwear or parts intended to come into contact with the skin; wall and floor coverings; childcare articles; female hygiene products; nappies; two-component RTV-2 moulding kits |
| 21 | Di-µ-oxo-di-n-butylstanniohydroxyborane / Dibutyltin hydrogen borate, C₈H₁₉BO₃Sn (DBB) (CAS 75113-37-0; EC 401-040-5) | ≥ 0.1 % by weight as substance or in mixtures prohibited; derogation for conversion into articles where the substance is no longer present at ≥ 0.1 % |
Nickel
Entry 27. Nickel (CAS 7440-02-0; EC 231-111-4) and its compounds.
| Sub-entry | Scope | Migration / release limit |
|---|---|---|
| 27.1(a) | Post assemblies inserted into pierced ears and other pierced parts of the human body | Nickel release rate < 0.2 µg/cm²/week (migration limit) |
| 27.1(b) | Articles intended to come into direct and prolonged contact with the skin: earrings; necklaces, bracelets and chains, anklets, finger rings; wrist-watch cases, watch straps and tighteners; rivet buttons, tighteners, rivets, zippers and metal marks when used in garments | Nickel release rate from parts in direct and prolonged skin contact > 0.5 µg/cm²/week prohibited |
| 27.1(c) | Non-nickel coatings on articles in 27.1(b) | Coating must ensure release rate does not exceed 0.5 µg/cm²/week for at least 2 years of normal use |
| 27.3 | Test methods | CEN standards adopted by the European Committee for Standardisation shall be used as test methods (per the entry text reproduced in the PDF) |
Chromium VI
Entry 47. Chromium VI compounds.
| Sub-entry | Scope | Concentration limit |
|---|---|---|
| 47.1 | Cement and cement-containing mixtures, when hydrated | > 2 mg/kg (0.0002 %) soluble chromium VI of total dry weight of cement prohibited |
| 47.5 | Leather articles coming into contact with skin | ≥ 3 mg/kg (0.0003 % by weight) chromium VI of total dry weight of leather prohibited |
| 47.6 | Leather parts of articles coming into contact with skin | ≥ 3 mg/kg (0.0003 % by weight) chromium VI of total dry weight of that leather part prohibited |
| 47.7 | Second-hand articles in end-use in the Union before 1 May 2015 | Paragraphs 5 and 6 derogated |
Tattoo-ink CMR restriction (entry 75) — nickel and chromium VI signalling
Entry 75 is a CMR-substance restriction on mixtures for tattooing purposes (in force from 4 January 2022 for most substances). The HMI-relevant numbers it reproduces for heavy metals are in the mandatory labelling text required from 4 January 2022 (paragraph 7):
- “Contains nickel. Can cause allergic reactions.” must appear on a tattoo-ink mixture if the mixture contains nickel below the concentration limit specified in Appendix 13 (Appendix not reproduced in this PDF).
- “Contains chromium (VI). Can cause allergic reactions.” must appear on a tattoo-ink mixture if the mixture contains chromium (VI) below the concentration limit specified in Appendix 13 (Appendix not reproduced in this PDF).
For substances in Appendix 13 (the appendix-specific concentration table not reproduced here), the concentration limit specified in Appendix 13 applies (paragraph 1(h)); a substance not in Appendix 13 falling within general points (a)–(g) takes the strictest applicable concentration limit, with the carcinogen/germ-cell mutagen 1A/1B/2 limit at ≥ 0.00005 % by weight and the reproductive toxicant 1A/1B/2 limit at ≥ 0.001 % by weight as the operative CMR-class thresholds (paragraph 1(a), 1(b)).
Cross-reference summary by metal
| Metal | REACH Annex XVII entries (this reproduction) | Operative limits / scopes (selected) |
|---|---|---|
| Lead (Pb) | 16, 17, 63 | 0.05 % in jewellery parts; 0.05 % in mouthable children’s articles or release ≤ 0.05 µg/cm²/h; gunshot ≥ 1 % in/near wetlands prohibited |
| Cadmium (Cd) | 23 (sub-entries 23.1, 23.2, 23.3, 23.4, 23.5, 23.6, 23.8, 23.10) | 0.01 % in plastics; 0.01 % in paints (0.1 % zinc-rich); 0.1 % in painted articles; 0.01 % in brazing fillers; 0.01 % in jewellery/hair-accessory metal parts |
| Mercury (Hg, tHg) | 18, 18a, 62 | Outright prohibition for antifouling, wood preservation, textile impregnation, industrial waters (18); thermometer and measuring-device prohibitions (18a); 0.01 % phenylmercury (5 compounds) in mixtures and articles after 10 October 2017 (62) |
| Arsenic (tAs) | 19 | Outright prohibition for antifouling, wood preservation, industrial waters; CCA Type C derogation for restricted industrial wood uses; exclusions for residential, skin-contact, marine, agricultural-with-livestock-or-structural exceptions, and food-contact uses |
| Organotins (Sn) | 20 (sub-entries 20.4, 20.5, 20.6), 21 | TBT/TPT 0.1 % by weight of tin in articles after 1 July 2010; DBT 0.1 % in mixtures/articles for general public after 1 January 2012; DOT 0.1 % in textile/skin-contact articles, gloves, footwear, wall and floor coverings, childcare articles, female hygiene, nappies, RTV-2 moulding kits after 1 January 2012; DBB 0.1 % in substance/mixtures |
| Nickel (Ni) | 27 | Post-assembly migration < 0.2 µg/cm²/week; skin-contact-article migration ≤ 0.5 µg/cm²/week; coating durability ≥ 2 years |
| Chromium VI (Cr-VI) | 47 | Cement > 2 mg/kg soluble Cr-VI prohibited; leather articles in skin contact ≥ 3 mg/kg prohibited |
| CMR tattoo-ink labelling | 75 | Mandatory “Contains nickel” / “Contains chromium (VI)” labels for tattoo inks below Appendix 13 limits |
Methods (brief)
This is reproduced regulatory text, not an analytical study. The document does not specify measurement methods; the entries themselves reference CEN test methods (entry 27.3 for nickel release; entry 50 references EN 16143:2013 for PAH in extender oils; entry 47.4 references the CEN standard for soluble chromium VI in cement; entry 50.2 references ISO 21461 for Bay protons in rubber) which are external to this PDF. Limits are stated as concentration in mass-percent of substance, mass-percent of metal, mg/kg, µg/cm²/week (migration), or µg/cm²/hour (release). The reproduction preserves the EU regulatory unit conventions verbatim and uses the EU continental decimal separator (comma in some entries, period in others) inconsistently as reproduced from the underlying text.
Scope of the reproduction (entries 1–77, what is and is not heavy-metal-relevant)
The reproduction contains entries 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 (asbestos fibres), 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12–15, 16, 17, 18, 18a, 19, 20, 21, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28–30 (CMR cat. 1A/1B class), 31 (creosote), 32–38 (chlorinated solvents), 40 (flammable aerosols), 41 (hexachloroethane in non-ferrous metal manufacturing), 43 (azocolourants and azodyes), 45 (diphenylether octabromo derivative), 46/46a (nonylphenol and NPE), 47 (chromium VI), 48 (toluene), 49 (trichlorobenzene), 50 (polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in extender oils, tyres, granules/mulches for synthetic turf, articles for general public, toys/childcare articles), 51 (DEHP, DBP, BBP, DIBP phthalates), 52 (DINP, DIDP, DNOP phthalates), 54 (DEGME), 55 (DEGBE), 56 (MDI), 57 (cyclohexane), 58 (ammonium nitrate), 59 (dichloromethane), 60 (acrylamide), 61 (DMF), 62, 63, 64 (1,4-DCB), 65 (inorganic ammonium salts), 66 (BPA in thermal paper), 68 (C9–C14 PFCAs), 69 (methanol), 70 (D4/D5 cyclosiloxanes), 71 (NMP), 72 (textile substances in Appendix 12), 73 (TDFAs), 74 (diisocyanates), 75 (tattoo-ink CMR restriction), 76 (DMF), 77 (formaldehyde and formaldehyde-releasing substances in articles and road vehicles).
Heavy-metal entries reproduced: 16, 17, 18, 18a, 19, 20, 21, 23, 27, 47, 62, 63, 75 (the last for the nickel/chromium-VI labelling clause within the CMR tattoo-ink restriction).
Non-reproduced content within Annex XVII relevant to HMI but referenced by the entries: Appendix 8 (aromatic amines released from azodyes), Appendix 11 (substances for which CMR cat. 1A/1B derogation applies), Appendix 12 (substances in clothing/textiles with per-substance concentration limits — operative for chromium VI 1 mg/kg textile-extractable and for several other metals in the textile-clothing scope), Appendix 13 (tattoo-ink concentration limits for specific substances including nickel and chromium VI), and Appendix 14 (formaldehyde-emission test conditions). The PDF references these Appendices but does not reproduce them; any HMI claim that depends on Appendix-table concentration values cannot be sourced from this reproduction.
Implications for the HMI corpus
This reproduction serves as a working consolidated reading of Annex XVII heavy-metal restrictions for HMI cross-reference against children’s-product and textile/leather/jewellery sources already in the corpus. Specific intersections:
- The 0.5 µg/cm²/week nickel-release migration limit on skin-contact articles (entry 27.1(b)) and the < 0.2 µg/cm²/week post-assembly migration limit (entry 27.1(a)) are the operative restriction underlying the test-method update documented in Hohenstein 2023; the values are unchanged from the predecessor EU Nickel Directive 94/27/EC recorded in eu-nickel-directive-94-27-ec.
- The 0.05 % by weight lead-in-mouthable-children’s-articles threshold (entry 63.7) with its 0.05 µg/cm²/h release-rate alternative and 5-cm-mouthability rule is the EU counterpart to ASTM/CPSC lead-in-children’s-product limits recorded on US regulatory sources in the corpus; the EU exemption for brass-alloy articles ≤ 0.5 % lead is a category-specific carve-out HMI should note when evaluating brass-containing children’s metal products.
- The cadmium 0.01 % in jewellery metal parts (entry 23.10), 0.01 % in plastic articles (entry 23.1), and 0.1 % in painted articles (entry 23.2) are the EU operative limits against which ECHA’s 2023 CMR-childcare-articles investigation report (ECHA 2023) proposes the more protective LOQ-derived 10 mg Cd/kg content and 0.1 mg Cd/kg extractable limits for childcare articles specifically.
- The DOT 0.1 % organotin restriction in nappies, childcare articles, female hygiene products, textile skin-contact articles, gloves, footwear, and wall/floor coverings (entry 20.6) is direct evidence for the diapers-and-components page and for any future childcare-textile product page; ECHA 2023 proposes the more protective 1 mg/kg sum of DOT/DBT for childcare-article content.
- The chromium VI ≥ 3 mg/kg leather-skin-contact prohibition (entry 47.5 and 47.6) is the operative restriction the corpus cross-references when discussing children’s leather goods and shoes.
Limitations
The CIRS reproduction is a third-party consolidation; the canonical citation for any operative HMI use (e.g. an HMTc threshold rationale tag of regulatory-alignment per CLAUDE.md Part 19) is the EUR-Lex consolidated version of Annex XVII or the specific amending Commission Regulation, not this snapshot. Specific limitations:
- The reproduction does not enumerate which amending Commission Regulations are included or excluded; entries amended after 17 July 2023 will not be reflected.
- Appendices 8 through 14 (notably Appendix 12 textile-substance limits and Appendix 13 tattoo-ink limits) are not reproduced; any claim that depends on Appendix-table concentration values must be sourced from the underlying regulation directly.
- Several entries reproduced in the document have been amended in subsequent Commission Regulations (for example, entry 51 phthalates received a substance addition in early 2024; entry 23 cadmium derogation review under Article 69 paragraph 4 was due for re-evaluation by 31 December 2017 and the outcome is not reproduced); the snapshot does not flag where it is current versus historical.
- Entries reference external CEN/ISO test methods (EN 16143:2013 for extender-oil PAH analysis; ISO 21461 for rubber Bay protons; an unspecified CEN standard for soluble Cr-VI in cement; CEN standards for nickel release) which are not reproduced in this PDF.
- The reproduction uses both period and comma as decimal separators across entries (e.g. “0.01 %” in entry 23.1 vs “0,01 % by weight” in entry 23.2) inconsistently, preserving the inconsistency of the underlying EU text; HMI numerical values quoted in the Key numbers table are normalised to period as the decimal separator.
- Entries 22, 33, 39, 42, 44, 53, and 67 are absent from the reproduction (consistent with the canonical Annex XVII where some entry numbers have been vacated by repeals or remain reserved).
Verification notes
- Document provenance. The header on every page reads “CIRS – C&K Testing www.cirs-ck.com/en”; the footer of the final page lists “CIRS | Hangzhou C&K Testing Technic Co., Ltd Web: www.cirs-ck.com/en Phone: +86-(0)571-87206587 FAX: +86-(0)571-89900719 E-mail: test@cirs-group.com”. CIRS is identified as a Chinese chemical-compliance testing and consulting firm; the document is a CIRS-branded reproduction of EU regulatory text, not an EU institutional publication.
- Date anchor. The document states “Last update: 2023-07-17” on the first page beneath the title. The frontmatter
yearis 2023; the publication string preserves the full date. - Entry-numbering gaps. Entries 22, 33, 39, 42, 44, 53, and 67 are absent from the document. This matches the canonical Annex XVII where some entry numbers have been vacated by repeals; the gaps are not reproduction errors.
- Decimal-separator inconsistency. The reproduced text uses period and comma decimal separators inconsistently across entries (e.g. “0.01 %” in entry 23.1 and “0,01 % by weight” in entry 23.2 within the same entry). The inconsistency is preserved in the underlying EU text and reproduced verbatim. Key numbers in this source page are normalised to period.
- Speciation. Entries 18 (mercury compounds, broad scope), 18a (elemental mercury), and 62 (five specific phenylmercury compounds) are distinct entries with distinct restrictions; the frontmatter
metals: [..., tHg, iHg, ...]is intentional (tHg for the total-mercury restriction scope of entry 18 and iHg for the elemental-mercury restriction scope of entry 18a; phenylmercury sits under tHg). The arsenic entry 19 is restricted to compounds generally without iAs/tAs speciation in the regulatory text, so the frontmatter usestAs. The chromium VI restriction (entry 47) is recorded asCr-VI. Organotin compounds are aggregated asSnper HMI’smetals: [..., Sn, ...]convention; TBT, TPT, DBT, DOT, and DBB are sub-species underSn. - Audit subagent (2026-06-01) flagged
Hgas not in the controlled metals abbreviation vocabulary (the documented set isPb, Cd, iAs, tAs, iHg, MeHg, tHg, Ni, Al, Cr, Cr-VI, Sn, Sb, Uper the system-prompt vocabulary referenced in taxonomy-snapshot). Verified against the controlled vocabulary — finding was correct. The elemental-mercury restriction in entry 18a falls under inorganic mercury (Hg⁰ and Hg²⁺) per the speciation flag, soiHgis the controlled-vocabulary equivalent. ReplacedHgwithiHgin the metals array. The wiki body and verification notes have been updated to reflect this. Some other source pages in the corpus use the bareHgflag inconsistently; that is a corpus-wide vocabulary drift not addressed by this ingest. - Audit subagent (2026-06-01) flagged
childrens-jewelryandclasps-fasteners-infant-productsas not in the 2026-05-18 taxonomy snapshot. Verified againstwiki/products/childrens-jewelry.mdandwiki/products/clasps-fasteners-infant-products.md: both pages exist on disk and are valid routing targets (the routing audit accepts both as live product pages). Findings were false positives because the taxonomy snapshot is a static 2026-05-18 export, not the live wiki state; the live product pages exist and the routing layer routes to them correctly. No change toproducts:array. The auditor self-corrected four other product-slug findings (piercing-post-assemblies,toys-painted,toys-substrate-materials,tattoo-inks) for the same reason during its own re-check. - Brand-firewall. CIRS is the publisher of the reproduction, not a brand of measured product; per the Part 12 strict reading (locked 2026-05-17), publisher identification is not a brand-firewall violation. No brand names appear in the underlying REACH regulatory text reproduced.
- Wiki/HMTc firewall. The reproduction reports the EU operative restriction as it is; it does not synthesise across the corpus, does not propose HMTc thresholds, and does not advocate tightening or loosening any value. The “Implications for the HMI corpus” section above flags cross-references to existing wiki sources without making synthesis claims.
- New-page proposals (for Karen’s review, not created in this ingest):
regulations/eu-1907-2006-reach-annex-xvii— the umbrella regulation page for Annex XVII as a whole. Multiple existing HMI sources reference Annex XVII in prose (Hohenstein 2023; ECHA 2023; entries 27, 47, 63 in particular); a dedicated regulation page would let those sources route to a canonical page. The wiki currently hasregulations/eu-nickel-directive-94-27-ec(the predecessor Nickel Directive) but no Annex XVII page.- Alternative: per-entry regulation pages (
regulations/reach-annex-xvii-entry-27,regulations/reach-annex-xvii-entry-63, etc.) following the per-entry granularity of the canonical text. Either umbrella or per-entry — Karen’s call.
- Routing scope. The reproduction’s product scope is broader than the HMI wiki product taxonomy (which is primarily food and personal-care focused with selected childcare-article slugs). The frontmatter routes to the eight existing product slugs whose scope intersects with the reproduction’s heavy-metal entries:
childrens-jewelry(entries 23.10, 27.1(b), 63.1),piercing-post-assemblies(entry 27.1(a)),clasps-fasteners-infant-products(entry 27.1(b) for rivets/zippers/metal marks in garments),diapers-and-components(entry 20.6 DOT in nappies),infant-clothing(entry 20.6 DOT in textile articles intended for skin contact; entry 47.5/47.6 Cr-VI in leather parts of children’s footwear and clothing accessories),toys-painted(entry 23.2 Cd in painted articles; entry 63.7 Pb in articles for general public placed in mouth by children),toys-substrate-materials(entry 23.1 Cd in plastic materials; entry 63.7 Pb in articles placed in mouth by children; entry 20.6 DOT in childcare articles), andtattoo-inks(entry 75 CMR tattoo-ink restriction including the nickel/chromium-VI labelling clauses). This routing treats the source asregulatory_contextfor product pages whose scope intersects the entries; the source is not direct contamination evidence (no measurements) for any of these product categories. - Matrices. The reproduction is not a food or skin-contact-material measurement study;
matrices: []is correct. - Jurisdictions. EU only; the restrictions apply throughout the European Economic Area via the REACH framework.
Page history
The five most recent substantive edits to this page. The full version history lives in git; when DOI minting comes online (see schema docs), each entry below will also link to a version-pinned DataCite DOI.
| Commit | Date | Description |
|---|---|---|
| c1aef38 | 2026-06-02 | audit-queue: hamid2021-bacterial-plant-biostimulants-review → audited-promote |