Skip to content
Heavy Metal Index

In vitro evaluation of bio-fortification effects on the nutritional quality, toxicological safety, and antioxidant of cassava (Manihot esculenta) flour, and environmental safety of processing water, using natural additives

Source

Albishi and colleagues measured Pb, Cd, As (total), and Cr in cassava (Manihot esculenta) flour samples from Nigeria under different natural biofortification treatments, finding that all heavy metal concentrations were well below WHO/FAO maximum permissible limits (Pb: 300 µg/kg DW; Cd and ...

Page snapshot
Cited by8 pages
Metals measured4
Evidence tierA
Year2026

Overview

Albishi and colleagues measured Pb, Cd, As (total), and Cr in cassava (Manihot esculenta) flour samples from Nigeria under different natural biofortification treatments, finding that all heavy metal concentrations were well below WHO/FAO maximum permissible limits (Pb: 300 µg/kg DW; Cd and As: 200 µg/kg DW). The control group (unfortified cassava flour) showed Pb at 61.33–68.67 µg/kg DW, Cd at 57.67–63.00 µg/kg DW, As at 9.97–11.13 µg/kg DW, and Cr at 65.00–68.00 µg/kg DW, and biofortification treatments generally reduced heavy metal levels, with the best-performing treatment (F11) achieving Pb 21.33, Cd 27.33, As 6.07, and Cr 55.33 µg/kg DW. The primary focus of the paper is nutritional biofortification rather than contamination surveillance, so the cassava samples were not selected to represent worst-case contamination and the geographic sourcing details are limited.

Key numbers

All concentrations in µg/kg dry weight (DW), n=3 per treatment, mean ± SD (Table 6):

SamplePb (µg/kg DW)Cd (µg/kg DW)As (µg/kg DW)Cr (µg/kg DW)
Control A68.67 ± 3.2163.00 ± 2.6511.13 ± 0.8068.00 ± 3.00
Control B61.33 ± 2.0857.67 ± 1.539.97 ± 0.1565.00 ± 1.00
F1 (least-fortified)58.00 ± 2.0054.33 ± 1.539.43 ± 0.0664.33 ± 0.58
F1028.33 ± 3.0636.67 ± 1.536.13 ± 0.7258.33 ± 1.15
F11 (best)21.33 ± 1.5327.33 ± 2.526.07 ± 0.1555.33 ± 1.53

WHO/FAO limits cited: Pb 300 µg/kg DW, Cd 200 µg/kg DW, As 200 µg/kg DW.

As speciation: not performed; values are total arsenic (tAs). Cr speciation: not performed; values are total chromium.

Methods (brief)

Analytical method for heavy metals: ICP with HPLC referenced in methods (exact ICP variant not specified in extracted text). Samples are cassava flour specimens (CF) from Nigeria. The study design is a biofortification experiment with 11 treatment groups plus 2 controls; heavy metal measurement is a safety check rather than a contamination survey. LOD/LOQ not reported. Basis: dry weight. The Nigeria geographic context is relevant; cassava is a staple crop in West Africa and this provides a baseline for Nigerian commercial cassava flour heavy metal levels.

Implications

Certification: Cassava is a significant ingredient in gluten-free products and West African food supply chains. The control values (Pb ~62–69, Cd ~58–63, As ~10–11, Cr ~65–68 µg/kg DW) represent background contamination for Nigerian cassava flour and are well below WHO/FAO limits, suggesting this ingredient does not present elevated heavy metal risk in the Nigerian production context sampled here.

Courses: Illustrates that plant-based processing (biofortification, fermentation, or additive treatments) can reduce heavy metal concentrations in flour, with F11 achieving roughly 65–70% reduction in Pb and Cd vs controls.

App: Nigerian cassava flour baseline: Pb ~62–69 µg/kg DW, Cd ~58–63 µg/kg DW, tAs ~10–11 µg/kg DW, Cr ~65–68 µg/kg DW. Small n per treatment (n=3); single-country data point; sourcing details limited.

Wiki pages updated on ingest

Update history

The five most recent substantive edits to this page, classified major (evidence or structure moved), correction (a published value or statement was wrong and has been fixed), or minor (narrative rewritten without changing the underlying evidence). Each description is derived from what the edit did to this page; the linked commit is the authoritative record, routine regeneration passes are excluded, and the full version history lives in git. When DOI minting comes online (see schema docs), each entry below will also link to a version-pinned DataCite DOI.

CommitDateChangeDescription
a8052bb2026-08-09major6 sections added; narrative text revised