Skip to content
Heavy Metal Index

Elevated Metal Levels in U.S. Honeys: Is There a Concern for Human Health?

Overview

Twenty elements were measured in 28 U.S. honey samples from 15 states using benchtop X-ray fluorescence (XRF), which the authors describe as the most geographically broad survey of metal contaminants in U.S. honeys reported to date. The majority of samples exceeded EU maximum residue levels for lead (0.10 µg/g) and mercury (0.01 µg/g), with the highest lead (Pb) observed in Tennessee (0.918 µg/g), Massachusetts (0.820 µg/g), and New Mexico (0.367 µg/g), and the highest mercury (Hg) in Massachusetts (8.94 µg/g), Tennessee (7.04 µg/g), and New Mexico (6.92 µg/g) — 894×, 704×, and 692× the EU MRL respectively. Estimated weekly intake calculations at 300 mg honey/kg body mass/day showed that all four toxic metals (As, Pb, cadmium (Cd), Hg) and aluminum exceeded JECFA provisional tolerable weekly intake (PTWI) values, with Hg EWI of 2.504 mg/kg body mass/week against a PTWI of 0.005 mg/kg (≈501× excess). The paper contains several internal inconsistencies in the Cd reporting (see Key numbers).

Key numbers

U.S. honey concentrations from Table 2 (mg metal/kg honey, equivalent to µg/g):

ClassMetalUS Honey MeanWeekly Intake (mg/kg body mass)JECFA PTWI (mg/kg body mass)Ratio
ToxicAs0.0600.1280.00264×
ToxicPb0.1780.4010.02516×
ToxicCd0.1320.0270.0073.9×
ToxicHg3.7102.5040.005501×
ToxicAl64.3677.2332.00039×
EssentialCu3.6121.0843.5000.31× (below)
EssentialMn2.3300.6992.5000.28× (below)
EssentialZn75.9122.777.0003.3×
EssentialSe0.5090.0150.0660.23× (below)

EWI assumes 300 mg honey/kg body mass/day (≈15.3 mL or 1.03 US tablespoons for a 70-kg adult), the dose commonly used in honey therapeutic studies (paper Methods, Estimated Weekly Intake section).

Mean ± SEM concentrations for 13 metals detected in all 28 honeys (paper Results, p. 1793):

Sodium 406.8 ± 1.58 µg/g; Calcium 234.8 ± 2.15 µg/g; Zinc 75.9 ± 12.18 µg/g; Iron 31.33 ± 7.23 µg/g; Bromine 4.82 ± 0.45 µg/g; Copper 3.61 ± 0.01 µg/g; Manganese 2.33 ± 0.37 µg/g; Selenium 0.51 ± 0.03 µg/g; Silicon 0.19 ± 0.02 µg/g; Gallium 0.14 ± 0.01 µg/g; Titanium 0.056 ± 0.039 µg/g; Germanium 0.035 ± 0.01 µg/g; Vanadium 0.021 ± 0.004 µg/g. (The Discussion section reports Sodium 406.8 ± 8.3 µg/g and Calcium 234.8 ± 11.35 µg/g — paper-internal SEM discrepancies; means are consistent across both presentations.)

Highest values by state (µg/g), from paper Results & Discussion (p. 1793):

  • Pb: Tennessee 0.918, Massachusetts 0.820, New Mexico 0.367 (EU MRL = 0.10; ratios 9.18×, 8.2×, 3.67×)
  • Cd: paper text gives “Tennessee 0.918, Massachusetts 0.820, Vermont 0.350” — values for TN and MA are an exact duplicate of the Pb top-two and are clearly a copy-paste editorial error in the source; Fig 2B shows the Cd y-axis ranging 0.005–0.020 µg/g, and the Table 2 Cd EWI of 0.027 mg/kg body mass/week implies a true Cd mean of ≈0.013 mg/kg honey (paper-internal contradiction — see Verification notes)
  • Hg: Massachusetts 8.94, Tennessee 7.04, New Mexico 6.92 (EU MRL = 0.01; ratios 894×, 704×, 692×)
  • arsenic (As): Oregon 0.067, Indiana 0.065, Arkansas 0.065 (EU has no honey-specific inorganic arsenic (iAs)/total arsenic (tAs) MRL)

Fig 1 element-range groupings (paper Results): Eleven metals in 0–1 µg/g range (Mg, Si, Ti, V, chromium (Cr), As, Se, Pb, Cd, Ga, Ge); four in 1–15 µg/g (Mn, Cu, Br, Hg); three in 0–300 µg/g (Al, Fe, Zn); two in 200–500 µg/g (Na, Ca). The paper reports levels of 20 elements total; thirteen of those were detected in all 28 honeys.

States sampled (n samples): Arkansas (2), Florida (2), Indiana (2), Kentucky (4), Maine (1), Maryland (1), Massachusetts (2), New Mexico (4), North Carolina (1), Oklahoma (1), Oregon (2), Tennessee (3), Texas (1), Vermont (1), West Virginia (1) — 28 samples across 15 states. (The paper Methods opening states “14 different states” in passing; Table 1 and the abstract both correctly enumerate 15.)

Methods (brief)

Benchtop XRF (Epsilon 4, Malvern Panalytical, Marlborough, MA) with 15-W X-ray tube at 50 kV maximum and 300 µA, 7.5-minute collection per sample. Honey samples were placed undigested and unhomogenized in 30-mm XRF cups covered with 4-µm polypropylene film. Quantification used Epsilon 4 software deconvolution (gaussian + polynomial background) and calibration against phantom samples doped with known metal concentrations across a thickness/mass range; Compton scattering peak normalization corrected for sample mass and thickness variation. Reported in µg/g, the standard ICP-MS unit. ArcGIS Pro 3.2.2 used for state-level mapping with zip-code-centered coordinates.

The EWI formula reported by the authors is: EWI = (daily honey consumption × metal concentration / body mass) × 7, with daily honey consumption of 300 mg/kg body mass per day and adult body mass of 70 kg (yielding ≈21 g honey/day). The Table 2 EWI values are internally consistent with the stated formula for As, Pb, and Cd if the Cd “US Honey Mean” is read as 0.013 rather than the printed 0.132 (see Verification notes); the Hg EWI of 2.504 mg/kg/week is high but lower than a strict formula application to the stated Hg mean of 3.710 mg/kg would predict.

Method limitations stated or implied by the paper: XRF does not speciate arsenic, so the reported values are total As (tAs), not iAs. XRF is less sensitive for Hg than ICP-MS; the unusually high Hg values (up to 8.94 µg/g) are notable and would benefit from independent ICP-MS verification, which the authors do not provide. The paper does not report method-specific LODs/LOQs, recovery percentages, or analytical replicates per sample. No certified reference material results are reported in the main text. Citizen-science benchtop-XRF validation citations are provided for related applications (toenails, soil, blood) but not for honey specifically.

Implications

Certification: U.S. honey has no federal maximum contaminant levels for metals; the EU maximum residue level for Pb in honey (Commission Regulation 2023/915) is 0.10 µg/g and for Hg (Commission Regulation 2018/73 amending Reg. EC 396/2005) is 0.01 µg/g. The majority of samples in this study exceed both. This is directly relevant to the HMT&C analyte panel for honey, if honey or honey-containing products fall within program scope: the literature demonstrates that commercial small-batch U.S. honey frequently fails EU standards for Pb and Hg. The arsenic values here are total As (tAs); a speciation study would be needed to determine the inorganic As (iAs) fraction relevant to the HMT&C iAs threshold.

Courses: The XRF methodology illustrates a non-destructive, no-digestion screening approach that enables broad geographic survey but cannot differentiate metal species. The contrast between the high estimated weekly intakes and typical honey consumption patterns (most adults do not consume 15 mL/day as a therapeutic dose) demonstrates how exposure scenario assumptions dominate health-risk calculations. The paper’s several internal arithmetic inconsistencies (Cd state values, Cd mean vs Cd EWI, SEM discrepancies between Results and Discussion) make it a useful teaching case for source-level quality criticism within evidence synthesis.

App: State-level variation suggests honey from Tennessee, Massachusetts, and New Mexico carries higher risk for Pb and Hg, with smaller-magnitude elevations across most sampled states. The absence of US federal regulatory limits for metals in honey means the app should cite the EU MRLs as comparison benchmarks rather than domestic regulatory exceedances. Total As at mean 0.060 µg/g is at the low end of the food-matrix arsenic range; the iAs fraction is unknown from XRF measurement.

Update history

No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.