Overview
Islam et al. (2007) review phytotoxic effects and bioaccumulation of cadmium (Cd), Zn, Cu, lead (Pb), and aluminum (Al) in four Asian leafy vegetables — Chinese cabbage (Brassica chinensis cv. Zao-Shu 5), winter greens (B. rosularis), pakchoi (B. chinensis), and celery (Apium graveolens var. dulce DC) — and compile soil heavy metal threshold values for “potential dietary toxicity” (PDT) derived from pot and nutrient-solution work at Zhejiang University. The principal numerical contributions are (i) soil extractable Cd thresholds of 0.869, 0.730, and 0.489 mg/kg for Chinese cabbage, winter greens, and celery, respectively, calculated against the Chinese food-hygiene limit of 0.05 mg/kg FW Cd in vegetables (GB N238-84); (ii) soil Zn and Cu PDT thresholds (total and DTPA-available) for the same four crops, against Chinese food limits of 20 mg/kg Zn and 10 mg/kg Cu; and (iii) accumulation-coefficient (AF = tissue/soil) tables showing celery as the most sensitive Cd accumulator in edible parts. The paper also reviews Al phytotoxicity (Al-based coagulants on Brassica seed germination) and surveys dietary intake estimates from European urban-garden studies (Lăcătuşu et al. 1996, Bahemuka & Mubofu 1999). Lead is discussed qualitatively only: the paper cites a 0.2 mg/kg edible-crop limit (Chinese Department of Preventive Medicine 1994) and notes that soil Pb thresholds for safe vegetable production “are not available”. chromium (Cr) and mercury (Hg) are mentioned in the abstract as important environmental pollutants but no quantitative data are presented for either.
Key numbers
Food-hygiene limits the paper references as the basis for its PDT calculations:
- Cd in edible vegetable parts: 0.05 mg/kg fresh weight (China, GB N238-84)
- Pb in edible parts of crops: 0.2 mg/kg (Chinese Department of Preventive Medicine, 1994)
- Zn for human health: 20 mg/kg (Chinese Department of Preventive Medicine, 1995)
- Cu in food: 10 mg/kg (Chinese Department of Preventive Medicine, 1995)
Cd in vegetable tissue (Table 5; soil extractable-Cd ladder 0.15 → 0.89 → 1.38 → 1.84 → 2.30 mg/kg; mg/kg fresh weight)
- Chinese cabbage root: 0.017 → 0.158 → 0.332 → 0.455 → 1.095
- Chinese cabbage shoot (edible): 0.010 → 0.049 → 0.076 → 0.086 → 0.151
- Winter greens root: 0.023 → 0.095 → 0.151 → 0.235 → 0.428
- Winter greens shoot (edible): 0.022 → 0.038 → 0.103 → 0.119 → 0.166
- Celery root: 0.096 → 0.265 → 0.385 → 0.439 → 0.653
- Celery stem (edible): 0.020 → 0.085 → 0.113 → 0.204 → 0.241
- Celery leaf (edible): 0.020 → 0.040 → 0.072 → 0.082 → 0.253
- F-ANOVA across the soil-Cd ladder significant at P=0.01 for every tissue column.
- Celery accumulated the highest Cd in edible parts among the three vegetable crops.
Soil extractable-Cd PDT thresholds (Table 10; regression-derived, n=5 each; correlations P<0.01)
- Chinese cabbage: 0.869 mg/kg (Cp = 0.0575 × Cs; r = 0.965)
- Winter greens: 0.730 mg/kg (Cp = 0.0685 × Cs; r = 0.969)
- Celery: 0.489 mg/kg (Cp = 0.1022 × Cs; r = 0.983)
- Celery has the lowest threshold (most sensitive accumulator).
Zn in vegetable tissue (Table 3; nutrient-solution Zn supply 0.03 → 200 mg/L; mg/kg dry weight)
- Chinese cabbage shoot: 65.9 → 494 → 1024 → 1835 → 2975 (at supply 0.03 → 25 → 50 → 100 → 200 mg/L)
- Chinese cabbage root: 135.5 → 1167 → 2313 → 3595 → 12807
- Pakchoi shoot: 61.7 → 925 → 977 → 1883 → 2375
- Pakchoi root: 127.5 → 1587 → 2623 → 4642 → 7483
- Celery stem: 72.5 → 870 → 2820 → 4075 → 4514
- Celery leaf: 125.8 → 1295 → 2070 → 2342 → 2978
- Celery root: 115.0 → 2308 → 4350 → 7567 → 12823
- Shoots/edible parts accumulated >3-fold less Zn than roots under nutrient-solution culture.
Zn accumulation coefficient (Table 4; AF = plant Zn / total soil Zn; soil ladder CK → 200 → 400 → 600 → 800 mg/kg added Zn)
- Chinese cabbage shoot AF: 0.039 → 0.030 → 0.036 → 0.042 → 0.058
- Pakchoi shoot AF: 0.056 → 0.078 → 0.098 → 0.119 → 0.189 (rises monotonically)
- Celery stem AF: 0.113 → 0.068 → 0.069 → 0.066 → 0.068
- Celery leaf AF: 0.195 → 0.138 → 0.114 → 0.135 → 0.130
Soil Zn PDT thresholds (Table 9; against Chinese 20 mg/kg Zn food limit)
- Total soil Zn (mg/kg): Chinese cabbage 413, pakchoi 224, celery (stem) 272, celery (leaf) 122 → range 122–413
- DTPA-extractable soil Zn (mg/kg): Chinese cabbage 175.6, pakchoi 74.9, celery (stem) 101.0, celery (leaf) 19.4 → range 19.4–175.6
- Soil-Zn thresholds for 10% yield reduction (SDMYR) are systematically lower than PDT thresholds for shoot tissue but higher for celery (leaf), indicating that for some species PDT is reached before visible yield loss.
Cu in vegetable tissue (Table 6; nutrient-solution Cu supply 0.01 → 40 mg/L; mg/kg dry weight)
- Chinese cabbage shoot: 13.34 → 45.00 → 58.75 → 71.13 → 97.50
- Chinese cabbage root: 13.00 → 238.30 → 361.30 → 565.60 → 711.30
- Pakchoi shoot: 9.00 → 17.67 → 32.33 → 128.30 → 179.20
- Pakchoi root: 18.67 → 235.80 → 475.00 → 528.30 → 705.60
- Celery stem: 21.50 → 53.00 → 81.50 → 95.00 → 145.00
- Celery leaf: 31.17 → 65.83 → 101.00 → 123.30 → 166.70
- Celery root: 27.00 → 566.70 → 1312.00 → 1423.00 → 1557.00 (highest tissue Cu among the three species)
- ~10–20% of absorbed Cu translocated from root to shoot; remainder retained in roots.
Soil Cu PDT thresholds (Table 8; against Chinese 10 mg/kg Cu food limit)
- Total soil Cu (mg/kg): Chinese cabbage 835.56, pakchoi 429.93, celery (stem) 608.22, celery (leaf) 161.07 → range 161.07–835.56
- DTPA-available soil Cu (mg/kg): Chinese cabbage 338.98, pakchoi 269.14, celery (stem) 312.72, celery (leaf) 57.22 → range 57.22–338.98
- Soil total/available Cu PDT thresholds for edible parts run ~5-fold higher than thresholds for phytotoxicity (10% yield reduction) — Cu reaches PDT before visible plant injury, particularly for the more sensitive tissues.
- Among the three species, pakchoi had the lowest total and available Cu thresholds.
Pb (qualitative only)
- Edible-crop Pb limit: 0.2 mg/kg (Chinese Department of Preventive Medicine, 1994).
- Soil Pb thresholds for safe vegetable production: “not available” per the review.
- Bilateral and curvilinear correlations exist between shoot Pb and soil NH4NO3-extractable Pb (Song 2002, cited).
Al (qualitative; Zhang & Zhou 2005, cited)
- Al-based coagulants at tested concentrations inhibited seed germination of Brassica chinensis under acidic and neutral conditions.
- Curvilinear/linear positive relationships between inhibition rate and Al concentration in acidic and neutral conditions, except polyaluminum-chloride (PAC) under neutral conditions.
- Root elongation of Brassica chinensis exposed to AlCl₃ depressed in acidic pH conditions.
European urban-garden context (Lăcătuşu et al. 1996, Romania; cited p. 9)
- In neutral-to-slightly-alkaline polluted soils, soluble forms of Cd, Cu, Pb, Zn averaged 37%, 17%, 28%, and 14% of their global concentration, respectively.
- Plant uptake exceeded the maximum allowable level (MAL) for soluble forms by up to 14.8× (Pb), 4.2× (Cd), 2.1× (Zn).
- For an adult consuming 2 kg potatoes + 2 kg tomatoes + 1 kg carrots per week, intake exceeded Cd MAL by 12% (0.525 mg/wk).
- Consuming 880 g/wk of mixed vegetables (potatoes/tomatoes/carrots/cucumbers in equal parts) exceeded MAL for Pb by 23.4×, Cd 2.1×, Cu 2.8×, Zn 2.7×.
- Pb in carrots was 10× the MAL; Cd in analyzed vegetables exceeded MAL by 5×.
- Reported diseases attributed to chronic exposure: Pb and Cd intoxication, saturnine encephalopathy, radial nerve paralysis, saturnine colic — with children identified as the most affected group.
- Dietary intake estimates (cited from various 1980s–1990s studies): Pb 54–412 mg/day (Dabeca 1987; Dick 1978), Cd 10–30 mg/day (Reilly 1991), Zn 1–3 mg/day, Cu 10–20 mg/day (Fox 1982).
Methods (brief)
This is a narrative review (received 2006-05-02; accepted 2006-07-24). The authors integrate primary experimental data from their own and collaborators’ work at Zhejiang University Key Lab of Environment Remediation and Ecosystem Health (Long et al. 2003 Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal. 34:1421–1434; nickel (Ni) et al. 2002 J. Plant Nutr. 25:957–968; Yang et al. 2002 J. Environ. Sci. Health B37:625–635; Xiong & Wang 2005 Environ. Toxicol. 20:188–194; Zhang & Zhou 2005 Environ. Toxicol. 20:179–187) with literature comparators. Primary experimental designs were pot, greenhouse, and nutrient-solution cultures using Brassica and Apium cultivars in Chinese garden soil. Soil heavy metal fractionation used DTPA extraction (per Lindsay & Norvell, as documented in Shuman 1991 and Kuo 1983 frameworks cited in the references). Tissue analysis methods (AAS or ICP-MS) are referenced through the cited primary studies; the review itself does not redescribe analytical detail. Pot experiments report values as means of 3–4 replications; significant-letter coding by Duncan’s multiple range test (P<0.05 / P<0.01).
Limitations relevant to wiki use:
- This is a narrative literature review (no PRISMA, no formal quality appraisal, no meta-analysis); evidence_tier downgraded to B.
- Primary data are concentrated in Chinese garden-soil and nutrient-solution contexts; transferability to other soil types, climates, or commercial supply chains is not addressed by the review.
- Food-hygiene reference values cited are Chinese GB standards (1994/1995). Codex CXS 193 and EU Regulation 1881/2006 maximum levels for the same crops are not compared; readers wanting jurisdiction-specific PDT recalculation must substitute their own regulatory ceiling into the regression equations in Table 10.
- The Cr and Hg mentions in the abstract are not backed by quantitative data anywhere in the body. No speciation work (iAs vs total arsenic (tAs), methylmercury (MeHg) vs total mercury (tHg), hexavalent chromium (Cr-VI) vs Cr-III) is reported. The wiki
metalsfield reflects only the metals with quantitative data in the review (Cd, Zn, Cu, Pb, Al). - Lăcătuşu et al. 1996 dietary-intake values reported as “mg/day” in the review are likely “µg/day” (typical adult dietary Pb and Cd are in the µg/day range; the review’s “mg/day” reads as a units mismatch transmitted from the cited Romanian source). The Key numbers preserve the review’s printed units but flag the discrepancy here.
- Al data are summarized qualitatively from Zhang & Zhou 2005; no soil-Al PDT threshold is calculated.
Implications
Certification. The Cd regression equations in Table 10 (Cp = a × Cs, where Cp is tissue Cd mg/kg FW and Cs is soil extractable Cd mg/kg) are the most directly usable contribution for soil-screening criteria on Asian leafy-vegetable supply. The species-specific slopes (Chinese cabbage 0.0575, winter greens 0.0685, celery 0.1022) let a soil-Cd measurement be converted to expected edible-tissue Cd under any chosen food-side limit. Celery’s slope is roughly 2× that of Chinese cabbage; a single soil-Cd standard for “leafy vegetables” will under-protect celery and over-protect Chinese cabbage. Soil Zn and Cu PDT thresholds (Tables 8–9) span more than 6× across the four crop-tissue combinations and likewise resist a single-number aggregation. The review’s reliance on Chinese GB food limits means HMTc workbench use requires substituting the relevant jurisdictional ceiling (Codex CXS 193, EU 1881/2006, or HMTc’s own) into the regressions; the Cd-tissue values themselves are independent of the food-side limit.
Courses. The Tables 1–10 sequence is an unusually clean teaching set on soil-to-plant transfer: dose-response in pot cultures (Table 5), dose-response in nutrient solution (Tables 3, 6), species differences (every table), and the derivation of a soil threshold by setting a regression equal to the food-side limit (Table 10 plus surrounding text). Suitable for a worked-example module on how soil standards for vegetable production are calculated.
App. Provides Cd accumulation factors for Chinese cabbage, winter greens, pakchoi, and celery in Chinese garden soil — usable as ingredient-level priors for Asian leafy-vegetable risk estimates where soil-Cd data are available. The 2007 vintage and Chinese-soil-only context limit direct applicability to global commercial supply chains; the app should treat this as one regional/older comparator rather than a global baseline.
Related evidence
- ingredients/chinese-cabbage
- ingredients/pakchoi
- supply-chain/soil-contamination
- Agronomic mitigation
- Leafy greens
- Celery
- Cadmium
- Zinc
- Copper
- Lead
- Aluminum
Update history
No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.
