Skip to content
Heavy Metal Index

Duplicate diet study to assess dietary exposure to metals in a Japanese population

Overview

This duplicate diet study measured 12 metals (V, Co, nickel (Ni), Rb, Sr, Mo, Ag, cadmium (Cd), Sb, Cs, Ba, and Pb) in 150 complete 24-hour dietary samples from adult Japanese, collected 2017–2019. Each participant provided a duplicate portion of every food and beverage consumed across the sampling day, which was homogenized, freeze-dried, acid-digested, and analyzed by ICP-MS. The duplicate diet approach measures what people actually consumed rather than estimating intake from food composition tables and market basket statistics. The authors also estimated the contributions of incidental soil and house-dust ingestion to total oral metal exposure and compared dietary intakes against US EPA Reference Doses.

Key numbers

Median daily intake from diet (Table 4, N=150):

MetalUnitMedian(min–max)Mean (SD)
Vµg/day7.20(1.69–81.2)12.3 (13.1)
Coµg/day7.09(1.03–29.4)7.93 (4.59)
nickel (Ni)µg/day86.4(14.3–435)115 (83.8)
Rbmg/day1.49(0.348–3.34)1.58 (0.68)
Srmg/day1.21(0.334–8.29)1.88 (1.81)
Moµg/day169(30.3–538)190 (100)
Agµg/day<0.71(<0.71–14.7)1.32 (2.59)*
cadmium (Cd)µg/day12.0(1.91–42.5)13.7 (7.2)
Sbµg/day0.712(<0.56–14.7)1.07 (1.43)*
Csµg/day5.57(0.841–29.7)6.40 (4.07)
Bamg/day0.334(0.0814–0.959)0.375 (0.180)
lead (Pb)µg/day2.24(<2.3–47.2)3.44 (5.17)*

*One-half the LLD substituted for non-detect samples in mean/SD; Cd values recapitulated from Yoshinaga and Ogawa, 2024. Non-detect counts: Ag n=83, Sb n=49, lead (Pb) n=65.

Median metal concentrations in dried duplicate diet (Table 3, N=150):

MetalUnitMedian dried(min–max)Median fresh(min–max)
Vµg/kg21.6(6.10–207)3.26(0.855–35.4)
Coµg/kg19.3(5.62–98.0)2.56(0.746–13.0)
nickel (Ni)µg/kg249(37.2–1440)33.0(4.93–191)
Rbmg/kg4.04(1.18–11.8)0.537(0.156–1.57)
Srmg/kg3.10(1.02–22.3)0.411(0.135–2.96)
Moµg/kg480(135–1530)63.7(17.9–203)
Agµg/kg<1.9(<1.9–56.9)<0.30(<0.30–7.55)
cadmium (Cd)µg/kg35.1(8.81–105)4.66(1.17–13.9)
Sbµg/kg1.99(<1.5–63.3)0.264(<0.24–8.40)
Csµg/kg14.3(2.45–83.0)1.90(0.325–11.0)
Bamg/kg1.00(0.313–2.20)0.132(0.0416–0.292)
lead (Pb)µg/kg7.29(<6.2–145)0.968(<0.980–19.7)

Moisture content of the 150 diets ranged 69.6–92.5 %; mean dry-matter fraction 0.158 (factor 0.842 reported in the paper for the conversion from dried to fresh basis).

Body-weight-corrected daily intake and RfD comparison (Table 5, N=150):

MetalUnitMedian(min–max)Mean (SD)US EPA RfD
Vµg/kg/day0.108(0.0252–1.21)0.184 (0.196)9
Coµg/kg/day0.106(0.0154–0.439)0.118 (0.069)—
nickel (Ni)µg/kg/day1.29(0.214–6.45)1.72 (1.25)20
Rbµg/kg/day22.3(5.19–49.9)23.5 (10.1)—
Srµg/kg/day18.1(4.98–124)28.1 (27.0)600
Moµg/kg/day2.53(0.453–8.03)2.84 (1.50)5
Agng/kg/day<12(<12–329)20.1 (38.5)*5,000
cadmium (Cd)µg/kg/day0.180(0.0285–0.634)0.204 (0.107)1
Sbng/kg/day10.6(<9.7–204)16.2 (21.2)*400
Csµg/kg/day0.0831(0.0126–0.443)0.0955 (0.0608)—
Baµg/kg/day4.99(1.21–14.3)5.60 (2.62)200
lead (Pb)µg/kg/day0.0334(<0.039–0.705)0.0523 (0.0768)*—

Median intakes were below the EPA RfD for all metals for which an RfD is available; Co, Rb, Cs, and Pb lack EPA oral RfDs. The maximum Mo intake (8.03 µg/kg/day) exceeded the RfD of 5 µg/kg/day; the population median (2.53 µg/kg/day) is ~51 % of the RfD, leaving a narrow margin. The authors also note that the minimum Mo intake among the 150 participants (30 µg/day, from the Table 4 range minimum of 30.3 µg/day) exceeded the Japanese MHLW daily Mo requirement of 25 µg/day, so every participant met or exceeded the nutritional requirement.

Diet vs soil and house-dust contributions (Table 6):

MetalDiet µg/day (% of total)Soil µg/dayHouse dust µg/dayTotal oral µg/day
V7.20 (77 %)1.70.4929.4
Co7.09 (97 %)0.150.08867.3
nickel (Ni)86.4 (98 %)0.241.1388
Rb1490 (100 %)0.61—1491
Sr1210 (100 %)0.981.381212
Mo169 (100 %)0.0120.0406169
Ag1.32 (100 %)0.00088—1.3
cadmium (Cd)12.0 (100 %)0.00270.020812
Sb0.712 (80 %)0.00650.1770.90
Cs5.57 (99 %)0.00490.01435.6
Ba334 (98 %)3.14.14341
lead (Pb)2.24 (66 %)0.0200.9823.4

Soil and house-dust intakes computed from median environmental concentrations (Takeda et al. 2004 for soil; Yoshinaga et al. 2011 for house dust) and US EPA 2011 default adult ingestion rates (10 mg/day soil, 20 mg/day house dust). Diet contributes essentially all oral exposure for most metals; for V, Sb, and Pb, dust and soil together contribute 20–34 %.

Lower limits of detection (Table 2): in dried diet, µg/kg — V 1.8, Co 0.71, Ni 30, Rb 0.6, Sr 15, Mo 5.0, Ag 1.9, Cd 0.45, Sb 1.5, Cs 0.17, Ba 13, Pb 6.2. Corresponding daily-intake LLDs (µg/day) — V 0.68, Co 0.26, Ni 11, Rb 0.22, Sr 5.5, Mo 1.8, Ag 0.71, Cd 0.17, Sb 0.56, Cs 0.062, Ba 4.8, Pb 2.3.

Pb time-series context (Figure 1): Adult Japanese Pb intakes by sampling year — duplicate-diet studies (dark bars) reported 5.5 µg/day (2008), 4.5 (2015), 3.5 (2016), 2.24 (this study, 2018), nominal trend continued in 2019, ≈4.3 (2023); NIHS market-basket estimates (diagonal-hatched bars) consistently higher: ≈18 (2008), 12 (2015), 10 (2016), 10 (2018), ≈9 (2019). Methodological gap between approaches persists.

Method validation (Table 1): ICP-MS measurements against NIES CRM No. 27 (Typical Japanese Diet) — measured vs certified/reference (units per table): V 27.7±2.1 µg/kg (no cert), Co 20.3±0.7 µg/kg vs 22, Ni 380±25 µg/kg vs 390, Rb 4.64±0.08 mg/kg vs 4.7, Sr 4.97±0.20 mg/kg vs 4.9, Mo 0.444±0.009 mg/kg vs 0.43, Ag 5.88±0.41 µg/kg (no cert), Cd 0.063±0.003 mg/kg vs 0.069±0.009 (recapitulated from Yoshinaga and Ogawa 2024), Sb 4.98±0.58 µg/kg (no cert), Cs 20.1±0.7 µg/kg vs 20, Ba 1.14±0.03 mg/kg vs 1.1±0.1, Pb 0.592±0.025 mg/kg vs 0.62. Means agreed well with certified/reference values across the 13 repeat analyses.

Methods (brief)

24-hour duplicate diets were collected from 150 adult volunteers (65 males, 85 females, 19–83 years; 89 northern Kanto, 49 southern Kanto, 12 elsewhere in Japan) recruited 2017–2019 via newspaper advertisement and Toyo University staff/student networks. Each duplicate sample (sample weights 918–4,766 g/day; moisture 69.6–92.5 %) was homogenized in a 3 L domestic food processor (Cuisinart), freeze-dried, and pulverized. 50 mg of freeze-dried sample was nitric-acid digested (ultrapure HNO₃, Kanto Chemicals Ltd., Tokyo, Japan) in a 4.5 mL screw-capped Teflon vessel within a 25 mL Teflon outer vessel jacketed in stainless steel (Okamoto and Fuwa 1984 double-digestion method). Digests were analyzed by ICP-MS (Agilent 8800, Agilent Technologies Ltd., Japan) at the National Institute for Environmental Studies (NIES), Ibaraki, Japan, with helium collision gas (4.3 mL/min) and on-line indium (m/z 115) internal standardization. Each digestion series (n=20) included 2–3 procedural blanks, 2 sub-samples of NIES CRM No. 27 Typical Japanese Diet, and 15–16 participant samples; lower limit of detection was the 3-σ of the 16 blanks. Cd values were recapitulated from the same group’s prior study (Yoshinaga and Ogawa 2024). Distributions were non-normal (Kolmogorov–Smirnov test p<0.05); median (min–max) is the primary descriptor.

Implications

This duplicate-diet dataset provides Japan-specific adult dietary exposure benchmarks for 12 metals, computed from direct measurement of the consumed food matrix rather than from market-basket composites. The study reports diet-only oral exposure and separately estimates soil and house-dust contributions, giving an aggregated oral exposure estimate for each metal. For Pb, diet contributes 66 % of total oral exposure (2.24 µg/day from diet vs 3.4 µg/day total); for V and Sb, diet contributes 77–80 %; for the remaining metals diet is essentially the entire oral source. Maximum Mo intake exceeds the EPA RfD; the population median is at 51 % of the RfD, and median intake exceeds the Japanese MHLW daily requirement, so the margin is narrow on the high side rather than on a deficiency basis. The duplicate-diet Pb medians sit below the time-series of Japanese NIHS market-basket estimates by a factor of 2–4 across the years compared in Figure 1; the authors note that the methodology gap is unresolved.

The recruitment was non-random (newspaper plus university convenience sampling, mostly Kanto District) so the results are not a population mean; they are a snapshot of one regional adult sample. Pb was non-detect in 65 of 150 samples and the LLD (6.2 µg/kg dried diet) is high relative to clean-room work (Yoshinaga et al. 2017 reported 0.17 µg/kg under clean-room pretreatment), so the dietary Pb medians here are an upper-bound indicator rather than a definitive concentration measurement.

Update history

No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.