Overview
Open-access narrative review (CC BY 4.0, De Gruyter) synthesizing toxicological data on by-products (peels, pomace, seeds, kernels, rinds) of the world’s highest-production fruits as of 2022, motivated by the valorization push that increasingly routes these by-products into food ingredients, nutraceuticals, cosmetics, and animal feed. Scope is global; the review pulls from refs [1–142] without restricting to any single jurisdiction, growing region, or analytical method. Hazards examined are heavy metals (As, cadmium (Cd), Co, chromium (Cr), nickel (Ni), lead (Pb), Hg), mycotoxins (aflatoxins, OTA, fumonisins, ZEN, T-2, alternaria toxins, tryptoquialanines), anti-nutritional factors (oxalates, phytates, tannins, alkaloids, saponins, HCN, glycosides), toxicant organic compounds (biogenic amines, AMG, phthalates), and pesticide/fungicide residues. Final section reviews thermal, chemical, and non-thermal detoxification methods (high-pressure processing, pulsed electric field, cold plasma, supercritical CO₂, ultrasound, ozone treatment, lyophilization, fermentation).
Key numbers
Hazard quotient ranges cited from upstream literature (ref [2]) for fruit by-products generically (the review does not attribute these to any specific commodity or sample set): arsenic (As) 2.71–11.38, Cd 0.60–3.32, Cr 0.81–3.18, Co 0.03–0.09, Cu 0.09–0.26, Ni 0.08–0.34, Pb 0.83–2.23 (mg/kg basis stated in the review; HQ values above 1.0 indicate concern in cited contexts).
Table 1 (dominant heavy metals in fruit by-products, all mg/kg unless noted):
- Apple peel: Pb <1, Cd <1, Cr 0.57–3.8, Ni <1 (refs [37,40,41]).
- Apricot kernel: Cd 0.1–6, Co 2.7–35.7 (ref [42]).
- Avocado seed: Cr 0.57–2.29, Co 0.00, Pb 0.00 (refs [40,43]).
- Banana peel: As <0.0001, Cd 0.0013–0.18, Cr 1.42–4.04, Co 0.4–47.2, Ni 0.592, Pb 0.0038–0.64 (refs [36,44,45]).
- Blueberry pomace: Cd 0.011, Cr 0.242, Co 0.08, Ni 0.73 (ref [46]).
- Grape peel/skin/pomace: As 0.004, Cd <0.5, Cr 0.18–2.41, Ni <0.5, Pb 0.021–1.11 (refs [34,35,37]).
- Lemon peel by-products: Cd 0.00047–0.25, Cr 1.04, Co 0.038, Ni 0.973–1.24, Pb 0.0188–0.22 (refs [34,36,39]).
- Lime by-products: As ND, Cd 0.003, Co 0.073, Ni 1.678, Pb 0.128 (ref [39]).
- Mango (peel + seed kernel composite): Cd 0.33, Co 28.0 (ref [45]).
- Orange peel: Cd <0.5, Cr 1.04–4.14, Co 0.015, Ni 0.05–2.36, Pb 0.01–1.75 (refs [34,36,37,39,47]).
- Papaya peel + seed: As 0.0287–0.03, Cd 0.0027–0.00685, Cr 0.278–7.36, Co 0.4–219, Ni 0.246–13.2, Pb 0.03–0.044 (refs [45,48,49]).
- Peach: Cr 0.17–1.38, Pb <0.10 (ref [50]).
- Pineapple peel: As <0.0001, Cd 0.0074, Cr 8.77, Co 70.3, Pb 0.0027 (refs [44,45]).
- Plum peel: As 1.2, Cd ND, Ni 2.8, Pb ND (ref [51]). Plum kernel: As <0.1, Cd 0.13, Co 0.2, Ni 1.7, Pb 0.13 (ref [52]).
- Pomelo peel: Cd 1.36 × 10⁻³, Pb 0.0296 (ref [34]).
- Raspberry pomace: Cd 0.0084, Cr 0.116, Co 0.073, Ni 0.762, Pb 0.047 (ref [46]).
- Strawberry pomace: Cd 0.0078, Cr <0.01, Ni 0.00336, Pb 0.0011 (refs [53,54]).
- Mandarin: Cd 0.00062, Pb 0.020 (ref [38]).
- Watermelon peel + seed: Cd 0.008–0.1, Cr 4.65, Pb 0.06–0.09 (refs [40,55]).
Single-paper outlier (peel): Pineapple skin reported at 0.64 mg/100 g Pb (= 6.4 mg/kg) dry weight per refs [13,14] — above the WHO 0.02 mg/100 g (= 0.2 mg/kg) maximum limit for edible parts of crops cited in the review. Six other by-products in the same comparison (orange peel, watermelon rind, banana peel, apple pomace, strawberry pomace, grape pomace) showed Pb below 0.1 µg/L (a unit the review states without converting to mg/kg; not reconciled in the source text).
Banana peel ANFs (M. sinensis, fresh, ref [15]): alkaloid 0.66 g/100 g, oxalate 37.0 g/100 g, phytate 2.78 g/100 g, saponin 6.57 g/100 g. Same paper reported boiled banana fruit extract values higher: alkaloid 1.76 g/100 g, oxalate 40.2 g/100 g, saponin 8.12 g/100 g.
Regulatory limits cited in review (mg/kg unless noted):
- WHO maximum for Pb in edible parts of crops: 0.02 mg/100 g (= 0.2 mg/kg) (ref [12]).
- WHO maximum for As and Pb (monthly intake): 0.21 mg/100 g (ref [12]).
- WHO maximum for Cd: 0.25 mg/100 g (ref [12]).
- WHO maximum for aluminum (Al): <0.2 mg/100 g (ref [12]).
- EU Regulation 1275/2013 / Ordinance 10/2009 (animal feed): 1 mg/kg Cd, 10 mg/kg Pb (ref [38]).
- European Commission MRL for citrus by-products: As 0.02, Cd 0.02, mercury (Hg) n/a, Co n/a, Ni n/a, Pb 0.1 mg/kg (ref [56]).
- WHO/FAO RDI thresholds for orange by-product analytes: Cr 0.05–0.2, Ni 1.4, Pb 0.214 mg/day (ref [87]).
- FAO/WHO ADI: Pb 0.21–0.25 mg/day, Cd 0.06–0.07 mg/day (ref [55]).
Mycotoxin highlights (mg/kg, from Table 2 of the review):
- Apple peel/skin/seed/pomace: AOH-3-S 1.4–10.8 × 10⁻³, AME-3-S 1.7–10 × 10⁻³ (refs [57–61]).
- Apricot seeds: AFB1 and AFB2 = 0.0017–22.451 (refs [62–64]).
- Pineapple shell: Fusarium = 250 (refs [70–72]). Pineapple pomace: Aflatoxin B₂ and B₁ = 0.008 × 10⁻³, Aflatoxin G₁ = 0.013–0.033 × 10⁻³, OTA = 0.051 × 10⁻³ (refs [60,72,79]).
- Tangerine peel: tryptoquialanine A = 248.1, tryptoquialanine C = 375.80 (refs [34,60,69,72–75]).
- Watermelon peel: AOH = 0.003–0.017 (refs [60,81,82]).
- Pineapple shell mycotoxins: aflatoxin B₂, aflatoxin G₁, and OTA all measured below detection limit 2.9 × 10⁻³ mg/kg (ref [77]).
- Stępień et al. [78]: pineapple skin infected with mycotoxin mainly Fusarium 250 mg/kg (cited US FDA mycotoxin exposure guideline for total fusarium in cereal foods is 2–4 mg/kg — paper notes the cited value as hazardous without pretreatment).
ANF outliers (mg/kg):
- Orange peel oxalates: 997.8 (Table 2).
- Watermelon meal: phytate 9,900, tannin 32 × 10⁵, oxalate 2,130 (ref [81]).
- Mango kernel flour ANFs: tannins 1027.4, phytic acid 1149.8, oxalates 213.4, HCN 0.00 (ref [63]).
- Pineapple pomace: HCN 715, alkaloids 161.9.
- Apricot seed AMG (amygdalin): 52,000 mg/kg (ref [62]) — review notes 3.0 mg/kg body weight oral dose did not induce changes in rabbit spermatozoa.
Pesticide outliers (mg/kg):
- Mango peel: chlorpyrifos and methiocarb residues within Codex MRL (refs [65,66]).
- Orange pomace: imidacloprid 162.16, carbendazim 372.1, abamectin 0.261, cypermethrin 495.6, prochloraz 8.11.7 (refs [34,60,69,72–75]).
- Pomelo: total pesticides 2.143 mg/kg, procymidone 0.7 (ref [34]).
Fruit waste percentages (Figure 1b, % of fresh fruit weight discarded as by-product): pineapple peel + crown + core 60%, orange pomace 50%, lemon pomace 50%, mango peel + seed 45%, banana peel 35%, watermelon rind 33%, kiwi seeds 30%, melon peel + seed 30%, papaya peel + seed 29.5%, peach peel + seed 24.8%, grape pomace 20%, cashew-apple bagasse 20%.
Global production 2022, million tonnes (Figure 1a, FAOSTAT): bananas 135.1, watermelons 100.4, apples 95.8, oranges 76.4, mangoes/guavas/mangosteens 59.2, tangerines/mandarins/clementines 44.2, pineapples 29.4, melons 28.6, peaches/nectarines 26.4, pears 24.6, plums/sloes 12.4, papayas 13.8.
Cytotoxicity findings noted:
- Banana peel aqueous extract: no cytotoxicity to CAL 27, Caco-2, or HepG2 at 0.014–10 mg/mL across 0.5/1/2 h treatments; 10 mg/mL polysaccharide-free aqueous extract showed slight proliferation in Caco-2 (ref [105]).
- Pomelo seed oil: IC₅₀ in LO₂ and HepG2 cells 16.31–28.8 mg/mL (non-cytotoxic per the >1 mg/mL criterion stated by the review) (ref [93]).
- Avocado peel/seed (Hass and Fuerte): no cytotoxicity to RAW 264.7 cells at 0.1–100 µg/mL (ref [103]).
- Citrus deliciosa peel EO (mature fruit): IC₅₀ 110 µg/mL against HT-29 cells (ref [94]).
Methods (brief)
Narrative review, not a systematic review. The authors prioritized fruits with global production exceeding 1.2 million tonnes in 2022 per FAOSTAT (ref [22]). No PRISMA-style search strategy, inclusion/exclusion criteria, or risk-of-bias assessment is reported. No pooled estimates or meta-analytic synthesis. All numerical values are extracted from cited primary literature (refs [1–142]) and presented in Tables 1 (heavy metals), 2 (mycotoxins/toxicant organic compounds/ANFs/pesticides), and narrative subsections. Sample sizes, analytical methods, LODs, and matrix-prep conditions are not consistently reported for each entry — many cells in Table 1 give a single concentration or a range without n or method context.
Editorial timing: received 14 October 2024, accepted 24 March 2025. Open-access publication under CC BY 4.0.
Limitations explicit to this review’s evidence quality:
- Tertiary synthesis. All concentrations are second-hand from cited primary studies. Disagreements between primary sources are noted in Table 1 (e.g., banana peel Cd 0.0013–0.18 mg/kg spans two orders of magnitude across refs [36,44,45]) but not arbitrated.
- Units are inconsistent across the review body and tables. mg/kg, µg/L, mg/100 g, g/100 g, and dry-weight versus wet-weight bases are used in adjacent sentences without harmonization. The pineapple Pb 0.64 mg/100 g vs other by-products “below 0.1 µg/L” contrast is the clearest example.
- Speciation absent. Heavy metal entries are reported as total element (As, Hg, Cr) without inorganic arsenic (iAs)/total arsenic (tAs), methylmercury (MeHg)/total mercury (tHg), or hexavalent chromium (Cr-VI)/Cr-III breakdown. Toxicologically critical for As, Hg, and Cr.
- Hazard quotient ranges (As 2.71–11.38, etc.) are cited from a single upstream review (ref [2]) without identifying the underlying contamination concentrations, exposure scenarios, body-weight assumptions, or consumption rates used to compute them.
- Pineapple peel Pb outlier (0.64 mg/100 g dry weight) is presented without sample n, geographic origin, growing-region soil background, or replication context. A single dry-weight measurement reported as a hard maximum should not be over-weighted in any downstream synthesis.
- No regulatory-event documentation. The review cites WHO and EC limits as comparators but does not document any enforcement actions, recalls, or jurisdictional MRL exceedances tied to by-product valorization.
- Suspected source-printing errors preserved verbatim in Key numbers (the review is the authoritative record; we do not silently correct):
- Watermelon meal tannin “32 × 10⁵ mg/kg” (Table 2, ref [81]) implies 3,200 g/kg, which exceeds physical possibility (>100% of dry mass). Most likely intended
32 × 10²(= 3,200 mg/kg) or similar; do not propagate as a quantitative input without re-checking ref [81]. - Orange pomace “Prochloraz = 8.11.7 mg/kg” (Table 2, refs [34,60,69,72–75]) is a malformed numeric (extra decimal). Do not propagate as a quantitative input without re-checking the cited refs.
- Watermelon meal tannin “32 × 10⁵ mg/kg” (Table 2, ref [81]) implies 3,200 g/kg, which exceeds physical possibility (>100% of dry mass). Most likely intended
Implications
For certification: Pineapple peel, mango peel/kernel, orange peel, and watermelon rind concentrate metals (notably Cd, Cr, Co, Pb) and ANFs relative to whole-fruit edible flesh. Programs certifying derivative ingredients sourced from these by-products (fruit-fiber concentrates, peel-derived pectin, seed-meal flours, pomace press-cakes used as functional ingredients) cannot rely on whole-fruit contamination profiles. This review does not provide enough primary-data structure to set thresholds directly, but it establishes that by-products as a functional ingredient class warrant separate analytical treatment from the edible fraction.
For app modeling: Insufficient sample-size, LOD, and method-context disclosure to support ppb-level exposure modeling for any specific by-product ingredient. Use as a routing pointer to the primary studies cited in Tables 1 and 2 rather than as a quantitative input. The review’s chief contribution to app modeling is signaling which fruit by-products are studied at all — many tropical fruits (papaya, pomelo, cherimoya) and stone fruits beyond apricot have only one or two primary citations.
For courses and synthesis pages: Useful as the entry point for the fruit-by-product valorization domain. Sections 7 (“Current trends on fruit by-product toxicant reduction”) and Figure 4 catalog the detoxification methods (HPP, PEF, cold plasma, supercritical CO₂, ultrasound, lyophilization, fermentation) that are increasingly relevant to ingredient suppliers — material for an ingredient-handling course module.
Update history
No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.
