Overview
A fast HPLC-ICP-MS method was developed for Cr(VI) speciation in food matrices, achieving separation in 1.5 minutes using a weak anion-exchange column (Sepax Proteomix WAX-NP5) with 70 mM NH4NO3 mobile phase at pH 7.0. The limit of detection was 0.1 µg/kg, substantially better than most prior published HPLC-ICP-MS methods. When applied to seven commercially purchased food products from a Nanjing supermarket (milk powder, rice flour, whole wheat bread, yoghurt, white vinegar, orange juice, green tea), Cr(VI) was not detected in any sample. Spiking experiments revealed that Cr(VI) is unstable in food matrices and rapidly converts to Cr(III), with conversion accelerated by vitamin C, tea polyphenols, acidic conditions (pH 3.0), and elevated temperatures (80 °C). The authors conclude that natural reducing substances in foods likely prevent the occurrence of Cr(VI).
Key numbers
Method performance: LOD = 0.1 µg/kg Cr(VI) (3σ S/N). Analysis time 1.5 min per sample, versus 5–11 min for prior published HPLC-ICP-MS methods (Table 2 comparison). Linear range 0–50 µg/kg with calibration y = 587.32x − 24.39, R² = 0.9996. Precision RSD = 1.20% on five replicate measurements of a 5 µg/kg Cr(VI) standard.
Cr(VI) in the seven tested foods: not detected (< 0.1 µg/kg) in milk powder, rice flour, whole wheat bread, yoghurt, white vinegar, orange juice, and green tea (Figure 3 chromatograms; each food n = 3 triplicate measurements).
Recovery rates across three spiking approaches (spike levels 5, 25, 50 µg/kg; Table 3):
| Approach | Recovery range (%) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 1 — Cr(VI) spiked directly into the alkaline extract | 91.70 – 111.85 | Across all 7 foods × 3 spike levels |
| 2 — Cr(VI) spiked into food, extracted after 2 min | 33.91 – 104.76 | Orange juice 33.91% at 5 µg/kg was the lowest |
| 3 — Cr(VI) spiked into food, extracted after 3 h | 0 – 102.38 | Orange juice and green tea were ND at all 3 spike levels |
Cr(VI) reduction time-to-completion in spiked food components (1 g component per 1 L ultrapure water; 0.01 g for vitamin C; Cr(VI) spiked at 200 µg/kg for vitamin C and 25 µg/kg for the other five; Figure 5):
| Food component | Time to complete conversion |
|---|---|
| Vitamin C | 20 min |
| Tea polyphenols | 24 min |
| Whey proteins | 24 h |
| Gelatin | 24 h |
| Fructose | 60 h |
| Cellulose | 60 h |
Reduction-rate acceleration at 80 °C versus 25 °C (Figure 6): vitamin C 1.93×, tea polyphenols 1.04×, whey proteins 3.92×, gelatin 2.07×, fructose 10.11×, cellulose 1.70×.
Reduction-rate acceleration at pH 3.0 versus pH 7.0 (proteins/sugars/cellulose only; vitamin C and tea polyphenols already complete at neutral pH): whey proteins 5.12×, gelatin 4.47×, fructose 6.81×, cellulose 4.5×.
Methods (brief)
Speciation analysis by HPLC-ICP-MS: Agilent 1260 HPLC system coupled to an Agilent 7700 ICP-MS via PEEK tubing into the ICP nebulizer. Separation column: Sepax Proteomix WAX-NP5 weak anion-exchange (50 × 4.6 mm, 5 µm). Mobile phase 70 mM NH4NO3 adjusted to pH 7.0, isocratic at 0.8 mL/min, 5 µL injection, ambient column temperature. ICP-MS at 1550 W RF, He carrier and compensatory gas at 1.0 L/min each, time-resolved peak-hopping acquisition monitoring m/z 52 chromium (Cr). Cr(VI) was identified by retention time; Cr(III) chelated to EDTA served as the reference Cr(III) peak.
Sample extraction was modified from US EPA Method 3060A: 0.5 g sample combined with 0.5 mL phosphate buffer (0.5 M K2HPO4 + 0.5 M KH2PO4), 2.5 mL alkaline solution (0.5 M NaOH + 0.28 M Na2CO3), and 0.4 g MgCl2 in a 50 mL polyethylene tube; ultrasonic extraction 20 min in a KQ-400DE ultrasonic bath; centrifuged at 5120 × g for 5 min in an H1850 centrifuge; supernatant filtered through a 0.22 µm mixed cellulose ester membrane before injection. Calibration with Cr(III) (1000 mg/L) and Cr(VI) (100 mg/L) standards from the National Institute of Metrology (Beijing); food-grade reagents from Aladdin (Shanghai); analytical-grade salts from Macklin (Shanghai). LOD calculated as 3σ/(S/N). Triplicate runs per sample (n = 3) with mean ± SD; one-factor ANOVA + Tukey’s HSD via SPSS Statistics 25; chromatograms in Origin 2018. Published open access in MDPI Toxics under CC BY 4.0.
The paper does not report a certified reference material for Cr(VI) accuracy verification; method accuracy was assessed by spike-recovery only.
Implications
Certification (HMT&C): The paper’s main contribution to threshold work is methodological. It demonstrates that Cr(VI) is rapidly reduced to Cr(III) by reducing agents present in most foods — vitamin C, tea polyphenols, proteins, gelatin, sugars, cellulose — with timescales ranging from 20 minutes (vitamin C) to 60 hours (cellulose, fructose), accelerated by heat and acidity. For HMT&C threshold work where hexavalent chromium (Cr-VI) is a target analyte (one of the 10 official HMT&C analytes), this paper supports the view that protocols permitting prolonged contact time between sampling and extraction will systematically underestimate any Cr(VI) that was originally present, and that the fast (1.5 min) anion-exchange extraction used here represents a methodologically more defensible upper-bound. The negative result (Cr(VI) ND across all seven foods, LOD 0.1 µg/kg) is, in the authors’ own framing (introduction §1 citing Novotnik et al. [9] and Vacchina et al. [10]; conclusion §4), consistent with the position that Cr(VI) is generally absent from plant-based and animal-derived foods at typical detection limits.
Courses: Excellent teaching case for the distinction between total Cr and Cr-VI: foods can contain detectable total Cr while having effectively zero Cr-VI because the food matrix reduces Cr(VI) to Cr(III). Vitamin C and tea polyphenols are quantitatively the most potent reducing agents identified; protein and gelatin matrices reduce more slowly due to steric hindrance and less favorable electron-donating geometry; cellulose and fructose reduce slowest. Heat and acidic conditions during food processing further accelerate the Cr(VI) → Cr(III) conversion, particularly for protein, sugar, and cellulose matrices.
App: Reinforces the wiki rule that Cr-VI must be distinguished from total Cr in occurrence reporting. In this single seven-food study, Cr(VI) was not detected at LOD 0.1 µg/kg, and the spike-recovery experiments showed effectively complete loss of Cr(VI) within 3 h of contact for orange juice and green tea (and partial loss for the other five matrices). The paper’s authors conclude (§4) that Cr(VI) is “unlikely to be present in foods”; the wiki and app should mirror that single-paper finding without extrapolating beyond it, while continuing to treat total Cr as a separately quantifiable analyte.
Related evidence
- Chromium
- Chromium, Hexavalent
- Tea
- Rice Flour
- Orange juice
- Yogurt
- Vinegar
- Whole wheat bread
- Milk and Dairy
- ingredients/milk
- Wheat
- testing/arsenic-speciation
Update history
No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.
