Skip to content
Heavy Metal Index

Speciation analysis of Cr(III) and Cr(VI) in bread and breakfast cereals using species-specific isotope dilution and HPLC-ICP-MS

Overview

This study developed and validated a method for simultaneous Cr(III) and Cr(VI) speciation in bread and breakfast cereals using species-specific isotope dilution (SS-ID) coupled to HPLC-ICP-MS, then applied it to 22 retail samples (11 breads, 11 breakfast cereals) purchased in Denmark and France. The SS-ID approach corrects for any species interconversion that occurs during sample preparation, which is the principal weakness of conventional speciation methods. Cr(VI) was below the 0.047 µg/kg quantification limit in every sample analyzed; all chromium present was Cr(III), with concentrations spanning 5.2–176 µg/kg in breads and 23.8–350 µg/kg in breakfast cereals. The Cr(III) totals agreed with independent total-Cr measurements by ICP-MS to within 87–109%. The authors also performed Cr(VI) spike-recovery experiments on bread and recovered all of the spiked Cr(VI) as Cr(III), supporting the hypothesis that the bread matrix actively reduces Cr(VI) to Cr(III) and that prior reports of Cr(VI) in such matrices are most likely analytical artefacts.

Key numbers

Cr(III) by SS-ID HPLC-ICP-MS vs total chromium (Cr) by ICP-MS (µg/kg, mean ± SD, n=2 per sample; Table 7):

SampleTotal Cr (ICP-MS)Cr(III) (SS-ID)Cr(VI) (SS-ID)Cr(III)/total Cr (%)
Danish rugbrød (rye)86 ± 588 ± 5< 0.047102
Malt flour bread (malted wheat)67 ± 267 ± 3< 0.047101
”Burger” buns (wheat)170 ± 2170 ± 6< 0.047100
Spelt bread (spelt)202 ± 3176 ± 6< 0.04787
”Pita” bread (wheat)76 ± 577 ± 2< 0.047101
Baguette (wheat)135 ± 19131 ± 8< 0.04797
Sandwich (wheat)45 ± 644 ± 3< 0.04798
Wheat bread (wheat)< 106 ± 1< 0.047—
Bread toasted (wheat)< 105 ± 1< 0.047—
Bread toasted complete (wheat)< 1010 ± 1< 0.047—
French bread (wheat)27 ± 427 ± 1< 0.047101
Cocoa cereals (20.1%, brand I)360 ± 51350 ± 6< 0.04797
High-bran flake cereal67 ± 363 ± 5< 0.04794
Bran flakes bio26 ± 125 ± 1< 0.04796
Corn flakes24 ± 126 ± 1< 0.047106
Whole-grain wheat25 ± 125 ± 2< 0.047100
Whole-grain wheat + fruit + nuts62 ± 263 ± 2< 0.047102
Cocoa cereals (16.5%, brand II)219 ± 7238 ± 1< 0.047109
Granola (rolled oats) bio42 ± 240 ± 3< 0.04796
Granola (rolled oats) gluten free26 ± 027 ± 1< 0.047105
Fruity muesli26 ± 124 ± 2< 0.04790
Toasted muesli41 ± 140 ± 1< 0.04797

Range summary:

  • Bread Cr(III): 5.2–176 µg/kg (spelt bread is the maximum).
  • Breakfast-cereal Cr(III): 23.8–350 µg/kg (20.1% cocoa cereals is the maximum; the cocoa cereals dominate the upper tail of the dataset).
  • Cr(VI): not detected in any sample (< LOQ of 0.047 µg/kg).
  • Cr(III)/total-Cr ratio: 87–102% across breads with quantifiable total Cr; 90–109% across breakfast cereals — consistent with all measured Cr being Cr(III).

Cr(VI) spike-recovery experiments on French wheat bread (Fig. 1; n=4 spike levels at 5, 10, 15, 20 µg/kg):

  • When the sample was spiked with Cr(III), Cr(III) was recovered quantitatively (104 ± 5%) and Cr(VI) remained undetected.
  • When the same sample was spiked with Cr(VI) at the same levels, the spike was recovered entirely as Cr(III) (98 ± 7%) and Cr(VI) remained undetected.
  • This is the load-bearing evidence in the paper: the bread matrix reduces added Cr(VI) to Cr(III) quantitatively, so Cr(VI) cannot be measured in bread matrices using extraction approaches that do not correct for species interconversion.

Method validation (accuracy profile, three measurement series × duplicate × 5 days over one month; Table 6):

  • Trueness (bias): individual matrix/level values run from −0.31% to +0.49% (Cr(III) values 0.30, −0.02, −0.31, 0.01 across the four matrix levels; Cr(VI) values 0.03, 0.14, 0.49 across the three spike levels). The paper summarizes this as “<1% in all cases” (§3.2).
  • Repeatability (CV_r): 1.3–4.4% for Cr(III); 0.6–7.9% for Cr(VI).
  • Intermediate reproducibility (CV_R): 1.3–4.4% for Cr(III); 2.0–8.9% for Cr(VI).
  • LOQ (IUPAC, 10× σ_0 from 21 blank replicates, 0.3 g test portion): 14 ng/kg for Cr(III); 47 ng/kg for Cr(VI). The authors note these LOQs are substantially lower than off-line speciation methods reported in the literature (Hernandez 2017/2018, Mathebula 2017).
  • Cr(III) recovery factors in two bread matrices (Table 5; recovery factor = Cr(III) by SS-ID compared to total Cr by ICP-MS): 97–113% across all eight unspiked-plus-spiked cells. At the 5/10/15 µg/kg spike levels alone, recoveries are 99–113%; the 97% lower bound comes from the unspiked (0 µg/kg added) baseline cell where the genuine Cr(III) is compared against total Cr.
  • NIST 8436 (Durum wheat flour) certified reference material recovered at 96–103% for the Cr(III) + Cr(VI) sum over 5 measurement days (the CRM has a certified value for total Cr only; the paper uses it to validate the sum of speciated Cr against the certified total).

Extraction-condition sensitivity (Table 3, French bread, n=2): Using the milk/meat protocol (70 °C × 25 min EDTA + 70 °C × 25 min DPC) on bread produced an apparent Cr(VI) value of 28.5 ± 2.8 µg/kg, which the optimized 90 °C × 60 min EDTA step then revealed to be an artefact: at the optimal conditions Cr(III) was 25.8 ± 0.4 µg/kg and Cr(VI) was < LOQ. The “Cr(VI)” measured under sub-optimal conditions is genuinely Cr(III) that failed to release into the EDTA step and was subsequently captured during the DPC step. This is a direct experimental demonstration of how Cr(VI) over-reporting in cereal matrices can arise from extraction-step design alone, even before considering matrix reduction.

Dietary exposure to Cr from cereal products in DK and FR (Table 8; FAOSTAT 2018 consumption × measured Cr(III) levels; 70 kg body weight):

  • Wheat: 0.017–1.168 µg/kg bw/day (DK); 0.024–1.593 µg/kg bw/day (FR).
  • Maize: 0.006 µg/kg bw/day (DK); 0.014 µg/kg bw/day (FR).
  • Rye: 0.044 µg/kg bw/day (DK); 0.001 µg/kg bw/day (FR).
  • Oats: 0.004–0.006 µg/kg bw/day (DK); ~0.001 µg/kg bw/day (FR).
  • Malt: ~0.000 µg/kg bw/day (DK); 0.001 µg/kg bw/day (FR).
  • All values are several orders of magnitude below the EFSA 2014 TDI of 300 µg/kg bw/day for Cr(III) and the US IOM adequate-intake range of 20–35 µg/day for adults; cereal-derived Cr exposure is not a regulatory or toxicological concern in either country on these data.

Methods

Speciation analysis (SS-ID HPLC-ICP-MS). ~0.3 g of homogenized bread or breakfast cereal was weighed into a 50 mL polypropylene tube and spiked with isotopically enriched ⁵⁰Cr(III) (97.4% enrichment, ISC Science) and ⁵³Cr(VI) (92.4% enrichment, ISC Science) at amounts chosen to bring blend ⁵⁰Cr/⁵²Cr and ⁵³Cr/⁵²Cr isotope ratios to ~1. 16 mL of 2.4 mM EDTA (Sigma-Aldrich, 99.995%) was added and the mixture heated in a water bath at 90 °C for 60 min to extract and complex genuine Cr(III). After cooling (~15 min), 200 µL of 0.02 mM DPC (1,5-diphenylcarbazide, Sigma-Aldrich, in methanol/sulfuric acid) was added, volume brought to 20 mL with ultrapure water, and the mixture re-heated at 90 °C for 25 min to reduce any Cr(VI) to Cr(III) and complex it as Cr(III)-DPCO. Extracts were cooled to room temperature and filtered through 0.45 µm PVDF syringe filters before same-day analysis. The 90 °C × 60 min first step was experimentally established as necessary to release genuine Cr(III) from the bread matrix — the milk/meat protocol (70 °C × 25 min) does not (Table 3).

HPLC separation. Dionex IonPac AG7 anion-exchange column (2 mm × 50 mm, 10 µm) on a Dionex ICS-5000+ (at Anses, France) or ICS-6000 (at DTU Food, Denmark). Mobile phase 10 mM HNO₃ + 2.5% methanol + 0.30 mM EDTA (pH 2.1), isocratic, 0.20 mL/min, 5 µL injection, column 30 °C, injector 5 °C. The Cr(III)-EDTA and Cr(III)-DPCO complexes co-eluted as separated peaks in under 3 min.

ICP-MS detection. Thermo iCAP TQ (at DTU) for speciation; Agilent 7700 (at Anses) and iCAP TQ used for total Cr. PFA standard nebulizer, cyclonic quartz spray chamber, He collision cell (KED mode) at ~5 mL/min, 1550 W plasma power, monitoring ⁵⁰Cr, ⁵²Cr, ⁵³Cr, ⁴⁵Sc (internal standard).

Total Cr determination. Closed-vessel microwave digestion (Anton Paar Multiwave 3000): 0.3 g sample + 3 mL concentrated HNO₃ (67% m/m, Merck) + 3 mL ultrapure water in 80 mL quartz vessels; digest diluted to 50 mL with the addition of ⁴⁵Sc as internal standard. External calibration 1.0–10.0 µg/L. Performed in duplicate at Anses and DTU. Method is the accredited 31-element procedure from Chevallier et al. 2015.

Validation. Accuracy profile per AFNOR NF V03-110 / Thompson et al. 2002 IUPAC guideline: three measurement series in duplicate on 5 separate days over one month. Three bread samples spiked with Cr(VI) at 5, 10, 15 µg/kg; two bread samples spiked with Cr(III) at 5, 10, 15 µg/kg. Validity domain: LOQ to 15 µg/kg. NIST 8436 Durum wheat flour CRM analyzed alongside food samples for internal QC.

Risk-assessment calculation. Daily exposure E_i = Σ (C_i,k × L_k) / W_i, where C is daily consumption (FAOSTAT 2018, Denmark and France), L is the measured Cr(III) level in this study, and W = 70 kg adult body weight. Compared against EFSA 2014 TDI of 300 µg/kg bw/day and US IOM 2001 adequate-intake range 20–35 µg/day.

Implications

This source is the principal A-tier methodological reference for the position that Cr(VI) is not analytically detectable in bread or breakfast cereals when measured by a method that corrects for species interconversion, and that prior literature reports of Cr(VI) presence in such matrices (Soares 2010, Mathebula 2017, both cited and discussed in §3.4) are most likely artefacts of off-line analytical procedures lacking on-line species separation and isotope-dilution correction. The matrix-reduction experimental evidence (Cr(VI) spike → recovered entirely as Cr(III), n=4) is the load-bearing finding and is what distinguishes this paper from a method-validation report.

For contributing-source synthesis on grain-based product and ingredient pages, the dataset establishes Cr(III) ranges for typical European bread and breakfast cereal samples (5–350 µg/kg, with cocoa-containing breakfast cereals and spelt bread driving the upper end) and supports the working assumption — at the synthesis level, not in this source page — that total Cr in grain matrices is essentially equivalent to Cr(III) for routing purposes. The exposure calculations in Table 8 provide a quantitative baseline against the EFSA TDI for the rare case where a synthesis page needs to bound cereal-derived Cr intake in EU adults.

Update history

No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.