Skip to content
Heavy Metal Index

Determination of Metals Contamination in Rock Melon (Cucumis melo) and Coco Peat

Overview

Rock melon fruits (Cucumis melo, cultivar ‘Glamour’, n=70) from five Malaysian farm locations — selected because preliminary testing had already shown elevated metals — were analyzed for aluminum (Al), B, Co, chromium (Cr), Cu, Fe, Mn, nickel (Ni), lead (Pb), and Zn by ICP-OES. Six of the ten elements (Al, Cr, Cu, Fe, Pb, Zn) exceeded Malaysian Food Act (1983) / Malaysian Food Regulation (1985) maximum allowable limits (MALs) in the fruit; B, Mn, and Ni did not exceed; Co was not detected. The coco peat growth medium used in the fertigation system also showed elevated metals (Al, Cu, Fe, Mn, Ni, Pb above MAL in coco peat), which the authors propose as a contamination pathway pending confirmatory work.

Key numbers

Concentrations in Cucumis melo (means ± SD across 5 farms, ppm = mg/kg in the analyzed sample; basis not explicitly stated by source — see Methods):

ElementMean ± SD (ppm)Malaysian MAL (ppm)Exceeds MAL?
aluminum (Al)60.14 ± 0.39350Yes (~1.2×)
B15.0018No
Conot detected15—
chromium (Cr)6.42 ± 0.1705Yes (~1.3×)
Cu17.4 ± 0.0794Yes (~4×)
Fe102.62 ± 0.11450Yes (~2×)
Mn4.4320No
nickel (Ni)3.258No
lead (Pb)1.82 ± 0.2350.5Yes (~3.6×)
Zn11.97 ± 0.8211.2Yes (~10×)

Per-farm Pb means (Table 2): Mantin-1 1.81, Mantin-2 1.89, Mantin-3 1.78, Klang-1 1.74, Klang-2 1.82 ppm. Mean Pb range across farms 1.74–1.89 ppm. Mean Pb across all 70 fruits 1.82 ppm; SPI/MPI/PI risk indices were not reported.

Note: Cr measured as total chromium; no hexavalent chromium (Cr-VI) speciation performed. Pb, Al, and Ni are HMT&C target analytes; Cr-VI is on the HMT&C list but only total Cr was measured here, so this paper does not contribute to Cr-VI evidence. Cu, Fe, Mn, Zn, B, and Co are not HMT&C analytes but are reported for completeness.

Comparison with international limits in mg/kg: Pb 1.82 mg/kg is ~18× the EU Regulation 1881/2006 limit for fruits (0.10 mg/kg), and exceeds the Malaysian MAL of 0.50 mg/kg by ~3.6×. The Malaysian MAL for Pb in fruit (0.50 mg/kg) is itself permissive relative to EU and Codex limits.

Sampling caveat: farms were chosen because preliminary tests had already shown elevated metals. These values are not representative of typical Malaysian rock melon retail and are upper-bound, biased outlier values rather than a national survey.

Methods (brief)

Sampling: completely randomized design with 14 fruit replications per location across 5 farms (3 farms at Mantin, Negeri Sembilan; 2 farms at Jalan Kebun, Klang, Selangor). Coco peat samples (70 used as growth medium plus 14 fresh-before-use) collected from the same farms.

Instrument: Inductively Coupled Plasma Optical Emission Spectrometry (ICP-OES) at the soil laboratory, Faculty of Applied Science, Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM), Shah Alam. The paper does not describe sample preparation (acid digestion protocol, drying schedule, particle size), instrument operating conditions, calibration standards, limits of detection, recovery checks, or QA/QC procedures. Statistical reporting is limited to per-cell means with SDs and asterisk codes for significance vs. MAL (* p<0.05, ** p<0.01, *** p<0.001) but the test underlying those flags is not named.

Basis ambiguity: the paper reports concentrations in “ppm” without specifying wet vs. dry weight. Fe 102.62 ppm and Al 60.14 ppm in fresh melon flesh are implausibly high if interpreted as wet weight (typical fresh melon Fe is ~1–5 ppm wet weight, Al typically <1 ppm wet weight), suggesting either a dry-weight basis or a substantial methodological artefact (e.g., inadequate washing, surface contamination from soil/coco-peat residue, or contamination during digestion at the soil lab). The paper itself draws no distinction. Coco peat values (Table 1: Al 1220 ppm, Fe 210.53 ppm) are consistent with dry-weight reporting in a substrate context.

Evidence tier B: regional journal (Jurnal Intelek, UiTM Perlis), no DOI, methods reporting is thin, sample selection is explicitly biased toward known-contaminated farms.

Implications

Certification: Pb at 1.82 mg/kg in rock melon from these contaminated Malaysian farms is approximately 18× the EU Regulation 1881/2006 fruit limit (0.10 mg/kg) and exceeds the Malaysian MAL by ~3.6×. However, farm-selection bias plus basis ambiguity preclude using these values as evidence of typical Malaysian rock-melon contamination. Useful only as upper-bound outlier evidence and as illustration of a contaminated-growing-medium pathway in fertigation systems.

Courses: Useful illustration of (a) coco-peat growing medium as a metal contamination vector in soilless/fertigation cultivation, (b) the importance of basis specification (wet vs. dry weight) in interpreting reported ppm values, and (c) how biased farm selection limits the inferential reach of a contamination survey.

App: Not suitable for typical contamination profiling of melons given biased farm selection and basis ambiguity. Provides upper-bound outlier context only.

Update history

No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.