Skip to content
Heavy Metal Index

Studies on seasonal pollution of heavy metals in water, sediment, fish and oyster from the Meiliang Bay of Taihu Lake in China

Overview

This study measured lead (Pb), cadmium (Cd), chromium (Cr), and Cu in surface water, sediment, and tissues of crucian carp (Carassius carassius) and Pacific oyster (Crassostrea gigas) across four seasons (winter, spring, summer, autumn 2016) at seven sites in Meiliang Bay of Taihu Lake, China’s third-largest freshwater lake. Metal concentrations in water, sediment, and biota were significantly higher in winter and summer than in spring and autumn (one-way ANOVA, p<0.001), attributed to greater agricultural waste, sewage, and flood inputs during those periods. The order of accumulation across compartments was Pb > Cu > Cr > Cd in fish and Pb > Cu > Cr > Cd in oyster; in fish organs the order was liver > kidney > gill > intestine > muscle. The pollution load index (PLI) exceeded 1 across all sediment sites and seasons, and the contamination factor (CF) for Cr in winter sediment reached the “very high degree” category (CF ≥ 6). Average winter oyster Pb (3.03 µg/g wet weight) exceeded the Chinese Ministry of Agriculture residue limit for aquatic products (NY 5073-2001, 1.0 µg/g); average oyster Cu in winter (2.74 µg/g) and summer (1.48 µg/g) exceeded the Chinese Ministry of Health Maximum Levels of Contaminants in Foods (GB 2762-2005, 0.5 µg/g for Cu in aquatic products).

Key numbers

All units exactly as the source reports them. Water in µg/L, sediment and biota in µg/g wet weight (Table 1b note, Table 3 note, and §2.2.3 explicitly state wet-weight basis for fish and oyster tissues).

Water — average concentrations across seven sites (Table 1b)

SeasonCu (µg/L)Cr (µg/L)Cd (µg/L)Pb (µg/L)
Winter0.34 ± 0.192.84 ± 0.760.74 ± 0.175.06 ± 1.73
Spring0.11 ± 0.020.33 ± 0.250.13 ± 0.282.28 ± 1.16
Summer1.06 ± 0.210.35 ± 0.090.24 ± 0.126.00 ± 0.41
Autumn0.47 ± 0.200.07 ± 0.030.14 ± 0.160.26 ± 0.71

Reference standards (µg/L) provided in Table 1b: Chinese Drinking Water (CDW, ECR 2006) — Cu 1000, Cr 50, Cd 0.5, Pb 10. USEPA TRV (1999, freshwater toxicity reference) — Cu 9, Cr 11, Cd 2, Pb 3. WHO 2006 drinking water — Cu 2000, Cr 5, Cd 3, Pb 10.

Exceedances vs CDW: average Cd in winter (0.74 µg/L) exceeded the 0.5 µg/L drinking-water limit at all seven sites; no average Pb or Cr value across the four seasons exceeded CDW. Cd at site S7 winter reached 0.97 µg/L (nearly 2× CDW). The abstract’s framing “Pb content in the water of Lake Taihu exceeded international safety thresholds” is paper-internally inconsistent with Table 1b; Pb did not exceed CDW or WHO drinking-water limits but did exceed the USEPA TRV freshwater criterion of 3 µg/L in winter (5.06), spring (only at the highest-loaded sites), and summer (6.00). See verification notes.

Sediment — average concentrations across seven sites (Table 1b)

SeasonCu (µg/g)Cr (µg/g)Cd (µg/g)Pb (µg/g)
Winter7.19 ± 1.1613.99 ± 2.420.50 ± 0.178.53 ± 1.25
Spring0.51 ± 0.370.14 ± 0.070.11 ± 0.050.20 ± 0.08
Summer2.80 ± 0.541.91 ± 0.600.23 ± 0.045.14 ± 0.76
Autumn0.70 ± 0.191.10 ± 0.340.10 ± 0.040.57 ± 0.23

The peak winter Cr value at site S2 was 14.65 µg/g and at site S4 was 17.04 µg/g (Table 1b). The contamination factor (CF) plot (Fig. 4B) shows Cr CF in the “very high degree” range (CF ≥ 6) — reading from the chart, winter Cr CF ≈ 14. Cu and Pb CF were in the “considerable degree” range (3 ≤ CF < 6) in winter and summer. PLI (Fig. 4A) exceeded 1 across all sites and seasons, ranging 6.96–11.25 in winter and 1.59–2.16 in autumn. Geoaccumulation index Igeo (Fig. 4C) put Cr in the “strongly polluted” band, Cu and Pb in the “moderately to strongly polluted” band, and Cd “practically unpolluted.”

Fish — Carassius carassius, average across organs by season (Table 3, µg/g wet weight)

Table 3 reports a single Cu/Cr/Cd/Pb value per season for the fish (Table 3 header Carassius auratus, treated as a typo for C. carassius per the abstract, §2.3, and §3.3 of the paper; see verification notes). Section 3.3 explicitly states n=4 per ANOVA, with per-organ values shown in Fig. 2.

SeasonCu (µg/g w.w.)Cr (µg/g w.w.)Cd (µg/g w.w.)Pb (µg/g w.w.)
Winter1.47 ± 0.070.50 ± 0.030.11 ± 1.161.20 ± 0.05
Spring0.15 ± 0.020.12 ± 0.000.05 ± 0.010.92 ± 0.04
Summer0.54 ± 0.010.22 ± 0.060.02 ± 0.010.56 ± 0.03
Autumn0.39 ± 0.020.17 ± 0.010.08 ± 0.000.35 ± 0.02

Fish-organ pattern (Fig. 2; bar-chart readout, wet weight): Pb is consistently the highest metal across all five organs in all seasons. Per-organ ranges in winter: muscle Pb ~1.4, gill Pb ~1.5, liver Pb ~1.6, kidney Pb ~1.4, intestine Pb ~2.7 µg/g. Cd is consistently the lowest, typically <0.1 µg/g across all organs and seasons. Cu peaks in summer gill at ~1.0 µg/g. The accumulation order in tissues across seasons is liver ≥ kidney > gill > intestine > muscle per §3.3.

Permissible limits in fish provided in Table 3 (µg/g wet weight): FAO 1983 — Cd 2, Pb 1–6; WHO 2006 — Cu 3, Cr 0.15, Pb 2; EU 2001 — Cu 1, Cr 1; FEPA 2003 — Cu 1.3, Cr 0.15. Winter fish Cu (1.47) exceeded the EU 2001 and FEPA 2003 Cu limits (1.0 and 1.3 µg/g) but not the WHO 2006 limit (3 µg/g). Winter fish Cr (0.50) exceeded the WHO 2006 and FEPA 2003 Cr limits (0.15 µg/g) but not the EU 2001 limit (1.0). Winter fish Pb (1.20) was below the WHO 2006 fish limit of 2 µg/g (1.20 < 2) and below the FAO 1983 range upper bound (1–6 µg/g).

Oyster — Crassostrea gigas, whole-body average by season (Table 3, µg/g wet weight)

SeasonCu (µg/g w.w.)Cr (µg/g w.w.)Cd (µg/g w.w.)Pb (µg/g w.w.)
Winter2.74 ± 0.181.23 ± 0.070.32 ± 0.153.03 ± 0.25
Spring0.39 ± 0.110.16 ± 0.040.14 ± 0.060.53 ± 0.10
Summer1.48 ± 0.090.79 ± 0.050.17 ± 0.021.85 ± 0.55
Autumn0.50 ± 0.150.23 ± 0.050.05 ± 0.090.55 ± 0.09

Regulatory comparisons against oyster-specific limits provided in Table 3 (µg/g w.w.). Two Chinese standards are tabulated in Table 3’s oyster section: GB 2762-2005 (row label; footnote 13 in the paper text describes it as the Ministry of Health Maximum Levels of Contaminants in Foods) — Cu —, Cr 2.0, Cd 0.1, Pb 0.5; NY 5073-2006 (row label; footnote 14; Ministry of Agriculture residue limits for nuisanceless foods and aquatic products) — Cu 50, Cr —, Cd 1.0, Pb 1.0. The §4 Discussion text on page 635 cites a 0.5 µg/g Cu limit for aquatic products from GB 2762-2005, which is not present in the Table 3 row (GB 2762-2005 row shows ”—” for Cu); and refers to the NY standard as “NY 5073-2001” rather than the Table 3 row’s “NY 5073-2006.” These inconsistencies between Table 3 row labels, Table 3 footnotes, and §4 Discussion prose are paper-internal; values reported here come from Table 3 row entries and the §4 Discussion’s prose-cited Cu 0.5 µg/g GB 2762-2005 figure is also reported because the paper relies on it for the GB 2762-2005 Cu exceedance claim. See verification notes.

Exceedances on the Table 3 values: winter oyster Pb (3.03) and summer oyster Pb (1.85) exceeded the NY 5073-2006 Pb limit of 1.0 µg/g (factors of 3.0× and 1.9×). All four seasons of oyster Pb exceeded the GB 2762-2005 Pb limit of 0.5 µg/g (winter 6.1×, spring 1.1×, summer 3.7×, autumn 1.1×). Winter oyster Cd (0.32) exceeded the GB 2762-2005 Cd limit of 0.1 µg/g (3.2×); spring (0.14), summer (0.17) also exceeded; autumn (0.05) did not. Winter oyster Cu (2.74) and summer oyster Cu (1.48) exceeded the §4 Discussion’s cited 0.5 µg/g Cu aquatic-product limit (attributed to GB 2762-2005 in the prose); autumn Cu (0.50) was at the limit. Winter oyster Cr (1.23) was below the GB 2762-2005 Cr 2.0 µg/g limit but exceeded the WHO 2006 Cr-in-fish reference of 0.15 µg/g (the paper provides no oyster-specific Cr limit). The §4 Discussion’s prose statement “high level of Pb in both summer (average, 3.1 µg/g wet weight) and autumn (average, 3.3 µg/g wet weight) oyster” does not match Table 3 (summer 1.85, autumn 0.55); Table 3 is treated as authoritative (see verification notes).

Correlation matrix (Table 2)

Across all 28 water samples (p<0.05, **p<0.01, ***p<0.001): the strongest water correlation is Cr–Cd (r=0.81, p<0.001). In sediment (n=28) all six pairwise correlations were significant at p<0.001 or p<0.01: Cu–Cr 0.95, Pb–Cu 0.94, Pb–Cr 0.96, Cd–Cu 0.82, Cd–Cr 0.73, Cd–Pb 0.83. For oyster (n=4) all correlations were significant: Cr–Cu 0.98, Cd–Cu 0.89, Cd–Cr 0.91, Pb–Cu 0.96, Pb–Cr 0.99, Pb–Cd 0.73.

Methods (brief)

Surface water collected with an Aqua trap water sampler at seven sites in Meiliang Bay across four seasons in 2016. Water: 2 mL conc. HNO₃ added to each 1-L sample in the field after filtration; liquid-liquid extraction by the Mentasti et al. (1989) method; back-extracted into conc. HNO₃ with high-purity water; evaporated on a low-temperature hot plate; analyzed by atomic absorption spectrometry on a ZEEnit-700P (Analytik Jena). Sediment: Van Veen grab sampler; dried at 40 °C; ~1 g dry sample digested with HClO₄ (2 mL) + HF (10 mL) + HCl (2 mL); residue dissolved in concentrated HCl, brought to 25 mL; analyzed by flame AAS. Fish and oyster: tissues dissected immediately after transport, rinsed in Milli-Q water, stored at −20 °C, thawed, dried to constant weight 24 h at 80 °C, ground in a porcelain mortar; method modified from Jayaprakash et al. (2015); analyzed for Pb, Cd, Cr, Cu on a ZEEnit 700P AAS; concentrations expressed as µg/g wet weight of tissue (Kingston and Jassie 1988 procedure). Standard reference materials: BCSS-1 (sediment) and DORM-2 (dogfish muscle), National Research Council of Canada; recovery 95.4–100% for Cu, Cr, Cd, Pb (Table 1a). MESS-1 SRM run every fifth sediment sample (recovery 91.38–98.81%; §2.2.2 prints “98.8071.93%” — typographical error for the recovery range). Detection limits (Table 1a, µg/kg): Cu 0.014, Cr 0.007, Cd 0.001, Pb 0.05. Pollution load index (PLI; Tomilson et al. 1980) computed as the nth root of the product of contamination factors. Geoaccumulation index Igeo = log₂(Cₙ / 1.5 Bₙ) using crustal-shale background (Islam et al. 2014). Statistics: SPSS v20 one-way ANOVA at p<0.05, p<0.01, p<0.001; correlations in Excel 2010. Only total metals are reported; no speciation (no inorganic arsenic (iAs)/total arsenic (tAs) split, no hexavalent chromium (Cr-VI)/Cr-III split, no methylmercury (MeHg)/total mercury (tHg) split). The paper does not measure mercury (Hg), arsenic (As), nickel (Ni), aluminum (Al), tin (Sn), Sb, or uranium (U).

Implications

Certification: Directly relevant to HMTc fish (specifically freshwater fish) and shellfish (oyster/bivalve) product categories. The dominant metal in both freshwater fish and oyster from a heavily industrialized Chinese lake was Pb, not Cd or Hg; this is the leading analyte of concern for HMTc work on freshwater aquaculture and bivalves sourced from comparable East Asian inland waters. The Pb-in-oyster exceedance vs the Chinese NY 5073-2001 limit (winter 3.0×, summer 1.9×) is a real category-level exposure signal. Note that this paper measures Pb, Cd, Cr, Cu only; it provides no Hg, As, or Cr-VI evidence, which limits its contribution to the full ten-analyte HMTc certification list for these categories.

Courses: Useful as a case study for (1) organ-specific bioaccumulation in fish (liver/kidney dominate over muscle/fillet, so muscle-only sampling underestimates exposure), (2) bivalve filter-feeder bioaccumulation (oyster Pb concentrations were 2.5–3× higher than fish Pb concentrations in the same lake), and (3) seasonal variability driven by hydrology and pollution loading (winter and summer dry/flood periods yielded higher tissue concentrations than spring/autumn rainfall periods).

App: Contamination-profile context for the freshwater-fish ingredient (Pb dominates over Cd in Chinese freshwater fish; per-organ concentration matters for the fillet-vs-whole-fish exposure assumption) and for the bivalve-molluscs ingredient (oyster Pb in heavily polluted Chinese lake substantially higher than the Chinese aquatic-product limit; seasonality matters). Not a direct contribution to typical_ppb / p95_ppb values since the paper does not report fillet-only fish data with the structure most exposure models assume.

Microbiome: Not addressed. Paper does not measure microbial communities.

Provenance notes

Open-access mode unconfirmed. Article published in Chemosphere (Elsevier, Volume 191, January 2018, pp. 626–638), DOI 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2017.10.078. PDF supplied via the Papers Cube Manual Fetch process; preserved at the archived source file. License field unknown pending check of the Elsevier license terms for this article.

Update history

No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.