Skip to content
Heavy Metal Index

Nutrient exploration and heavy metal risk assessment of baby milk and infant formulae sold within Umuahia metropolis, Nigeria

Overview

This Scientific Reports study from Michael Okpara University of Agriculture (Umudike, Abia State) analyses proximate composition, macro/micro minerals, and five heavy metals (Pb, nickel (Ni), Cu, cadmium (Cd), Cr) by atomic absorption spectrometry in 8 baby milk (milk-based powder) and 12 infant formula (cereal-based) products sold in Umuahia metropolis, Nigeria. All eight baby milk samples exceeded the WHO (2023) lead limit of 0.03 mg/kg (range 0.07–0.14 mg/kg), and three baby milk samples (A, C, D) had individual cadmium Target Hazard Quotients above 1.0; the source text also states that sample C had chromium THQ above 1.0, although Table 3 does not print a chromium (Cr) THQ column. Aggregate Cd Hazard Index across all 20 samples reached 15.55, which authors flag as indicating non-carcinogenic chronic-risk concern. Compared with baby milk, cereal-based formulae were lower for lead (Pb), Cd, and Cr and higher for Cu; Ni is source-internally inconsistent because Table 2 sample I lists 0.26 mg/kg while the abstract reports 0.003–0.040 mg/kg.

Key numbers

Instrument: Perkin Elmer Analyst Model 400 atomic absorption spectrometer; aqua regia digestion (HCl:HNO3 3:1), 90 °C for 2 h, dilution to 100 mL. Heavy metal concentrations in mg/kg (no wet-vs-dry basis explicitly stated; powdered/dry products as sold).

WHO (2023) limits cited by authors for comparison: Pb 0.03 mg/kg, Ni 0.07 mg/kg, Cu 0.7 mg/kg, Cd 0.2 mg/kg, Cr 0.3 mg/kg.

Baby Milk (n=8) heavy metal ranges and per-sample values (Table 2, mg/kg):

  • Pb: 0.07–0.140 (sample G lowest 0.07; sample H highest 0.140). All 8 samples exceeded the WHO limit (0.03 mg/kg).
  • Ni: 0.030–0.260 (sample D lowest 0.030; sample H highest 0.260). 5 of 8 samples (B, E, F, G, H) exceeded WHO limit (0.07 mg/kg).
  • Cu: 0.060–0.310 (sample G lowest 0.060; sample B highest 0.310). All samples below WHO limit (0.7 mg/kg).
  • Cd: 0.010–0.210 (samples A, E lowest 0.010; sample C highest 0.210). One sample (C) exceeded WHO limit (0.2 mg/kg).
  • Cr: 0.000–0.210 (samples E, F, G, H = 0.000; sample C highest 0.210). All samples were below the WHO limit (0.3 mg/kg).
  • Heavy metal ranking in Baby Milk: Pb > Cu > Ni > Cd > Cr (per paper text; reflects mean concentrations).

Infant Formula (n=12) heavy metal ranges and per-sample values (Table 2, mg/kg):

  • Pb: 0.000–0.015 (sample J highest 0.015). All samples below WHO limit (0.03 mg/kg).
  • Ni: 0.003–0.040 per abstract; Table 2 lists sample I = 0.26 mg/kg, an outlier inconsistent with the abstract-reported range and likely a typesetting error (0.026 vs 0.26). This page uses the abstract range and treats 0.26 mg/kg as a likely typesetting of 0.026 mg/kg.
  • Cu: 0.010–0.830 (Table 2 minimum sample I 0.010; sample M highest 0.830). Sample M exceeded WHO limit (0.7 mg/kg).
  • Cd: 0.006–0.043 (sample I lowest 0.006; sample O highest 0.043). All below WHO limit (0.2 mg/kg).
  • Cr: 0.000–0.010 (Table 2 maximum sample T 0.010; abstract reports 0.000–0.006). All below WHO limit (0.3 mg/kg).
  • Heavy metal ranking in Infant Formula: Cu > Cd > Ni > Cr > Pb (per paper text).

Risk assessment (Target Hazard Quotient and Hazard Index; assumed infant body weight 5 kg, daily intake DIV = 0.1 kg/day; USEPA IRIS RfD values cited: Cd 0.001, Cr 0.003, Pb 0.0035 mg/kg/day; THQ = DIV × Cm / (RfD × B)):

  • THQ > 1 in Baby Milk for Cd: samples A (THQ 2.2), C (4.2), D (1.6) per Table 3 — these are the samples the authors flag as risk-bearing for cadmium.
  • THQ > 1 in Baby Milk for Cr: sample C only, per paper text page 11 (“that of chromium was only in sample C”). Table 3 does not include a Cr THQ column (columns shown: Pb, Ni, Cu, Cd, HI), so no per-sample Cr THQ numeric is tabulated. Computed from Table 2: Cr THQ for sample C = 0.1 × 0.210 / (0.003 × 5) = 1.4.
  • THQ > 1 in Baby Milk for Pb: Table 3 lists per-sample Pb THQ values of 457, 514, 57, 629, 514, 457, 4, 8 for samples A–H, but these are inconsistent with both the paper text (“only cadmium and chromium…posed health risk in some Baby Milk samples”) and with the Pb Hazard Index of 4.277 reported in Table 4. The values are most plausibly decimal-point typesetting errors. Read that way, the printed lead THQs correspond to about 0.07 to 0.629. The stated formula is THQ = 0.1 × Pb (mg/kg) / (0.0035 × 5), which is Pb × 5.71. At 0.08 mg/kg lead, that formula gives a THQ of 0.46, not 457.
  • All THQ values <1 across all metals in Infant Formula.

Hazard Index (sum of per-metal THQ across all 20 BM + IF samples; Table 4):

  • Pb HI = 4.277 — flagged “no” potential health effect (the sample-level HI is within tolerance even though some BM samples carry elevated Pb).
  • Cu HI = 2.63 — “no” effect flag.
  • Cd HI = 15.55 — flagged “yes” potential health effect (HI > 10 indicates possible chronic-health concern per the framework the authors apply).
  • Cr HI = 3.13 — “no” effect flag.

Proximate composition (Table 1, % w/w):

  • Baby Milk: moisture 3.24–6.56, ash 2.42–3.17, fibre 0.00 (not detected in any BM sample), fat 11.32–28.68, protein 11.52–16.20, carbohydrate 50.52–72.92.
  • Infant Formula: moisture 7.89–9.29, ash 1.35–2.99, fibre 0.19–6.49, fat 0.47–9.75, protein 2.92–20.88, carbohydrate 52.21–84.91.

Macro-mineral composition (Figures 2 and 3, mg/kg):

  • Baby Milk: Ca 1391.40–1561.85 (sample A lowest, sample C highest); Mg 1200.00–1420.21; K 400.24–1340.26; P 889.90–1987.80; Na 250.00–699.33. Paper’s abstract reports macro-mineral ranking as P > Ca > Mg > K > Na, which does not match the per-sample numerical values. Ca > Mg > P > K > Na is the rank the table values support for most samples.
  • Infant Formula: Ca 165.67–699.33 (sample Q lowest, sample M highest); Mg 161.67–699.00; abstract reports ranking Mg > Ca > K > P > Na.

Micro-mineral composition (Figures 4 and 5, mg/kg):

  • Both samples ranked Fe > Zn > Mn.
  • Baby Milk: Fe 30.00–42.01 (none meet authors’ cited WHO “recommendation” of 425.5 mg/kg for iron — this WHO number appears to be a recommended daily intake/serving figure, not a concentration limit); Zn 2.80–24.03 (below cited 99.4 mg/kg WHO target); Mn 0.19–1.24 (only sample C at 0.674 mg/kg met the cited 0.5 mg/kg WHO Mn target).
  • Infant Formula: Fe 2.2–14.8; Zn 1.38–6.87; Mn 0.153–2.430 (samples R 0.500, M 1.44, N 2.430, S 1.153, T 2.04 met the 0.5 mg/kg cited target).

Methods (brief)

Cross-sectional market survey in Umuahia metropolis (Umuahia North Local Government Area), Abia State, Nigeria. One container per brand purchased from multiple shops over 3 months at monthly intervals. Brands selected at random by availability across shops. Proximate analysis by AOAC methods (Soxhlet for fat, Kjeldahl for protein, gravimetric for moisture/ash/fibre, by-difference for carbohydrate). Macro-minerals by EDTA complexiometric titration (Ca, Mg) and flame photometry (Na, K, Digital flame photometer ME-881); phosphorus by molybdo-vanadate spectrophotometry. Heavy metals by Atomic Absorption Spectrometry (Perkin Elmer Analyst Model 400) after aqua regia (3:1 HCl:HNO3) digestion at 90 °C for 2 h. Statistical analysis by ANOVA with Duncan multiple range test at 95% confidence (SPSS 22.0).

Limitations: no LOD/LOQ values reported. No speciation: chromium reported as total only (not Cr-VI); arsenic and mercury were not measured (key infant-formula contaminants absent from the analyte panel). Risk assessment uses a blanket 5 kg body weight assumption with no age stratification; for the WHO “infant” category (0–12 months) actual body weight ranges from ~3 to ~10 kg, which materially affects per-sample THQ. The “two years before shelf-life expiration” purchase timing means measured concentrations reflect product as it will be consumed near end-of-shelf-life, which is conservative for stability but introduces a confound for any storage-driven contamination (e.g. Pb leaching from packaging). The cereal-based products labelled “Infant Formula” in this paper are functionally infant cereals / cereal-based complementary foods, not the powdered cow-milk-derived infant formula that the international literature typically denotes by that term — readers should interpret the IF results in that context.

Implications

Certification: Lead in baby milk (powdered, milk-based) is the standout finding — all 8 samples exceeded the WHO 0.03 mg/kg limit, with the highest at 0.14 mg/kg (140 µg/kg). Cereal-based products (the paper’s “Infant Formula” category, which are functionally infant cereals) were uniformly below the Pb limit. Aggregate cadmium Hazard Index of 15.55 across the combined 20 samples suggests cumulative Cd exposure could be a chronic-risk consideration for infants consuming locally produced products in this region. The study is a Nigerian-market sample (n=20 total, single metropolis) with no analytical-method LODs reported and a blanket 5 kg infant BW; the data are qualitatively useful as a developing-country-market signal for Pb in milk-based infant products and for Cd as a cumulative exposure factor, but the small sample size, single-region scope, and missing arsenic/mercury panel limit quantitative use.

Courses: Useful as a case study for how a small market survey in a developing-country context produces THQ values for Pb that, even at relatively modest absolute concentrations (70–140 µg/kg), translate into sample-level Hazard Quotients that aggregate into the same order of magnitude as the cadmium HI when the very low Pb reference dose (0.0035 mg/kg/day) is applied. Demonstrates the gap between concentration-based regulatory limits and risk-based dose calculations.

App: Not suitable as primary input for contamination_profile synthesis on infant-formula or infant-cereal ingredient pages — small n, single-region, no LODs, no arsenic or mercury panel, no speciation. Useful as one of several developing-country corroborating sources for Pb in locally produced powdered milk-based infant products in Nigeria/West Africa.

Update history

No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.