Skip to content
Heavy Metal Index

Assessment of exposure to nickel intake with selected cereal grains and cereal-based products

Overview

Mania et al. (2020) measured nickel in 56 cereal-grain and cereal-based product samples from the Polish retail market in 2019-2020. The study used graphite furnace atomic absorption spectrometry (GFAAS) after microwave acid digestion and compared estimated dietary exposure with the EFSA 2020 tolerable daily intake of 13 ug nickel (Ni)/kg body weight per day. It is a primary Polish-market occurrence source for Ni in non-rice grains, pasta, flour, groats, flakes, and bran.

Key numbers

Concentrations are reported in mg/kg on an as-purchased product basis. The authors used middle-bound (MB) substitution for the main summary after 27% of analytical results fell below the food-matrix LOQ of 0.06 mg/kg.

CategorynMean (MB) mg/kgP95 (MB) mg/kgSD (MB)
Cereal grains (millet, rye, wheat, barley)51.163.912.04
Pasta110.261.040.52
Flour130.351.350.58
Groats120.631.720.67
Flakes100.931.970.66
Bran51.341.760.36
All grain-based products510.611.840.66
Cereal grains and grain-based products, all samples560.661.930.85

Individual and subgroup values reported in the text:

  • Cereal-grain Ni ranged from 0.10 mg/kg for rye to 4.80 mg/kg for millet.
  • Roasted buckwheat had 1.81 mg/kg Ni.
  • Oat flakes had 2.53 mg/kg Ni.
  • Whole-grain pasta ranged from 0.20 to 1.79 mg/kg; regular pasta made from wheat flour ranged from 0.03 to 0.08 mg/kg.
  • Whole-grain flour ranged from 0.23 to 2.12 mg/kg; wheat flour was below LOQ; spelt flour ranged from 0.14 to 0.18 mg/kg.
  • EFSA 2020 occurrence data cited by the authors reported grains and grain-based products at mean LB-UB 0.31-0.33 mg/kg and P95 1.25 mg/kg.

Exposure estimates as percent of EFSA’s 13 ug Ni/kg bw/day TDI:

Exposure scenarioPopulationPercent of TDI
WHO GEMS/Food cereal-grain consumption, excluding rice, at mean MB contaminationAdults13.4%
Average cereal-product consumption, excluding bread, rice, and bakery products, at mean MB contaminationAdults1.1%
Average cereal-product consumption, excluding bread, rice, and bakery products, at mean MB contaminationChildren3.9%
Same cereal-product scenario at P95 contaminationAdults3.4%
Same cereal-product scenario at P95 contaminationChildren11.8%
Pasta-only exposure at mean MB contaminationAdultsbelow 0.5%
Pasta-only exposure at mean MB contaminationChildren1.3%

Methods

The study used 56 samples from the Polish market: 5 grain samples and 51 grain-product samples. Product groups were pasta (n=11), flours (n=13), groats (n=12), flakes (n=10), bran (n=5), and grains including wheat, rye, barley, and millet.

Nickel was measured with an accredited in-house GFAAS method using Zeeman background correction after microwave closed-vessel digestion. Approximately 0.5 g of sample was digested with 5 mL concentrated nitric acid and 1 mL hydrogen peroxide. The method was validated with NIST SRM 1515 Apple Leaves, which had a certified Ni mass fraction of 0.936 +/- 0.094 mg/kg.

Method performance reported by the authors:

ParameterValue
In-solution LOD0.95 ug/L
In-solution LOQ1.25 ug/L
Food-matrix LOQ used for censoring0.06 mg/kg
RepeatabilityRSDr 7%
Relative error3.4%
Recovery97%
Expanded uncertainty24%
Calibration rangeLOQ to 25.0 ug/L

The authors used EFSA’s substitution method for left-censored data: lower bound = 0, middle bound = half the LOQ, and upper bound = LOQ. Exposure estimates used Polish Central Statistical Office consumption data and WHO GEMS/Food Consumption Cluster Diets.

Speciation and methods caveats

  • Nickel is reported as total Ni; no nickel species are distinguished.
  • The study measured only Ni. Mentions of lead (Pb), cadmium (Cd), pesticides, herbicides, and other contaminants in the introduction are contextual and should not be routed as measured analytes from this source.
  • The exposure estimates exclude bread, rice, and bakery products in the cereal-product scenario; do not generalize those percentages to total grain intake.

Implications

Standards work: The study is useful for nickel monitoring in non-rice cereal ingredients and grain-based products, especially where whole-grain, bran, oat, millet, or buckwheat components are present. It also documents that, at the time of publication, EU food law did not set general maximum levels for nickel in foodstuffs apart from food-additive specifications, while EFSA had identified grains and grain-based products as important dietary contributors.

Courses: The study is a clean teaching example of how processing fraction matters. Bran, flakes, and whole-grain products carried higher Ni than refined wheat flour and regular pasta.

App: Category means and P95 values can support Polish/EU context screens for Ni in cereal-grain products. They should be used as occurrence context, not as certification limits.

Update history

No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.