Overview
Si and colleagues at Beijing University of Chemical Technology survey recent advances in nanomaterial-based analytical methods for detecting trace heavy-metal ions in food samples. The review is organized into three method classes — electrochemical, colorimetric, and fluorescent — and emphasizes nanomaterial-enabled sensors (metal-organic frameworks, MXenes, carbon dots, gold nanoparticles, single-atom nanozymes) as alternatives to conventional ICP-MS, AAS, and GC-MS for rapid on-site screening. The review is shorter and more recent than Meng et al. 2023, and it adds colorimetric and fluorescent modalities that Meng does not cover.
Key numbers
The paper is a mini-review with no aggregate tables; representative sensor performance figures are quoted from primary studies in the body. The figures below are the LODs and matrices the review attributes to each cited sensor.
Electrochemical sensors (Section 2)
| Sensor / Reference | Analyte(s) | LOD | Matrix |
|---|---|---|---|
| Co-LTPA/GCE (Ma et al. 2024) | Cd(II), Pb(II) | 0.119 and 0.279 nM | Milk, honey, orange juice |
| MWCNTs + CeMOF (Dong et al. 2023) | Cd(II), Pb(II) | 2.2 and 0.64 ppb | Grain, water |
| UiO-66-NH₂ + carbon-based 3DGO (Huo et al. 2022) | Cd(II), Pb(II), Cu(II), Hg(II) | not stated by review | Rice, milk, honey |
| Co-MOF-NH₂/AuNPs/CPE (Pang et al. 2023) | Pb(II), Cd(II) | 7.0 × 10⁻² and 1.1 × 10⁻² ng·mL⁻¹ | Drinking water, juice, tea, grain, fruits, vegetables, liver, aquatic products |
| Ratiometric CDs / UiO-66-CNTs (Wang et al. 2024) | Pb(II), Hg(II) | not stated by review | Edible vegetables |
| ZIF-67@AMNFs (Zhang et al. 2023) | Cd(II), Pb(II), Hg(II) | 0.01, 0.042, 0.031 pM | Milk, honey, tea |
| NH₂-Ti₃C₂Tₓ MXene (Chen et al. 2023a) | Cd(II), Pb(II) | 0.41 and 0.31 µg·L⁻¹ | Rice, wheat, sorghum, corn |
| Melamine/MXene/rGO aerogel SPCE (Chen et al. 2023b) | Zn(II), Cd(II), Pb(II) | 0.48, 0.45, 0.29 µg·L⁻¹ | Sorghum, rice, wheat, corn |
| MXA-CuO/CC (Wen et al. 2022) | Cd(II), Pb(II) | not stated by review | Grain |
| UiO-66-NH₂ + MXene-rGO aerogel (Dong et al. 2024) | Cd(II), Pb(II) | “ultra-trace” (LOD not stated) | Grain, water |
| BCN-Nafion/GCE (Huang et al. 2023) | Cd(II), Pb(II) | not stated by review | Beta vulgaris var. cicla (leafy beet) |
Colorimetric sensors (Section 3)
| Sensor / Reference | Analyte(s) | LOD | Matrix |
|---|---|---|---|
| AuNPs (chloroauric-acid reduction; Hua et al. 2023) | Cu(II), Hg(II) | 3.5 and 0.1 nM | Drinking water |
| LGC-AuNPs (Bhattacharyya & Hossain 2024) | Zn(II), Hg(II) | “extremely low” (LOD not stated by review) | Drinking water |
| MSA-AuNPs (Komova et al. 2021) | Fe(III) | below WHO drinking-water limit | Drinking water |
| MPA-CeO₂ phosphatase mimic (Hu et al. 2024) | Hg(II) | 0.16 nM | Milk |
| SACe-N-C single-atom nanozyme (Song et al. 2022) | Fe(III), Cr(VI) | 34.72 and 93.65 ng·mL⁻¹ | Drinking water, spinach |
Fluorescence sensors (Section 4)
| Sensor / Reference | Analyte(s) | LOD | Matrix |
|---|---|---|---|
| GSH-CdS QDs (He et al. 2022) | Cu(II), Hg(II), Mg(II) | 0.22, 5.8, 1.6 ng·mL⁻¹ | Foods (unspecified) |
| GSH-CdTe QDs (Hu et al. 2023) | Cu(II) | 10.12 nM (linear range 20–1100 nM) | Hawthorn, American ginseng, honeysuckle |
| N-CQDs (Zou et al. 2022) | Hg(II) | 0.8 µM | Drinking water |
| N-BCDs (Zhang et al. 2023a) | Cr(VI) | not stated by review | Drinking water |
| N-CDs (Tan et al. 2022) | Cd(II), Hg(II) | 0.20 and 0.188 µM | Fruits, vegetables |
| NCDs + AuNCs three-channel array (Wang et al. 2022) | Cd(II), Pb(II), Hg(II) | 0.15, 0.20, 0.09 nM | Traditional Chinese medicine |
| Double-emitting CDs ratiometric (Lu et al. 2023) | Zn(II) | 5 nM | Milk powder, zinc gluconate oral solution |
Conclusions called out in the text
- The review explicitly distinguishes its in-scope methods from conventional reference methods (ICP-MS, AAS, GC-MS), which it describes as “complex to operate, requiring expensive and large analytical instruments” and not suitable for rapid screening (p. 2).
- The authors identify two open gaps: (1) sensitivity, selectivity, and anti-interference in complex food matrices need improvement — most cited sensors are validated in drinking water or simplified samples rather than real food; (2) sensors that can simultaneously detect multiple metals in food matrices are “relatively lacking” (p. 5).
- The future-prospects paragraph (Section 5) flags sensor arrays plus deep-learning algorithms as the most promising path to multi-metal high-throughput detection.
Methods (brief)
Narrative mini-review. Three method classes — electrochemical, colorimetric, and fluorescence — each given a single section organized around representative nanomaterial platforms and the heavy metals each platform has been validated against. No PRISMA-style protocol, study-quality scoring, or quantitative heterogeneity assessment is performed. The cited primary literature spans roughly 2021–2024 and is weighted toward Chinese institutions. Performance figures (LOD, linear range) are passed through from the primary studies as those authors reported them; the review does not re-validate any of them. Figures 1 and 2 reproduce schematic diagrams from four primary studies (Amali et al. 2021; Huang et al. 2023; Guo et al. 2014; Komova et al. 2021 for Fig. 1; Tan et al. 2022; Lu et al. 2023 for Fig. 2) and do not present new tabular data.
Implications
Certification (HMTc): A methods-landscape reference, not occurrence evidence. The review documents that several nanomaterial-based sensor configurations achieve LODs in the pM to ng·mL⁻¹ range for the HMTc analyte set (Pb, cadmium (Cd), total mercury (tHg), Cr-VI) in spiked or simplified food matrices, but explicitly flags that complex-food-matrix performance is the open validation gap. For HMTc auditor guidance the review is supporting evidence that the nanomaterial-sensor technique class can in principle approach regulatory limits; it is not a substitute for method-validation data in unspiked real food (full sample digestion, recovery testing against certified reference materials, head-to-head comparison with ICP-MS). No certification threshold should rest on this review alone.
Courses: A suitable backbone reading for a course module on emerging non-ICP detection platforms, particularly for brand QA, supply-chain, and regulatory-affairs audiences evaluating vendor claims about rapid or field-deployable sensors. The three-method organization (electrochemical / colorimetric / fluorescence) makes it a natural complement to Meng et al. 2023, which is restricted to electrochemical sensors but provides denser per-sensor coverage in that one modality.
App: Not applicable. The review does not produce ingredient-level contamination figures.
Microbiome: Not addressed.
Limitations
B-tier mini-review (Frontiers in Chemistry, CC BY 4.0). Coverage is restricted to nanomaterial-based sensors in three method classes; reference analytical platforms (ICP-MS, ICP-OES, AAS, AFS, XRF, GC-MS) are noted only as the high-instrumentation comparators in the introduction. Sample matrices in the cited primary studies are heavily weighted toward drinking water and spiked or simplified food matrices; unspiked real-food performance with full sample digestion is sparsely documented across the cited literature, a limitation the authors themselves flag in Section 5. The review reproduces LOD claims from primary studies without independent re-validation, and LOD claims in this literature class can be aspirational rather than operationally validated.
Related evidence
- Testing
- Lead
- Cadmium
- Mercury, Total
- Chromium, Hexavalent
- Copper
- Zinc
- Iron
- Rice
- Wheat
- Corn
- Milk and Dairy
- Honey
- Tea
- Water
- Fruit juice
- Leafy greens
- Fruit
- Vegetables
- The innovative and accurate detection of heavy metals in foods: A critical review on electrochemical sensors
Update history
No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.
