Skip to content
Heavy Metal Index

Mercury and Fatty Acids in Canned Tuna, Salmon, and Mackerel

Overview

This 2004 US study analyzed total mercury (tHg) and polyunsaturated fatty acids in canned tuna (n=240), salmon (n=16), and mackerel (n=16) purchased from stores in Lafayette, Indiana. Mercury was measured as total mercury (Hg) by thermal decomposition amalgamation atomic absorption spectrophotometry (TDA/AAS); the paper does not speciate methylmercury (MeHg) from inorganic Hg, but notes that up to 90% of Hg in fish is typically found as MeHg. Overall mean tHg was 188 ppb in tuna, 45 ppb in salmon, and 55 ppb in mackerel — all below the FDA action level of 1000 ppb. The paper’s central trade-off is that white/albacore tuna rows had higher tHg and higher EPA+DHA than light tuna in water, while salmon and mackerel had lower tHg and higher EPA+DHA than the tuna category average.

Key numbers

Total Hg and EPA+DHA in canned fish, aggregated by product form

Product groupTable rowstHg (ppb ww)EPA+DHA (mg/100 g wet tissue)
Light tuna in water348–63; mean 54213–339; mean 289
Light tuna in vegetable oil2174–191; mean 183174–190; mean 182
Light tuna in soy oil1340139
White/albacore tuna in water or pouch3227–330; mean 263886–931; mean 902
White/albacore tuna in soy oil1220239
Salmon220–70; mean 451489–1758; mean 1624
Mackerel250–61; mean 55500–1202; mean 851

Each tuna row in the source is the grand mean of duplicate analyses from 3 lots with 4 composites. Salmon and mackerel rows are duplicate analyses of 4 composites. Limit of detection for total Hg: 0.01 ng total Hg.

Summary by product category:

  • Overall tuna mean (n=240): 188 ppb tHg
  • Salmon mean (n=16): 45 ppb tHg
  • Mackerel mean (n=16): 55 ppb tHg
  • Light tuna in water was the lowest-tHg tuna group (mean 54 ppb).
  • White/albacore tuna in water or pouch had higher tHg (227–330 ppb) and higher EPA+DHA (mean 902 mg/100 g) than light tuna in water.

FDA action level for commercial fish under CPG 540.600: 1000 ppb methylmercury expressed as mercury in the edible portion. No sample exceeded this level.

EPA + DHA content by product type:

  • Light tuna in water: mean ~289 mg/100 g wet tissue (DHA 181–300; EPA 32–39)
  • White/albacore tuna in water: mean ~902 mg/100 g wet tissue (DHA 555–741; EPA 190–333) — highest EPA+DHA among tuna types
  • Salmon: mean ~1,623 mg/100 g wet tissue (DHA 564–874; EPA 884–925)
  • Mackerel: mean ~851 mg/100 g wet tissue (DHA 282–649; EPA 218–553)

Exposure estimate at current tuna consumption for a 60-kg woman:

  • At 95th percentile consumption (20 g/d): all tuna products below USEPA RfD of 0.1 µg MeHg/kg bw/day
  • At 99th percentile consumption (35 g/d): light tuna in oil and white/albacore tuna deliver 129–153% of RfD
  • Author-calculated fish-tissue concentration needed to stay below the RfD at 8 oz/wk (32.43 g/d): below 185 ppb
  • The authors concluded that the FDA action level should be reduced to 185 ppb or that products above this level should carry an appropriate warning. This is the source authors’ risk-management recommendation, not an HMT&C threshold.

Methods (brief)

Total mercury measured using Thermal Decomposition Gold Amalgamation Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometry (TDA/AAS, DMA-80 analyzer), calibrated against NRCC certified reference materials Tort-2 (0.270 ppm Hg) and Dorm-2 (4.64 ppm Hg). Two calibration ranges used: 0–35 ng Hg (R²=0.9929) and 30–470 ng Hg (R²=0.9958). LOD: 0.01 ng total Hg. Composite samples were prepared by pooling and grinding the entire contents of 2 cans from each lot. Fatty acids quantified by GC/FID using AOAC method 991.39 on lipids extracted by modified Folch method. SRM recovery for total fat: 95%. Standard deviation <±10% of mean for all mercury values (SD not shown). Mercury is reported as total Hg; no speciation of MeHg vs inorganic Hg performed, but authors note ~90% of Hg in fish is typically MeHg.

Implications

Certification: The substantial difference between light tuna in water (mean 54 ppb tHg) and white/albacore tuna in water/pouch rows (227–330 ppb tHg) provides a concrete example of how species/form descriptors within the canned-fish category determine mercury exposure. The source’s 185 ppb calculation is tied to a 60-kg woman consuming 8 oz/week and should be treated as source-side risk-context, not as a wiki or HMT&C threshold.

Courses: The mercury/omega-3 trade-off quantified here is a concrete teaching example: white/albacore tuna provides the highest EPA+DHA among tuna products but at ~4× the tHg of light tuna in water. Salmon and mackerel offer a better ratio (higher EPA+DHA at lower tHg).

App: Product-form-level tHg values (light tuna in water ~54 ppb, white/albacore tuna water/pouch rows 227–330 ppb, salmon ~45 ppb, mackerel ~55 ppb) are useful source inputs for canned-fish risk estimation. Use product-form and species descriptors rather than brand identity.

Update history

No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.