Overview
This MMWR surveillance report from the North Carolina Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention Program (NCCLPPP) describes seven years of environmental lead investigations in the homes of 61 children with confirmed elevated blood lead levels (BLLs), in which spices, herbal remedies, and ceremonial powders were sampled. Of 386 samples collected from 59 properties (6.0% of the 983 home lead investigations conducted in NC during January 2011–January 2018), 111 samples were contaminated with ≥1 mg/kg lead (Pb) — 28.8% of the full 386-sample set and 62.7% of the 177 samples that fell within the 50 product categories whose mean Pb was ≥1 mg/kg. Mean lead levels of ≥1 mg/kg were identified in 50 product categories — 40 food categories and 10 nonfood categories. Among edible items, turmeric had the highest average lead concentration (66.4 mg/kg, range 0.1–740 mg/kg, n=34); among nonfood items, traditional cosmetic and ceremonial powders (kumkum, sindoor, surma) reached percent-level lead concentrations, with sindoor averaging 41,401 mg/kg (range 0.1–130,000 mg/kg, n=8). The affected children were predominantly of Asian descent (67.2%), and 71% of the investigated properties were built after 1978, ruling out lead paint as the primary exposure source in most homes. The authors directly called for a national maximum allowable limit for lead in spices and herbal remedies, which did not exist at the time of publication.
Key numbers
Study scope:
- 983 home lead investigations conducted in North Carolina, January 2011–January 2018
- 59 properties (6.0% of 983) in 8 primarily urban counties had spice/herbal/ceremonial-powder sampling
- 61 children with confirmed elevated BLLs lived at these 59 properties
- 42 of 59 properties (71%) were built after 1978; in 32 of those 42 (76%) no lead was found in paint, dust, mini-blinds, faucets, bathtub glaze, or furniture finish; in 7 of those 32, spices/herbal remedies/ceremonial powders were the only identified risk
- 386 samples included in analysis (six excluded for different sampling/analysis methods): 344 food (89%), 42 nonfood (11%)
- 111/386 samples (28.8% of the full set; 62.7% of the 177 samples falling within the 50 mean-≥1 mg/kg categories) contained ≥1 mg/kg Pb; among nonfood, 35/42 (83.3%); among food, 76/344 (22.0%)
Blood lead levels in the 61 affected children:
- Average screening (initial) BLL: 17.0 µg/dL (SD 9.6)
- Average diagnostic (confirmatory) BLL: 15.2 µg/dL (SD 7.0)
- Average child age at investigation: 2.3 years (range 0.9–6.6 years)
- Diagnostic BLLs drawn February 28, 2011 – December 5, 2017
Lab method: Atomic absorption mass spectrometer screen at the NC State Laboratory of Public Health; samples <15 mg/kg Pb subsequently re-analyzed by ICP-MS (starting 2011). Below-LOD environmental sample values replaced with LOD/√2 (Croghan & Egeghy, 2003); below-LOD blood lead values standardized to 1 µg/dL.
Nonfood items — categories with average Pb ≥1 mg/kg (N=10 categories, 37 samples; Table):
| Category | n | Average Pb mg/kg (SD) | Range mg/kg |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ash powder | 1 | 19.0 (N/A) | N/A |
| Incense | 4 | 7.0 (6.6) | 1.9–15.7 |
| Kum kum (powder, social/religious markings, India) | 12 | 12,185.2 (40,276.5) | 0.4–140,000 |
| Pooja powder (Hindu religious worship) | 1 | 65.0 (N/A) | N/A |
| Rangoli (colored powders for designs) | 2 | 2.9 (1.8) | 1.6–4.2 |
| Sandal scented pooja powder | 2 | 4.2 (1.6) | 3.0–5.3 |
| Sandalwood (chandan) powder | 3 | 8.4 (9.2) | 3.0–19.0 |
| Sindoor (traditional red cosmetic powder) | 8 | 41,401.1 (58,540.7) | 0.1–130,000 |
| Surma (ground ore eye cosmetic) | 1 | 68,000 (N/A) | N/A |
| Vibhuti (ash applied to skin in religious rituals) | 3 | 80.3 (70.2) | 2.9–140.0 |
Food items — categories with average Pb ≥1 mg/kg (N=40 categories, 140 samples; Table):
Spices and condiments (N=26 categories):
| Category | n | Average Pb mg/kg (SD) | Range mg/kg |
|---|---|---|---|
| Anise | 4 | 1.7 (1.9) | 0.3–4.4 |
| Bay leaves | 1 | 2.6 (N/A) | N/A |
| Black seeds | 1 | 2.6 (N/A) | N/A |
| Cardamom | 1 | 1.4 (N/A) | N/A |
| Chaat masala | 1 | 1.5 (N/A) | N/A |
| Chili garlic sauce | 1 | 4.0 (N/A) | N/A |
| Chili powder / Red pepper | 23 | 12.6 (41.2) | 0.1–170.0 |
| Cinnamon | 2 | 2.6 (0.1) | 2.5–2.7 |
| Cloves | 1 | 1.4 (N/A) | N/A |
| Coriander | 9 | 4.8 (12.8) | 0.1–39.0 |
| Cumin | 17 | 1.1 (1.5) | 0.1–6.4 |
| Cumin and coriander mix | 2 | 1.1 (0.5) | 0.7–1.4 |
| Curry leaf powder | 1 | 1.4 (N/A) | N/A |
| Curry powder | 2 | 1.4 (1.7) | 0.2–2.6 |
| Dagad phool (stone flower) | 1 | 2.8 (N/A) | N/A |
| Fenugreek | 1 | 1.4 (N/A) | N/A |
| Ginger | 3 | 1.0 (0.5) | 0.7–1.6 |
| Lemon powder | 1 | 6.5 (N/A) | N/A |
| Kabsa spice | 1 | 19.0 (N/A) | N/A |
| Mint | 1 | 2.0 (N/A) | N/A |
| Rosemary | 1 | 1.6 (N/A) | N/A |
| Saffron | 2 | 1.2 (1.4) | 0.2–2.2 |
| Shwarma spice | 1 | 6.8 (N/A) | N/A |
| Spice mix (all purpose) | 3 | 1.8 (2.6) | 0.2–4.8 |
| Turmeric | 34 | 66.4 (206.6) | 0.1–740.0 |
| Vanilla | 1 | 8.5 (N/A) | N/A |
Medications, oils, and supplements:
| Category | n | Average Pb mg/kg (SD) | Range mg/kg |
|---|---|---|---|
| Balguti Kesaria (Ayurvedic medicine) | 1 | 220.0 (N/A) | N/A |
| Chamomile oil | 1 | 8.2 (N/A) | N/A |
| Herbal remedy | 1 | 8.2 (N/A) | N/A |
| Lime calcium powder | 1 | 1.4 (N/A) | 1.4 |
| Nux vomica | 1 | 10.6 (N/A) | N/A |
| Mojhat ceremonial drink | 1 | 31.0 (N/A) | N/A |
| Saffron supplement | 1 | 2,764.0 (N/A) | N/A |
Prepared foods and other food products:
| Category | n | Average Pb mg/kg (SD) | Range mg/kg |
|---|---|---|---|
| Candy | 5 | 10.6 (14.0) | 0.0–25.9 |
| Milk cookie | 1 | 1.4 (N/A) | N/A |
| Baby cereal | 2 | 17.6 (23.2) | 1.2–34.0 |
| Cornstarch | 2 | 5.4 (6.6) | 0.7–10.0 |
| Rice flour | 3 | 4.1 (5.7) | 0.1–10.6 |
| Rice with turmeric | 1 | 1.4 (N/A) | N/A |
| Sugar | 3 | 3.7 (6.0) | 0.1–10.6 |
Provenance metadata: Country of purchase was recorded for only 187/386 (48%) samples; of those with known origin, 142/187 (76%) were purchased in the United States. The remaining 199 samples have unknown provenance.
Demographics of the 61 affected children (race/ethnicity available for 58/61, 95%):
- Asian (including Indian and Pakistani descent): 41 children (67.2%)
- Black or African American (including two siblings born in West Africa): 9 children (13%)
- White (including one from Afghanistan): 8 children (≈14%)
- Hispanic ethnicity known for 51 children (84%); 7 of those (11.5%) Hispanic
Regulatory context cited by the report (at time of publication, November 2018):
- No US permissible limit for Pb in spices
- WHO Codex Standard 193–1995 permissible limit: 0.02 mg/kg Pb for infant formula; 2 mg/kg Pb for salt
- FDA limit for Pb in natural-source food color additives (e.g., paprika, saffron, turmeric): 10 mg/kg
- FDA action levels for products intended for consumption by children: 0.1 mg/kg for candy; 0.5 mg/kg for other foods; spices are not classified as food intended for children
- US spice imports increased ~50% since 1998 (>95% of US-consumed spices are imported)
Consumption-frequency context cited by the report:
- EPA What We Eat in America survey: 0.09 g/day cumin, 0.03 g/day turmeric (general US population)
- South Indian cooking pattern (Siruguri & Bhat 2015): 1.22 ± 1.14 g cumin per portion, 0.60 ± 0.46 g turmeric per portion, in dishes prepared daily
Methods (brief)
Retrospective cross-sectional case series. Lead investigators from state and local health departments conducted free home lead investigations for children with confirmed elevated BLLs (defined since July 1, 2017 as two consecutive results ≥5 µg/dL within 12 months; previously two consecutive ≥10 µg/dL within 6 months). Investigators collected information on home build year and documented evidence of lead in paint, water, soil, consumer products, and foods. Samples of lead paint, water, soil, consumer products, and foods (including spices, herbal remedies, and ceremonial powders) were submitted to the NC State Laboratory of Public Health for chemical analysis.
All spice, herbal-remedy, and ceremonial-powder samples were screened for lead by atomic absorption mass spectrometer at the NC State Laboratory of Public Health. Starting in 2011, samples with <15 mg/kg Pb on the AAS screen were subsequently re-analyzed by ICP-MS. Environmental-sample results below the limit of detection (LOD) were replaced with LOD/√2 (Croghan & Egeghy, 2003); blood-lead results below LOD were standardized to 1 µg/dL.
Investigation reports and environmental sample data were entered into the NC childhood lead surveillance system and linked to children’s blood lead test results. Because consumption-frequency information was not collected for most children, descriptive statistics were computed for environmental-sample results separately from blood-lead data; direct toxicologic modeling was not attempted.
This is a surveillance and case-series design, not a market-basket study: samples were collected from homes where children had already been identified with elevated BLLs, so reported concentrations represent a clinically-ascertained sample rather than a population-representative spice market.
Implications
Certification: US-government surveillance documentation of a quantified spice-lead pathway in real-world child health investigations: 28.8% of 386 spice / herbal / ceremonial-powder samples from homes of children with confirmed elevated BLLs were ≥1 mg/kg Pb, with turmeric reaching 740 mg/kg in a single sample and an average of 66.4 mg/kg across 34 samples. Within the food categories captured in this clinically-ascertained sample, chili powder/red pepper (n=23), coriander (n=9), cumin (n=17), and turmeric (n=34) are the categories with the largest within-source N and therefore the most weight-bearing food-category Pb distributions in this paper. The kumkum, sindoor, and surma percent-level Pb concentrations are nonfood ceremonial cosmetics, not directly applicable to food-row certification work, but they are the key documented pathway by which lead enters households as a result of accidental ingestion by children and contamination of household surfaces. The source itself argues that “setting a national maximum allowable limit for lead in spices and herbal remedies might further reduce the risk for lead exposure from these substances”; no numerical HMT&C threshold is proposed here.
Courses: Strong anchor case for the regulatory vacuum around spice lead contamination in 2018 (no US national limit; FDA action levels apply to candy and “other foods” but spices are not classified as food intended for children). Documents the cultural and demographic concentration of risk: 67.2% of affected children were of Asian descent, and many lived in post-1978 housing where lead paint was ruled out by investigation. Documents the failure mode of standard childhood lead risk assessment when the exposure pathway is dietary rather than environmental. The NCCLPPP survey tool developed for systematic spice/herbal-remedy exposure documentation (available in English and Spanish, piloted in one NC county, cultural-sensitivity tested in focus groups with Hispanic and South Asian community members) is a documented example of how to capture exposure data that standard environmental investigations miss.
App: Clinically-ascertained spice Pb distributions for turmeric (n=34, mean 66.4 mg/kg, range 0.1–740), chili powder/red pepper (n=23, mean 12.6 mg/kg, range 0.1–170), cumin (n=17, mean 1.1 mg/kg, range 0.1–6.4), coriander (n=9, mean 4.8 mg/kg, range 0.1–39), and cinnamon (n=2, mean 2.6 mg/kg, range 2.5–2.7). These are upper-tail distributions from homes of lead-exposed children, not population-representative market data; route into ingredient pages as exposure-tail context rather than as central tendency. Per-product-category contamination profiles for app surfacing should use this paper as evidence that high-Pb tails exist in turmeric and chili-powder/red-pepper categories at concentrations far above the FDA 10 mg/kg color-additive limit.
Microbiome: not addressed.
Limitations stated by the authors
The report explicitly notes five limitations: (1) spices are frequently purchased wholesale and decanted, so origin and lot-number metadata are often discarded; (2) many lead investigators did not collect spice/herbal-remedy samples — 11 reports were excluded from the numerator but not the denominator, so the prevalence of spice-related cases may be underestimated; (3) prior to recent policy changes, persons with BLLs 5–9 µg/dL were typically offered education only (no home investigation) unless local ordinance lowered the trigger, which may further underestimate cases; (4) even individually low Pb concentrations may produce elevated BLLs under chronic, combined exposure, but direct toxicologic modeling was not feasible given missing consumption data; (5) the small sample and broad age range (infants through age 6) make modeling exposure effects difficult because Pb metabolism and developmental sensitivity differ markedly between a 1-year-old and a 5-year-old.
Related evidence
Update history
No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.
