Skip to content
Heavy Metal Index
Spinach, kale, collard greens, romaine and iceberg lettuce illustrating ali2024 leek microbial metals iraq research context.

Contamination Alert: Microbial and Heavy Metal Levels in Green Vegetables

Overview

Ali measured microbial contamination (Escherichia coli, Klebsiella) and three heavy metals (Ni, Cu, Pb) in 100 leek samples and in soil at three agricultural stations in Thi-Qar governorate, southern Iraq, across winter and summer seasons. The study reports soil and leek-tissue concentrations separately, documents a seasonal pattern (higher concentrations in summer) and a spatial gradient (markets and district samples higher than city-center samples and farm samples), and links the elevated Station 2 metals to proximity to a thermal electric station, traffic emissions, and small industrial activity. This is a conference proceedings paper (Seminar Nasional & Call Paper, SENASAINS 7th, Universitas Muhammadiyah Sidoarjo, Procedia of Engineering and Life Science Vol. 7, 2024); B-tier.

Key numbers

Soil (µg/g dry weight; mean of three stations):

  • Winter: nickel (Ni) 94.99, Cu 44.82, lead (Pb) 20.68 (p. 712)
  • Summer: Ni 101.03, Cu 62.10, Pb 21.25 (p. 712)
  • Station 2 (near thermal station, traffic, small industry) had the highest concentrations in both seasons (p. 712)
  • Pb in soil reported as within the 100 µg/g dry-weight reference cited as “allowed concentration” by the author; Ni in soil exceeds 94 µg/g in both seasons (p. 712)

Leek tissue (µg/g dry weight):

  • Summer market sample (highest): Ni 28.41, Cu 22.08, Pb 6.73 (p. 713)
  • Winter farm sample (lowest): Ni 18.05, Cu 15.42, Pb 4.25 (p. 713)
  • Rank across sampling sources: market > restaurant > farmer in both seasons (p. 713)
  • Pb concentrations in leek exceeded the WHO permissible level of 5 µg/g dry weight in both seasons (p. 713)
  • Ni and Cu reported as below the stated permissible limit by the author

Microbial (% of samples positive):

  • E. coli, city-center markets: 29.51% positive; districts markets: 44.26% (p. 711, Table 1)
  • E. coli, city-center farms: 4.29%; districts farms: 11.48% (p. 711, Table 1)
  • E. coli, city-center restaurants: 3.28%; districts restaurants: 6.56% (p. 711, Table 1; X² = 82.40, df = 4, P = 0.00)
  • Klebsiella, city-center markets: 37.50%; districts markets: 40.63% (p. 712, Table 2)
  • Klebsiella, city-center farms: 3.13%; districts farms: 6.25% (p. 712, Table 2)
  • Klebsiella, city-center restaurants: 4.69%; districts restaurants: 7.81% (p. 712, Table 2; X² = 92.60, df = 4, P = 0.00)

Methods (brief)

Heavy metals: 1 g soil digested with 15 mL hydrochloric acid plus 5 mL nitric acid in a sand bath at 80 °C for 45–60 minutes; after cooling, an additional 5 mL HCl and 50 mL distilled water added; heated, filtered, diluted to 100 mL. Plant samples washed with distilled and deionized water, dried at room temperature, ground, sieved, and digested per method cited as [17] (Barman et al. 2000). Final extracts analyzed by flame atomic absorption spectrophotometry; specific instrument vendor and model not stated in text. LODs and LOQs not reported. Microbial: 1 g samples in peptone water, serial dilutions 10⁻¹ to 10⁻⁶ plated on MacConkey and EMB agar, incubated 37 °C for 24 h; phenotypic colony identification and VITEK 2 confirmation. Three stations sampled; plant samples taken with three replicates per station; sampling January–May.

Limitations

Conference proceedings, B-tier; no DOI assigned. The abstract and one discussion sentence refer to “zinc” as a measured analyte (the abstract attributes “28.41 ppm during the summer” to zinc), but the methods, results text, all four figures of metal data (Figs. 4–7), and the explicit numeric tuples in the body identify the three measured metals as Ni, Cu, and Pb — the 28.41 µg/g summer value is Ni in market-sourced leek tissue. This is treated here as a paper-internal labeling error rather than a fourth analyte; zinc is not represented in the metals source metadata. Analytical instrument vendor/model not specified. LOD/LOQ not stated. Numeric leek-tissue results are reported only as min/max tuples in the text plus three small bar charts (Figs. 6 and 7); per-station means by source-type are not tabulated and cannot be recovered from the figures with the precision needed for occurrence-distribution work. The “allowed concentration” of 100 µg/g for soil and 5 µg/g for leek Pb are stated by the author with reference to WHO but without specific citation. The city-center farmer E. coli rate is printed as 4.29% in Table 1 (3 positive of 8 samples) but as 4.92% in the corresponding bar in Figure 2 (p. 711); the table value (4.29%) is used here as the authoritative tabulation. Iraq, single-governorate, single-Allium-crop scope.

Implications

Direct evidence for Pb, Ni, and Cu occurrence in leek (an Allium leafy vegetable) grown near industrial point sources in southern Iraq; Pb in leek tissue exceeded the WHO 5 µg/g reference in both seasons across all three sampling-source types (market, farm, restaurant). The seasonal pattern (summer > winter) and the spatial gradient (Station 2 near thermal station > Stations 1 and 3) contribute geographic-variance context for Leafy greens in MENA-region market gardening systems. Microbial findings are out of scope for the heavy-metals wiki but are noted in the source page for completeness.

  • supply-chain/soil

Update history

No substantive edit history is available in this build. The full commit record is available in git.